11/24 Sheep WW Vanilla+ Game Thread

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by crackedquads

If she won't post that means we should kill her first. Say for instance that loretta is a wolf also/instead of imp, if loretta the wolf is willing to spew for us for the nekt three days I'm completely fine with that.

And to be clear I think IMP is already more likely to be a wolf here than loretta. Add to the fact that IMP is going to be essentially useless in either role going forward, then she should die first IMO. Loretta being alive longer is more valuable to us no matter what his role, because as a villager he'll help us and as a wolf he will spew. IMP will do neither.

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by Anarchist

he thinks me saying that he should jump in wolfchat with me and filthy is not allowed

Lol?

Ana don't talk about this now, just meet me in wolfchat so we kan discuss it.

[Anarchist]

Originally Posted by crackedquads

And to be clear I think IMP is already more likely to be a wolf here than loretta. Add to the fact that IMP is going to be essentially useless in either role going forward, then she should die first IMO. Loretta being alive longer is more valuable to us no matter what his role, because as a villager he'll help us and as a wolf he will spew. IMP will do neither.

he won't help us because we can't listen to his advice. i guess if he flips villa we can going forward but i highly doubt he's gonna flip villa.

he even did the wolfy overreaction to c-vig

[Acct banned]

Originally Posted by crackedquads

And to be clear I think IMP is already more likely to be a wolf here than loretta. Add to the fact that IMP is going to be essentially useless in either role going forward, then she should die first IMO. Loretta being alive longer is more valuable to us no matter what his role, because as a villager he'll help us and as a wolf he will spew. IMP will do neither.

IMP is never a wolf just because IMP defended a wolf. I hate getting wagoned because of that.

I'm seriously more likely to defend a wolf as a villager than I am W/W.

People just use it as an excuse to wagon someone because they don't want to take the time to look for real reasons.

[Anarchist]

why would you say someone is a lock villager several times unless you peeked them?

you laid it all out for filthy, you can't claim ignorance now

[Aksdal]

thought about this as I was going to bed yesterday. I think IMP is prob just a downtrodden villager. I feel better with Loretta for the time being

loretta

[Acct banned]

Originally Posted by Anarchist

why would you say someone is a lock villager several times unless you peeked them?

you laid it all out for filthy, you can't claim ignorance now

Because I hoped I'd be right, then be NK'd as seer and today everyone would say how amazing I am.

Seriously, move on. If you're a villager don't waste your time. I fricking swear to you that I'm a villager and if you are one as well you're wasting your breath.

[Crossnerd]

Originally Posted by Anarchist

yeah that's what makes me think cross is for sure a wolf

first of all in a different game a wolf did the same thing where they fake asked me to explain something then voted me anyway

second of all earlier in the day she had a villa lean on me

I never had you as a villager learn. You made it as high as neutral, with some points for and against you. When sun made a case against you, I dropped you down to wolf lean, and when I wrote a paragraph of questions to you about it, I never saw a response.

Originally Posted by VarianceMinefield

its not cause of a lot of votes on him

its just bad to not have close wagons

sure hitting a wolf is great

but making everyone have to make a important vote matters a lot too

I had vmf initially as a wolf lean yesterday, mainly bc of his interactions with anarchist, so as annie moved down, vmf moved up a little in my mind. I agree completely with the sentiment above and that was a major factor in where I placed my vote. The first game I played back in pog I did a ton of wagon analysis. I thought and still think it was correct to vote between the two lead wagons.

Originally Posted by Anarchist

no i agree

i had a bad and wolfy day 1 til i caught filthy

How can you blame people for voting you when you freely admit this?

[Anarchist]

How can you blame people for voting you when you freely admit this?

because you should never cfd anyone, ever, ESPECIALLY when we had a close to lock wolf on the line

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by InsureMePlz

IMP is never a wolf just because IMP defended a wolf. I hate getting wagoned because of that.

I'm seriously more likely to defend a wolf as a villager than I am W/W.

People just use it as an excuse to wagon someone because they don't want to take the time to look for real reasons.

Defending someone who flips wolf in and of itself isn't that bad, I agree.

The issue here, though, is that the group of you tried to cfd someone instead of let a soon to flip wolf die. That is considerably worse imo.

And the reason I'd rather go you instead is that you're quite less useful to the village irregardless of your role, couple's with loretta being so easily wagoned right now that I think loretta is more likely to be a villager.

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by Aksdal

thought about this as I was going to bed yesterday. I think IMP is prob just a downtrodden villager. I feel better with Loretta for the time being

loretta

Dislike.

[Crossnerd]

Originally Posted by Alrighty Roo

loretta is looking pretty wolfy. The one thing that concerns me is a few of the people who have voted for her are looking pretty wolfy themselves.

In regards to you xnerd. That's a pretty damn long post. I liked your opening post of reads, that seemed honest and villagery. However I don't like your late vote of ana, and I don't like you justifying it by saying you didn't think it would change the lynch (why do it then?).

Having said that, I agree with your best lynches, and it seems unlikely that all 3 of you could be wolves and it doesn't seem like w/w (unless you're just selfish) so idk. Either you are a wolf and Loretta and 425 aren't, or they are and you're not. Atm I think loretta is looking the worst but we'll see.

I put a lot of time into my reads list from d1. I felt like I owed it to sanga to really try hard this game since he was one of the villagers I completely screwed over in the mason game. My vote on annie turned out to be bad, but it seemed like there were plenty of other people that suspected him too and thought filthy was more likely to be a villager. I never made a case for saving filthy like imp or loretta did though. I just stuck to my read that anarchist was sketch (which he admits) and voted between the lead wagons. If everyone did this wagon analysis would actually be a lot easier fyi. Have you read any previous games where you can see how that is done? You would see what I mean.

[Acct banned]

Originally Posted by crackedquads

Defending someone who flips wolf in and of itself isn't that bad, I agree.

The issue here, though, is that the group of you tried to cfd someone instead of let a soon to flip wolf die. That is considerably worse imo.

And the reason I'd rather go you instead is that you're quite less useful to the village irregardless of your role, couple's with loretta being so easily wagoned right now that I think loretta is more likely to be a villager.

Yeah. Throw insults at me. That'll get people to wagon me.

Go **** yourself.

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by Anarchist

he won't help us because we can't listen to his advice. i guess if he flips villa we can going forward but i highly doubt he's gonna flip villa.

he even did the wolfy overreaction to c-vig

You can't assume his advice is useless when you're already assuming his role, you're going to end up making poor conclusions playing like that.

[crackedquads]

Originally Posted by InsureMePlz

Yeah. Throw insults at me. That'll get people to wagon me.

Go **** yourself.

You're only proving my point, lol.