11/24 Sheep WW Vanilla+ Game Thread

[Anarchist]

Originally Posted by Sun Tzu

lol

I guarantee that doesn't work for me

look at some of my wolf games

ok, villa lean retracted

[Anarchist]

i think i remember the same from las vegas game

maybe you were zerging or whatever tho

[Fluttershy]

Originally Posted by Willi

Here is your list.

(Skip)

Do not expect much explanation.

Thank you Willi.

Fluttershy It's Nice

I assume you have internally assigned your own reads. I haven't played Werewolf with you yet so I'll nudge you in the right direction by saying that if you explain your reads you'll usually get more buy-in to your ideas!

Unvote Willi

Originally Posted by crackedquads

Again, all of gad's post. He's done absolutely nothing. He's reminding me of his wolf game in the NFL game.

I agree, there's been some pointing out to "Gadarene's only post" ... "Gadarene's first two posts" ... etc.

Originally Posted by crackedquads

Anarhist
Sun
425
fluttershy
the mooher
thenothing
arianeminefield
willi

^People I don't want to ote for today.

What a wonderful list. I agree with over half of these, we share very similar lists.



Gadarene is usually a more active participant as a villager is what I gather. He has not contributed as much as his reputation would have me believe he would.

[filthyvermin]

Originally Posted by crackedquads

BASaint

Originally Posted by Sun Tzu

basaint

whoa, this is weird. they both vote him at exactly the same time like out of the blue....

i think CQ and sun wouln't do this as wolf team mates. they are almost never gonna be w/w here.

i admit i haven't read the thread yet. can someone please give me cliffs on the case on ba?

i am going to skim the thread now. i am not going to read the whole D1. i think chips said D1 is really valuable to go back and reread later in the game. i am excited to try that this game.

[Sun Tzu]

gadarene

[Crossnerd]

Hi again everyone, hope you guys all enjoyed Thanksgiving!

Disclaimer: I'm going to do my best this game to not ruin it for the rest of you like I did in the mason game. Sorry again for that...

So I get that everyone is in holiday spirirts and ww is supposed to fun etc, but I was not happy at how much useless crap I had to read in order to get through this monster. I can't see any scenarios where that is a benefit to us.. People who are posting a lot of useless crap should be among the first to go.


Strongest villa leans:

Crossnerd- lock villa

Aksdal- strongest villa lean, villagery thinking right from the start, talked about deciphering roles and mechanics. He's tough to read on tone alone bc of the constant sarcasm, but I like his actions so far, has asked a lot of questions and had several interactions. I don't know his wolf game, but his village game is strong

Sun- strong villa lean, posted strategy he researched from past games from amazing players, slightly aggressive tone, came down hard on vmf and 425 for bad play, also a strong player, would be a good leader

Loretta- villa lean, opening post contained a reads list, asked for a cutback in the useless chatter which I more than agree with

Less strong but still villa leans:

theNothing- posted a reads list that demonstrated a villagers thought process, even though I did not agree with it in its entirety

themoocher- seems like a super noob, he showed genuine frustration with being suspected by the more experienced players and to me it came across as honest

alrightyroo- super duper noob, he said this is the beginning of his ww career, then necro claims he peeked him wolf, his reaction was so normal that necro backed down


Thin villa leans:

evene- I liked her original reads list

fluttershy- seems enthusiastic, could prove helpful aside from the pony shtick

Neutral:

Zeestein- got a few weird votes in the beginning, hasn't posted that much, but supposedly a super noob so I can't peg these actions as wolfy yet, but I am observing the noobs more closely this game since there seem to be so many

Anarchist- If I had to make a choice right now, I'd prob throw him on the village list, but thats mostly based on tone and the fact that I want us to get along this game lol, the thunderdoming is weird, also someone pointed out that you made mention of rules for not discussing sheep answers which is really only an issue for the wolves, so undecided at the moment

IMP- threw around votes, said she is playing half-heartedly which is...not great, however he sponged aksdal at one point who is my strongest villa lean so he might be thinking like me as vanillager, not sure yet, should not play half-heartedly though in any role


Slight wolf leans:

BASaint- weird opening posts, weird tone, the weirdest of the noobs lol, and hasn't contributed much content until pressured by other players, seems to lurk and be around when others post about him

425kid- he spammed a lot in the beginning which I don't like at all, I've never played with him so I don't know if he is always this spazzy, hasn't posted too much content, his tone is ok but the spamming is not

necro- that was pretty bad to say you peeked a complete noob as a wolf and then back off, I don't understand that play at all, it seems just bad, and I've played with necro before so I know he's not a total noob to just spout off and do something like that, I don't get it

Wolf leans:

willi- has posted very little content, he's probably made more estonian jokes than content posts, thats not ok

VMF- I've seen him play so strongly as a villager and his day 1 this game is imho like garbage, I saw him in previous games as a major contributor, his tone also sets off my spidey sense, its so forced, the interactions early on with both anarchist and CQ were so bizarre, I don't see how all three of them can be village

CQ- worst offender of the spamming, posting drunk is usually a bad sign, also had bizarre interactions all day especially with anarchist, I've seen CQ also be a major contributor and he posted a lot but it was full of actually useful information, not all this clutter, definitely not himself this game




Its taken me a while to compile this bc I'm not feeling so great this morning so now I will reread a bit of the afternoon I've missed and see if anything has changed. I know there are a few people missing on my list, I tried to get everyone but some of them have not been very memorable and need to post more.

[Sun Tzu]

Originally Posted by filthyvermin

whoa, this is weird. they both vote him at exactly the same time like out of the blue....

i think CQ and sun wouln't do this as wolf team mates. they are almost never gonna be w/w here.

i admit i haven't read the thread yet. can someone please give me cliffs on the case on ba?

i am going to skim the thread now. i am not going to read the whole D1. i think chips said D1 is really valuable to go back and reread later in the game. i am excited to try that this game.

no, I would totally do that as w/w with quads

and then I would even tell you I would if you said this

[Anarchist]

it's not whether you'd do it as wolf teammates

it's whether i think you could be wolf teammates

and i don;t.

sans any reads, (6/25)(5/24) is a pretty small chance

[Anarchist]

ZOMG that's like 5% at rand for sun and cracked to be wolf teammates!!!

[Anarchist]

Originally Posted by filthyvermin

whoa, this is weird. they both vote him at exactly the same time like out of the blue....

i think CQ and sun wouln't do this as wolf team mates. they are almost never gonna be w/w here.

i admit i haven't read the thread yet. can someone please give me cliffs on the case on ba?

i am going to skim the thread now. i am not going to read the whole D1. i think chips said D1 is really valuable to go back and reread later in the game. i am excited to try that this game.

damn, i really wanted you to be a villager this game

but i think you're a wolf

[The Moocher]

Originally Posted by filthyvermin

i am going to skim the thread now. i am not going to read the whole D1. i think chips said D1 is really valuable to go back and reread later in the game. i am excited to try that this game.

I'm assuming it's valuable to re-read the thread every game day, sure it's valuable to re-read d1 later in the game but it has to be valuable now also...and deliberately not re-reading d1 so the info will me MORE valuable later seems counter-intuitive.

[Sun Tzu]

crossjen looking villa

[TheNothing]

Originally Posted by Anarchist

thenothing any thoughts on the last couple hundred posts?

Sitting with family and scrolling via phone. Will catch up when I return home. Quickly, not liking basaint or fluttershy (that happy sparkly pony **** makes me ill). But need to read and pay attention before making decision. Sorry I'm not more definitive.

[Anarchist]

if i didnt know him id think willi was a wolf, but since i do i think hes a villager

[Sun Tzu]

Originally Posted by The Moocher

I'm assuming it's valuable to re-read the thread every game day, sure it's valuable to re-read d1 later in the game but it has to be valuable now also...and deliberately not re-reading d1 so the info will me MORE valuable later seems counter-intuitive.

I like to read the whole thread every game day

but that gets hard when the thread gets really large