Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread 6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread

06-26-2017 , 01:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
But he's already smoking it, & as such has already chosen it, so are you asking him to manufacture a story?

This could easily be W/W. Or W/V. Or V/W. Or V/V.

I find nothing inherently wolfy in anyone's posts so far. So GJGE everyone.
wolf
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iraisetoomuch
I've seen maybe 1 episode.

NGL seems fine so far.
JM3 obv villa.

Donnie seems rand atm.
I'm clearly a villa.

Everyone else hasn't made a strong impression yet.
Given your track record with these types of statements, I feel like we should almost always vote the opposite of your strongest reads
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:36 PM
2 greens in a game are annoying with avatars turned off
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Donat3llo
So the above post from NGL, which is in response to the bolded form IRTM, is defensive and seems to make some assumptions and run with them. The bold part of NGL's post seems to rub me the wrong way, though not sure why (the pointing it out part of it, not the content)

That being said, I'm not sure if it is anything to go on or a case of me looking for something that isn't really there.
I noticed that, too, & it again reminded me of his posting last game. Seemed indicative of a lack of self-awareness if villager, & forced bombaticness if wolf.

Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
hello my friends, sorry for the late entrance. happy to be villaging.
I assume you're busy doing some villagery analysis of the thread thus far then?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Donat3llo
zorkman's MQ looks like it is an attempt at trying to make a case for voting jm3, but not sure if the case actually gets made. Not that I'm against making a case for jm3 being wolfy, but quantity:quality content ratio isn't quite there.

zorkman
I don't think there is a case for me being wolfy, but I'm always happy to listen to them, as they can hopefully tell me about people's motives.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
<3
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
wolf
I was going to say hi, but now I don't even want to haha.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:38 PM
irtm, do you usually play ww on a computer, ipad or phone?
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisV
Legit didn't even notice that before replying.

Like I said, pretty blasted.

I wonder if Zorkman is any better at ww than he is at politics.
bolded is weird. 'legit' is affirming your own honesty on something you wouldn't lie about, so it pinges me on the mindset you had writing that. 'like I said, pretty blasted' is an excuse, and an unnecessary one for that matter.

I like Jmurder3 posts, for the better part. The NGL reasoning is pointing at something other than the thread. I remember doing that kind of stuff in my wolf games.

No Lynches appears again:

Quote:
Originally Posted by No Lynches
Probably the case for most, yeah.

The post above is alright. Definitely not your typical ball-rolling post, particularly given the angle, which is NAI and easily refuted but perhaps just posted to get some discussion on some topic.
"the post is alright...". doesn't seem concerned with figuring out JMurder's role. excessively explanation, which to me also falls under the 'excuse' category of how wolves behave.

What follows is, a joke post, a second joke post, and an awkward read.

I did enjoy JM and NL interaction, despite some of what I perceive to be wolfiness from NL early on.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Donat3llo
Given your track record with these types of statements, I feel like we should almost always vote the opposite of your strongest reads
Not sure what to make of this post. It seems kinda weird in a vacuum.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
2 greens in a game are annoying with avatars turned off
Infracted.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
irtm, do you usually play ww on a computer, ipad or phone?
Normally computer, but sometimes phone.

Why?
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Myrologue
haven't played in a while. and wonder if it's wrong to like notgonnalie's first post. maybe it's a combination of him suggesting he's new and him being too open. lot of new villagers get cold feet.
myrologue
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iraisetoomuch
Not sure what to make of this post. It seems kinda weird in a vacuum.



Infracted.



Normally computer, but sometimes phone.

Why?
cause you're obviously phone posting to start the game, and obviously you're away from home so you're more likely to be on a phone than on a computer but posting on a phone to start the game and doing so semi-actively is a good look imo.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotGonnaLie
i finally rolled villager in a forum game and got a pretty badass persona to boot.

ill admit i was conscious of not wanting to post right at the start of day since it got me scum read last game, but id do that as either alignment. what kind of town wants to get lynched?
so you purposefully avoided the thread at SOD? were you scum the last game by any chance?
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
I don't think there is a case for me being wolfy, but I'm always happy to listen to them, as they can hopefully tell me about people's motives..
With regards to zorkman's post, it doesn't really matter if you think there is or there isn't, it's about what he thinks. And it seems like they wanted to say your wolfy, and added a bunch of words that look like a case, but it's surface level at best.

Feels like one of my own leaks as a wolf, so I see it in others. Maybe that's bad though
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:48 PM
Forced bombasticness is a fine way to describe my style day 1. I'm trying to generate reads by bouncing off of people.

I don't care much for projecting obvtown, because the level i generally operate from i expect mafia to be doing that day 1 at least. Town needs to generate info and its easier to do that by acting slightly scummy.

zorkman's posts felt like he was trying to pocket me, but i am in agreement with him that jmurder3 isn't as towny as some people are reading him. I don't know his personal style, but his posts seem very polished and confident which I tend to associate with wolves this early, but its the sort of thing that would be informed by personal meta.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
2 greens in a game are annoying with avatars turned off
I was thinking of making a gimmick account for WW games, but I would need to talk to my avatar guy about what other things he can make a J murder in gif format (not that you would read it).

Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
I like Jmurder3 posts, for the better part. The NGL reasoning is pointing at something other than the thread. I remember doing that kind of stuff in my wolf games.
There was nothing in the thread, but I do agree that some people use that sort of stuff for fake work in putting on a case later...& other people like Xkf do a complex analysis of all previous posting of people & make definitive statements regarding the shape of posts & things.

Quote:
Originally Posted by iraisetoomuch
Not sure what to make of this post. It seems kinda weird in a vacuum.
It made me wonder if there was some sort of additional history there.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iraisetoomuch
Not sure what to make of this post. It seems kinda weird in a vacuum.
I'm breaking your balls, which i can now do more freely as a villa.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zorkman
After researching all game statistics on both sites, I have determined an interesting tidbit:

78% of those casting the first vote on me in a game (turbos included) end up being wolves.

That's triple the confidence I have in myro being a wolf, given that I know 3 of the 11 of you must be wolves (NGL and I being excepted as the other 2 who are known villagers).
if you could post less that would be great
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotGonnaLie
Forced bombasticness is a fine way to describe my style day 1. I'm trying to generate reads by bouncing off of people.

I don't care much for projecting obvtown, because the level i generally operate from i expect mafia to be doing that day 1 at least. Town needs to generate info and its easier to do that by acting slightly scummy.

zorkman's posts felt like he was trying to pocket me, but i am in agreement with him that jmurder3 isn't as towny as some people are reading him. I don't know his personal style, but his posts seem very polished and confident which I tend to associate with wolves this early, but its the sort of thing that would be informed by personal meta.
I like this post and isn't something you did as a wolf last game.

Feeling those villa vibes from NGL this game

I've been a fan of Robik's entrance and presence in the thread so far

Going to be a good game boys and girls!!
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
so you purposefully avoided the thread at SOD? were you scum the last game by any chance?
jesus christ. i'm west coast. the thread opened at 5 am. last game when i was a wolf i posted shortly after thread open, and got scum read for it.

before this game started i did think about whether or not i should post so early. I decided it didnt matter and I'd post when i felt like it. I didn't feel like it when i half woke up super early. later after a cup of coffee i posted.

I was impressed by some of the logic people brought to the game last time around, but the amount of credence you put into something as silly as when someone posts seems asinine to me.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Donat3llo
With regards to zorkman's post, it doesn't really matter if you think there is or there isn't, it's about what he thinks. And it seems like they wanted to say your wolfy, and added a bunch of words that look like a case, but it's surface level at best.

Feels like one of my own leaks as a wolf, so I see it in others. Maybe that's bad though
I wasn't referring to your read, I was referring to the part about not objecting to people calling me wolfy. I liked your thought process on Zork, though, even if I don't necessarily think he's a wolf because that was an odd retraction to me if he was, & have tended to like your thought processes a lot this game, which is why for once I don't have the initial instinct to think you're a wolf.

Quote:
Originally Posted by NotGonnaLie
Forced bombasticness is a fine way to describe my style day 1. I'm trying to generate reads by bouncing off of people.

I don't care much for projecting obvtown, because the level i generally operate from i expect mafia to be doing that day 1 at least. Town needs to generate info and its easier to do that by acting slightly scummy.

zorkman's posts felt like he was trying to pocket me, but i am in agreement with him that jmurder3 isn't as towny as some people are reading him. I don't know his personal style, but his posts seem very polished and confident which I tend to associate with wolves this early, but its the sort of thing that would be informed by personal meta.
I'm an attorney. I'm polished & confident with the English language. I am very not confident in my ability to find wolves, though, as I've only played a few games, & I tend to think that the wrong things are wolfy.

So the best thing I can do is engage people in conversation & try to help those better at this than me to make an informed decision.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:57 PM
NGL too defensive
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 01:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotGonnaLie
jesus christ. i'm west coast. the thread opened at 5 am. last game when i was a wolf i posted shortly after thread open, and got scum read for it.

before this game started i did think about whether or not i should post so early. I decided it didnt matter and I'd post when i felt like it. I didn't feel like it when i half woke up super early. later after a cup of coffee i posted.

I was impressed by some of the logic people brought to the game last time around, but the amount of credence you put into something as silly as when someone posts seems asinine to me.
To me, the eager beaver read was pretty much a one-time, first game thing. From now on it's just going to be a levels game if we try to use it, meaning it's not going to be super reliable.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 02:01 PM
Votes from post 4 to post 145
Night in 5:59:57

---
VotesLynchVoters
2 Zorkman Myrologue (10), Donat3llo (22)
2 Myrologue Zorkman (6), IAmRobik (8)
1 t.ossenblok JMurder3 (36)
1 No Lynches NotGonnaLie (15)
7 not voting ChrisV (4), hardcoreUFO (3), iraisetoomuch (15), killer_kill (0), No Lynches (16), Sun Tzu (0), t.ossenblok (0)
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 02:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotGonnaLie
jesus christ. i'm west coast. the thread opened at 5 am. last game when i was a wolf i posted shortly after thread open, and got scum read for it.

before this game started i did think about whether or not i should post so early. I decided it didnt matter and I'd post when i felt like it. I didn't feel like it when i half woke up super early. later after a cup of coffee i posted.

I was impressed by some of the logic people brought to the game last time around, but the amount of credence you put into something as silly as when someone posts seems asinine to me.
ok first of all, you sound angry. most of your posts don't read me as someone having any fun doing this.

Since you speak of 'town' and 'scum', I know you come from a different website. Maybe boardgamegeek. I played on BGG once and got mislynched d2 when I was the only one with the good reads in the game. If you played here and got mislynched last game, that's just you being low hanging fruit on a different website. wolves will look at your post and find an opportunity, while villagers will find you wolfy and confusing.

You still haven't answered me if you were a wolf or a villager last game. It matters to me because if you were a villager and got ML, this time you can actually bank on that as a wolf and act the way you're acting. If you were a wolf, the brazeness if a lot more villagery.
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 02:02 PM
Unsure what to think of jm3 saying he agrees with my thought process on zorkman. While I think it makes sense, I can't remember the last time jm3 actually agreed with me, lol
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 02:03 PM
pretty sure that people have already said that he was a wolf last game
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote
06-26-2017 , 02:03 PM
@hardcoreUFO, he wolfed with me last game
6/26 Game of Thrones vanilla WW game thread Quote

      
m