11/24 Sheep WW Vanilla+ Game Thread

[Alrighty Roo]

Originally Posted by TheNothing

i think both claims stink but w/e

I think one of them has to be telling the truth. I don't see w/w or villa/villa being very likely at all. I guess it's possible that one is a wolf and the other is a villager pretending to be seer but seer/wolf seems most likely.

[TheNothing]

Originally Posted by Alrighty Roo

I think one of them has to be telling the truth. I don't see w/w or villa/villa being very likely at all. I guess it's possible that one is a wolf and the other is a villager pretending to be seer but seer/wolf seems most likely.

oh, yeah - i don't necessarily think they are both ****ing with us. what i meant was that i don't like the way either of them claimed.

[Noah]

Originally Posted by Alrighty Roo

I think one of them has to be telling the truth. I don't see w/w or villa/villa being very likely at all. I guess it's possible that one is a wolf and the other is a villager pretending to be seer but seer/wolf seems most likely.

And Roo has already made it very clear his personal opinion is that 425 is more likely full of **** than Loretta.

[BASaint]

its impossible for them to be v/v or w/w.

unless 425 is the worst player that has ever been

[Noah]

Originally Posted by Alrighty Roo

I think one of them has to be telling the truth. I don't see w/w or villa/villa being very likely at all.

Villa/villa is impossible.

[Loretta8]

Originally Posted by filthyvermin

i don't know willi. if he is a guy who always makes jokes then obviously that makes it less wolfy than from a random player. but i am still going with my read that it was a wolfy post because it was a wolfy post. and i am a little suspicious that none of the other players commented on it. looking forward to hear what CQ, sun and gad have to say.


actually, i just had an idea. what if we made CQ, sun and gad village leaders? if they are all wolves we will lose anyway. if they are all villagers, or if 2/3 them are villagers and the rest of the village listens, we should have a pretty easy win.

this was the post that made me think filthy was a villager since this idea was so bizarre (lol me)

however, look at the three people he nominates as villager leaders. sun is dead villa, gad is peeked villa by me, leaving CQ. now the question is, would he as a wolf list 3 villagers out of 3 to be leaders, or would he try to get a wolf mixed in there?

overall this looks bad for CQ

[BASaint]

Originally Posted by BASaint

its impossible for them to be v/v or w/w.

unless 425 is the worst player that has ever been

actually, w/w is just about possible but still bad

[TheNothing]

Noah, what are your thoughts on these particular players?

zeestein
fluttershy (now i see you listed her as )
necro

anything on them?

what do you think about Gad being so UTR this game? what about the others who've not posted at all? Should we be worried about them this early?

fwiw, i believe loretta just a tad more than 425 but i also agree that the game will resolve both of them shortly.

i agree with your villa/wolf leans aorn

[Alrighty Roo]

Originally Posted by Noah

Villa/villa is impossible.

Oh yeah, I forgot 425 said he peeked loretta wolf

[necro]

Its definitely not v/v because I doubt 425 would get his seer role confused with lorettas and if he did then I think, well I dont know what id think but it wouldnt be pretty thoughts regarding him

The problem is that as loretta has said if either ( or both) are wolves we will literally gain no information because till tomorrow at the earliest IF we dont lynch one of them

[Noah]

Originally Posted by TheNothing

Noah, what are your thoughts on these particular players?

zeestein lol suspicious, possible wolf.
fluttershy (now i see you listed her as ) I've not played with FS before but from what I've heard she is excellent in either role. And from what I gather she's been hanging back more than she usually would. I need to read more
necro Didn't enjoy his tunneling on Roo, didn't enjoy his list, but I have seen him village this way. Needs to be kept a close eye on imo

anything on them?

what do you think about Gad being so UTR this game? No idea what to make of this. Doesn't seem like Gad whatever his role.what about the others who've not posted at all?We should look at them all soon. Nothing to say about them really beyond that because they haven't really posted anything for us to go on Should we be worried about them this early?Possibly for power wolf. Such a blow up on eod1 that if one of them happened to be one, makes sense to lay low and let the village self implode, then come back when dust is settling

fwiw, i believe loretta just a tad more than 425 but i also agree that the game will resolve both of them shortly. Can you explain why you believe Loretta more?

i agree with your villa/wolf leans aorn

Also, what do you think of me this game?

[necro]

The people who havent posted if they are villagers just arent worth our consideration imo

[necro]

Noah my list may not have been good iyo but I bet I nabbed a wolf or two

Plus I explained my thinking behind roo I dont believe I need to justify it

[Noah]

Originally Posted by necro

Noah my list may not have been good iyo but I bet I nabbed a wolf or two

Plus I explained my thinking behind roo I dont believe I need to justify it

It's cool man. Actually, I'm quite suspicious of Roo myself at the moment.

[Alrighty Roo]

Whatever. It just seems to me that people are forgetting everything 425 did before he claimed, making him very very wolfy. I agree that loretta is still a suspect but now that it's a case of either/or I think it's 425.