2/16 Cupcakes and Lollipops Vanilla Slow Game Thread

[well named]

I agree with that entirely.

[EADGBE]

Caedus Maximus Aurelius






_35/60

[well named]

caedus

[globetrotter]

i've not been wolfy at all

[globetrotter]

caedus/moocher --> someone not me

imo

[well named]

The thing that kind of stuck with me a little bit when I was thinking about it last night was just that you did a lot of re-reading but haven't really offered any conclusions

And then I realized it was sort of silly because I've offered lots of conclusions, except I change my mind about what they are every time I re-read.

But still, it felt kind of wolfy

and partly it's just that moocher and mccarty both seem villagery in some ways and also different from past wolf games, whereas I can think of at least one neutral SK game where your style was not substantially different

It's harder for me to clear you. And I also realized it was probably a bad idea to clear anyone just for interactions with wolves

[EADGBE]

Originally Posted by globetrotter

i've not been wolfy at all

you came in with all these huge long rambling MQ's to start

which reminded me of myself when i wolf

cus i make my wolfy little plans like "ok im gunna go in tomorrow and make a buncha MQs so it looks like im villaging hard"

and it was one of those spots where a wolf would def want to look like hes putting in a ton of work.

unfair maybe if youre a villager, but i think it applies.

_36/60

[globetrotter]

I just offered my conclusions. Didn't do it before b/c I planned to reread all of you one more time, but that's not going to happen today.

Here are some more:

Moocher

• I agree with eadgbe's case on him. Moocher's posts about anarchist D1 and his other votes are sketchy.
• He pushed monte, but a lot of people suspected monte and he may have just been trying to get out ahead of that wagon (especialy since monte seemed not to have a lot of time to post).
• If he's the wolf it explains why neither he or I was ever nk'd and would have made it easier for anarchist to eliminate possible seers and single out toasters.
• I feel like he really cherry-picked his case on me.

Caedus

• Hasn't been real active, but he he's pushed a lot of wolves.
• Otoh, he has managed repeatedly to not actually vote wolves at eod.
• If he's the wolf it explains why he was never nk'd despite having correct reads and (according to WN) good seer cover.

Well Named

• If he's the wolf, it also explains why I was never nk'd and would have helped anarchist narrow down the seer to toasters (Moocher and I both peeked WN villa).
• His eod1 is wolfy (almost too wolfy to be a wolf).
• But there is villagery stuff too.

crmccarty

• Just wolfy in general, but he's playing differently than he did as a wolf.
• Pushed monte pretty hard.
• Has some villagery stuff too.
• I don't believe him that he said he was leaving me as a villa peek in that aao conversation.

I just hope caedus is the wolf b/c I want this to end...




btw, to say I could be a wolf b/c I've played SK like this before is
I made it to the end of that game b/c I was killing wolves during ITAs...

[globetrotter]

Originally Posted by EADGBE

you came in with all these huge long rambling MQ's to start

which reminded me of myself when i wolf

cus i make my wolfy little plans like "ok im gunna go in tomorrow and make a buncha MQs so it looks like im villaging hard"

and it was one of those spots where a wolf would def want to look like hes putting in a ton of work.

unfair maybe if youre a villager, but i think it applies.

_36/60

too villagery to be a villager?

i'm cool w/ getting lynched for that

[aao]

globetrotter

[iversonian]

Votes as of post 2124
Night in 05:44
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
2	Caedus	EADGBE (36), well named (33)
1	crmccarty	Caedus (8)
4	not voting	aao (14), crmccarty (17), globetrotter (13), The Moocher (32)

[iversonian]

Nice xpost.

Votes as of post 2125
Night in 05:44
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
2	Caedus	EADGBE (36), well named (33)
1	crmccarty	Caedus (8)
1	globetrotter	aao (15)
3	not voting	crmccarty (17), globetrotter (13), The Moocher (32)

[aao]

I've been waiting all day to snipe my vote in there.

[globetrotter]

Originally Posted by aao

I've been waiting all day to snipe my vote in there.

Was it everything you dreamed it could be?

[well named]

I feel like every single time I've ever been in this spot the person I was pretty sure I wanted to lynch first was not the wolf

and yet I don't really see how to not vote caedus today. I have to clear 1 out of 4 players. I can sort of see at the end of the game wanting that one to be moocher, globe, or mccarty, I just can't quite decide yet who it should be

I can't really see ever clearing caedus

And yet somehow I doubt this is actually going to be this simple.