|
|
| Computer Technical Help Post your questions about computer hardware and software and configuring same here. |
05-25-2012, 02:40 PM
|
#3
|
|
In My Own Mind
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: in the trainer's lap.
Posts: 20,489
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
With a quick glance I would increase the power supply from 650 to at least 750. When I built my machine 2 years ago 600 was not enough, and that was 2 years ago.
|
|
|
05-25-2012, 05:36 PM
|
#4
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 2,361
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
I'd suggest substituting the 3770k with an i7-2700k. They perform just about the same and the SB is much easier to overclock. With less in the way of heat concerns because of the thermal paste they're using in the new ones. I went back and forth and looked at everything... if OC'ing just get the 2700k. It's proven, easier & $50 cheaper for virtually no drop off in performance.
Without a video card you hardly need a heavy duty power supply. Those specs will run on a solid 430w PSU and still leave room for many video cards, nothing serious but the types non-gamers would be more than happy with. My mother's computer has a 430w with a GTS 450 in there (so she can play Portal 2 of course); works just fine. I'd worry about quality more than just wattage if you're not looking to heavy gaming. I'm a fan of the better Seasonic models despite the cost, though they do build for other companies including Corsair. With a 450w-550w of good quality it will work out.
Intel 520 is a really nice drive but overpriced. It figures to be reliable though they switched their controller to the second-gen Sandforce ones which overall haven't been. Other good 128GB SSDs are popping up around $110 pretty frequently now or less.
Rest seems reasonable.
|
|
|
05-26-2012, 07:27 PM
|
#5
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Food and Stuff
Posts: 2,074
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry Legend
With a quick glance I would increase the power supply from 650 to at least 750. When I built my machine 2 years ago 600 was not enough, and that was 2 years ago.
|
This is hysterical. With no GPU, he can use a 400w power supply.
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 10:09 AM
|
#6
|
|
Overlording RGT
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Bluff-Calling
Posts: 10,783
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sba9630
|
Thanks for the input. What specifically jumps out at you? I read the reviews as well, and although some people commented on the side panels being flimsy I didn't notice anything else. I don't really move the computer at all and I will not be changing things constantly so I am not sure that it will be an issue. But I will keep this in mind.
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 10:20 AM
|
#7
|
|
Overlording RGT
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Bluff-Calling
Posts: 10,783
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gonso
I'd suggest substituting the 3770k with an i7-2700k. They perform just about the same and the SB is much easier to overclock. With less in the way of heat concerns because of the thermal paste they're using in the new ones. I went back and forth and looked at everything... if OC'ing just get the 2700k. It's proven, easier & $50 cheaper for virtually no drop off in performance.
Without a video card you hardly need a heavy duty power supply. Those specs will run on a solid 430w PSU and still leave room for many video cards, nothing serious but the types non-gamers would be more than happy with. My mother's computer has a 430w with a GTS 450 in there (so she can play Portal 2 of course); works just fine. I'd worry about quality more than just wattage if you're not looking to heavy gaming. I'm a fan of the better Seasonic models despite the cost, though they do build for other companies including Corsair. With a 450w-550w of good quality it will work out.
|
I still am not sure if I am going to overclock. What are your thoughts about overclocking? Does it really put a ton of wear on your system? And I have read the reviews about the new 3770 not being much faster performance wise than the 2700, but it does seem like there are some advantages. One being the new iGPU and the new Z77 motherboards seem to have some nice advantages as well like better USB 3.0 integration and a few other performance tweaks. It also seems that the new 3770 allows for native 1600Mhz RAM as well. Maybe I am wrong on that though. I wasn't sold on the new Sandy Bridge at first either but after watching some videos and doing some reading there does seem to be some nice hidden pluses in the CPU and the MoBo. I will keep this in mind though.
As far as PSU, I will do some digging and find a more appropriate one and post it.
Quote:
Intel 520 is a really nice drive but overpriced. It figures to be reliable though they switched their controller to the second-gen Sandforce ones which overall haven't been. Other good 128GB SSDs are popping up around $110 pretty frequently now or less.
Rest seems reasonable.
|
I cannot believe they are getting that cheap! The reason that I went with the Intel 520 is because it offers a 5 year warranty and seems to be the only SSD that turns out that level of speed and yet doesn't have all of the bad feedback about BSOD and such. It seems that Intel is the only one that has a handle on the second-gen Sandforce. Although the others might have worked out the kinks by now. Any SSD that you recommend?
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 10:22 AM
|
#8
|
|
Overlording RGT
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Bluff-Calling
Posts: 10,783
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Also, how to you calculate how many watts your PSU needs to be? I have never quite figured that out?
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 11:35 AM
|
#9
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Food and Stuff
Posts: 2,074
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
It mainly depends on the graphics card. A solid 550w PSU would cover cards that are under $300. More expensive cards generally require more power. See this chart.
I'd keep everything you listed. Except maybe grab the ASRock Z77 Extreme4 motherboard.
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 05:09 PM
|
#10
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 2,361
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
I still am not sure if I am going to overclock. What are your thoughts about overclocking?
|
It's completely standard. Just buy an aftermarket cooler and do it, they're built for it.
Quote:
|
Does it really put a ton of wear on your system?
|
Yes, but not to a degree that seems to matter unless you're going really extreme. If you'd feel better, instead of trying to clock a 3.4 GHz chip up to 4.9 GHz, you could back it off to 4.2 or something. I just don't see people burning out CPUs very often.
Quote:
|
And I have read the reviews about the new 3770 not being much faster performance wise than the 2700, but it does seem like there are some advantages. One being the new iGPU and the new Z77 motherboards seem to have some nice advantages as well like better USB 3.0 integration and a few other performance tweaks.
|
All correct - but you can put a 2700 in a Z77 board and get the USB.
Quote:
|
It also seems that the new 3770 allows for native 1600Mhz RAM as well.
|
With the right RAM you can do this on Sandy Bridge also. And FWIW: the effects of RAM faster than 1600 is negligible. Just a heads up before you get to the part where you're thinking about spending on DDR3-2400 speed modules.
Quote:
|
I wasn't sold on the new Sandy Bridge at first either but after watching some videos and doing some reading there does seem to be some nice hidden pluses in the CPU and the MoBo.
|
Sandy and Ivy aren't that different. Ivy is better and more efficient at stock speed, but it gets hotter than Sandy as you overclock it - if overclocking, I call these two a wash). Ivy does have better integrated graphics if you actually use them, but I suspect if Ivy's integrated is good enough chances are so is Sandy's. Then LDO there's price to consider, and the fact that Z77 boards can use either of these chips.
Quote:
|
I cannot believe they are getting that cheap! The reason that I went with the Intel 520 is because it offers a 5 year warranty and seems to be the only SSD that turns out that level of speed and yet doesn't have all of the bad feedback about BSOD and such. It seems that Intel is the only one that has a handle on the second-gen Sandforce.
|
You might be correct, and the only issue of concern for me in Sandforce, not Intel. I have a 510 (not Sandforce) which is excellent, and have an early Intel X25 40GB that's still running strong in my Mom's computer. My argument against is basically (a) it's still Sandforce and there's a chance of problems beyond Intel's control, and (b) it costs a lot.
Quote:
|
Although the others might have worked out the kinks by now. Any SSD that you recommend?
|
See Slickdeals: the 128GB Crucial M4 goes on sale for $100 free ship at midnight at NewEgg. If the 520 is $185 it's not even a close decision for me. M4 is proven, not Sandforce, good company, and the drive is decent if though not spectacular performer. You could almost buy 2 of them for the same money as the 520. I doubt you'd notice a performance difference between the two anyway as far as day-to-day things. I have or have had 5 different SSD models and unless you're really tasking them with big jobs they're all fast.
Last edited by Gonso; 05-27-2012 at 05:16 PM.
|
|
|
05-27-2012, 05:24 PM
|
#11
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 2,361
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Also, how to you calculate how many watts your PSU needs to be? I have never quite figured that out?
|
It's not even the wattage so much. It's how much you can carry on the rails - before I bore you to tears I'd just figure out what you want to build and possible video card options and go from there. The underlying idea is that you find a nice efficient power supply with a good reputation (modular would be a nice plus), and going overboard a bit is okay if you do that.
Bad PSUs are a nightmare and unless they come DOA they can't be hard to identify as the culprit when troubleshooting. They're a PITA to replace also. I'd put good money into one that gives you piece of mind that you can hopefully run with for many years.
I have an X650. Definitely more than needed right now, but I needed something for a silent PC that gave me video card options I might look into in for a future build (PS- it's tested performance is pretty far beyond it's rated 650w, usually it's the other way around with PSUs). Cost a lot but I've seen them on sale for $99, and I love everything about it so far. I usually don't fawn over power supplies... but it's one of those things you understand when you buy the perfect part for what you want, and there's no doubt about it.
|
|
|
05-28-2012, 11:01 AM
|
#13
|
|
Overlording RGT
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Bluff-Calling
Posts: 10,783
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gonso
It's completely standard. Just buy an aftermarket cooler and do it, they're built for it.
|
Would the cooler that I have listed suffice? It seems to be a popular recommendation around here.
Quote:
|
Yes, but not to a degree that seems to matter unless you're going really extreme. If you'd feel better, instead of trying to clock a 3.4 GHz chip up to 4.9 GHz, you could back it off to 4.2 or something. I just don't see people burning out CPUs very often.
|
Ok, good to know.
Quote:
|
All correct - but you can put a 2700 in a Z77 board and get the USB.
|
Very true I didn't think about that.
Quote:
|
With the right RAM you can do this on Sandy Bridge also. And FWIW: the effects of RAM faster than 1600 is negligible. Just a heads up before you get to the part where you're thinking about spending on DDR3-2400 speed modules.
|
You would have to overclock the RAM to do this though, right? And I did not know that faster than 1600 is negligible, good to know.
Quote:
|
Sandy and Ivy aren't that different. Ivy is better and more efficient at stock speed, but it gets hotter than Sandy as you overclock it - if overclocking, I call these two a wash). Ivy does have better integrated graphics if you actually use them, but I suspect if Ivy's integrated is good enough chances are so is Sandy's. Then LDO there's price to consider, and the fact that Z77 boards can use either of these chips.
|
Very good points. What would you say the biggest advantage to the Ivy chip is? They do seem to be very close in specs.
Quote:
You might be correct, and the only issue of concern for me in Sandforce, not Intel. I have a 510 (not Sandforce) which is excellent, and have an early Intel X25 40GB that's still running strong in my Mom's computer. My argument against is basically (a) it's still Sandforce and there's a chance of problems beyond Intel's control, and (b) it costs a lot.
See Slickdeals: the 128GB Crucial M4 goes on sale for $100 free ship at midnight at NewEgg. If the 520 is $185 it's not even a close decision for me. M4 is proven, not Sandforce, good company, and the drive is decent if though not spectacular performer. You could almost buy 2 of them for the same money as the 520. I doubt you'd notice a performance difference between the two anyway as far as day-to-day things. I have or have had 5 different SSD models and unless you're really tasking them with big jobs they're all fast.
|
Man, there is quite a difference in price and researching a bit shows you are right that in real world scenarios there will not be much of a difference in performance. You have sold me on the M4.
|
|
|
05-28-2012, 06:49 PM
|
#14
|
|
veteran
Join Date: May 2008
Location: This space intentionally left blank
Posts: 3,454
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Thanks for the input. What specifically jumps out at you? I read the reviews as well, and although some people commented on the side panels being flimsy I didn't notice anything else. I don't really move the computer at all and I will not be changing things constantly so I am not sure that it will be an issue. But I will keep this in mind.
|
I would be concerned with overall build quality due to numerous comments such as:
Quote:
There are some gaps in the corners of the case.
|
If you're putting this case under a desk or is otherwise hidden, that might not be a big deal for you.
A bigger issue for me would be noise. You might be able to do some things to alleviate it, but it would be a concern for me:
Quote:
My 1TB Seagate make a good deal of noise in the mounts they use. I tried putting in the additional two screws, but it's still loud enough to irritate me.
Poorly designed fan grills that are very noisy even with low RPM fans.
HDD trays are very loose fitting and rattle immensely when drives are being accessed, very loud.
|
|
|
|
05-28-2012, 08:01 PM
|
#15
|
|
veteran
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 2,361
|
Re: Finally going to build a new comp, what do you think of this spec?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Would the cooler that I have listed suffice? It seems to be a popular recommendation around here.
|
It's fine. I've used it myself and it was part of the tutorial build I did last year.
Quote:
|
You would have to overclock the RAM to do this though, right? And I did not know that faster than 1600 is negligible, good to know.
|
Yes and no. If you have XMP enabled in bios it will read the RAM at it's rated speed and change it automatically. 1866 is gives a very slight real world improvement but you wouldn't see it.
Quote:
|
What would you say the biggest advantage to the Ivy chip is? They do seem to be very close in specs.
|
That it's more energy efficient at clock speeds and a small bit faster. It also has some nice video encoding features if you do that in particular. And the integrated graphics have improved quite a bit, though still not enough for serious gamers. For a $50 savings I'd take the 2700k though, which I did.
Quote:
|
Man, there is quite a difference in price and researching a bit shows you are right that in real world scenarios there will not be much of a difference in performance. You have sold me on the M4.
|
Those little savings add up. Now you can buy a better display or mouse or something you'll actually notice and appreciate. Hard to go wrong with any SATA 6gb/s SSD so long as it works.
|
|
|
| Thread Tools |
|
|
| Display Modes |
Linear Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:23 PM.
|