Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights?

09-22-2010 , 08:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sober
So you're a kinesiology dropout?
Dropouts don't get degrees...I didn't drop out: I changed majors.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ra_Z_Boy
Lol @ this whole post.
Ummm...ok. Maybe you don't think that people ever landed on the moon, either. You have fun.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:39 AM
No one could possibly be laughing at you, they must be conspiracy theorists.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:40 AM
I'm just curious which part you think is lol and why.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:46 AM
that an elite badminton player who had a back injury could squat 500lbs within the reasonably short time frame you have implied. that is what is lol, that is why i called you a liar. all this whilst breathing mid squat.

Last edited by tmcdmck; 09-22-2010 at 08:46 AM. Reason: well the whole thread is lol but that in particular.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 09:30 AM
It took well over 2yrs to get to that point...where was it implied that it took less time?
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 09:32 AM
no 2 years IS the reasonably short time frame.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 09:39 AM
If you say so...you have indicated zero training that would suggest an expertise that would warrant your belief. You have fun asserting the opposite of people's achievements whom you know nothing about over the interwebz. You're a real winner. 2 years of very hard work is easily enough time to do what I did. Your claim is like saying that you can't take a couch potato and have them run a marathon in 8 months...hard, but totally possible. On neither topic do you have any expertise, though...just your own views not backed up by anything other than your opinion and perhaps intuitions and anecdotes.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 09:43 AM
Just like you then ?

Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 09:54 AM
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-0...vy-league.html

that is an article on a 295lb college level american footballer. he can squat 500lbs. he has obviously been strength training for more than 2 years, without the disadvantage of a back injury. he has NFL aspirations. i assume he weighs close to 100lbs more than you, and doesnt spend as much time as you did doing catabolic activities (such as badminton)

quotation from the article:

Quote:
Osborne said he split his time this summer between writing computer code for the website and working in the weight room to add muscle. His bench press is 375 pounds and his squat is 500 pounds, he said. Hortiz said 500-pound squats are good even by NFL standards, though the benchmark for bench presses is about 400 pounds.
look up more american football squat information. even the most elite squatters there are squatting around 700lbs, and most of the big guys are squatting less than 600. there are plenty of nfl players who cannot squat 500. this is in a sport than selects for strength, with players who all have presumably been squatting 5 years plus and have elite genetics.

now can you see why claiming to squat 500lbs only 2 years after being injured so badly you struggled to carry a backpack and playing badminton, a catabolic sport where being too big disadvantages you, is an outrageous claim?
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 10:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ra_Z_Boy
Just like you then ?

Exactly. I could do up to 200+the bar safely. Usually with less, though.

Quote:
Originally Posted by tmcdmck
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-0...vy-league.html

that is an article on a 295lb college level american footballer. he can squat 500lbs. he has obviously been strength training for more than 2 years, without the disadvantage of a back injury. he has NFL aspirations. i assume he weighs close to 100lbs more than you, and doesnt spend as much time as you did doing catabolic activities (such as badminton)

quotation from the article:



look up more american football squat information. even the most elite squatters there are squatting around 700lbs, and most of the big guys are squatting less than 600. there are plenty of nfl players who cannot squat 500. this is in a sport than selects for strength, with players who all have presumably been squatting 5 years plus and have elite genetics.

now can you see why claiming to squat 500lbs only 2 years after being injured so badly you struggled to carry a backpack and playing badminton, a catabolic sport where being too big disadvantages you, is an outrageous claim?
Why do you think NFL players are the right metric by which to judge? I had absurdly big legs for badminton...so big, in fact, that it was a big detriment to my game (I was extremely explosive for the first game or two, but would fade if it went to 3). Squats are something that I over-focused on in my training. I wasn't training nearly as smart as I could have...

You also seem to think that I started from scratch with my fitness...I was extremely fit going into the accident, which helped the recovery phase a lot.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 10:06 AM
http://www.crossfit.com/cf-journal/WLSTANDARDS.pdf

ok ignore nfl then (despite the fact you are comparing your strength levels to those of a 295lb football player, whatever). the above is a link to a table of strength standards created by mark rippetoe, a world renowned strength training expert.

a 500lb squat would make you "elite", the most advanced possible category, if you weighed 198lbs.

Quote:
An "intermediate" is a person who
has engaged in regular training for up to two years. The intermediate level
indicates some degree of specialization in the exercises and a high level of
performance at the recreational level. The term"advanced" refers to an individual
with multi-year training experience with definite goals in the higher levels of
competitive athletics. The term"elite" refers specifically to athletes competing in
strength sports. Less than 1%of the weight training population will attain this
level.
*edit* so anyway, i think ive done enough to show im not just running my mouth by calling you a liar. your claim has been shown too be pretty outrageous. if you could actually do this, how about some proof?
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 10:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by durkadurka33
Exactly. I could do up to 200+the bar safely. Usually with less, though.

I wouldn't be so use this as a claim to your knowledge of working out.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 11:51 AM
He may have had 500 lbs on his back at some point in time, but he obv didn't go all the way down with it.

Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 12:02 PM
Relevant post on the subject matter.

Quote:
The way that you can stave off the strain-induced blackout is by exhaling a bit of air as you grind through the rep. This is completely different than exhaling as you go up on a rep, fitness style. Instead, you will hiss air out from between your teeth or produce a guttural sound from your throat (grunting/yelling, but not singing). This is like putting your thumb over the end of the house; a little bit comes out, but the pressure stays high inside. Letting some air out relieves some of the pressure overall while the teeth/glottis help keep the pressure up enough so that your trunk is still stabilized as you finish the lift. Completely exhaling would let out too much air and not keep the trunk stabilized.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 12:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ra_Z_Boy
This made me lol.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 12:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Parlay Slow
I have no polite way of saying the obvious here: you have no idea what you're talking about.

j/k.. there's no such thing as a "seated hack squat" machine

google has a number of links to references of "seated hack squat machine". It looks like they are sometimes referred to as "leg lift/seated hack squat machines".


PairTheBoard
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 01:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Parlay Slow
He may have had 500 lbs on his back at some point in time, but he obv didn't go all the way down with it.

Absolutely not. It was to approximately 85degrees of knee flexion.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 02:13 PM
fyi, that would typically be called a "partial squat"
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 02:42 PM
what parlay slow said, but i still dont believe you.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 04:53 PM
wow @ the ownage in this thread
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 07:26 PM
Wait. You can be nationally ranked in badminton?

j/k, but wtf were you lifting heavy for? I would assume that ballistic exercises would be more appropriate, given my limited knowledge.

I was an indoor goalkeeper (decent) and boxer (subpar - probably the worst of all time), and my trainers wouldn't even let me touch heavy weights.

Granted, this was in the late '80s/early '90s, but still...
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:22 PM
Yes, your trainers had a lifetime of experience to go on but he has a partial degree in kinesiology. His knowledge in that and his superb personal trainer skills make him all knowing. I guess we need to bow down to his genius in this aspect of life.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote
09-22-2010 , 08:44 PM
fwiw strength training a bit would be beneficial. boxing trainers are notorious for their old fashioned views wrt weight lifting (ie thinking its bad, mainly because it slows you down), but recently that has started to change, and all of the top boxers lift weights, even the small ones (amir khan is a good example: famous for his hand speed, has improved dramatically under freddie roach who has had him do a bunch of lower body strength training). i have no doubt that some strength training would be beneficial for a badminton player (stronger legs = faster acceleration, higher jump etc), but obviously not what you need to focus on, and gaining too much mass would be detrimental.

more relevantly to this thread, playing badminton is detrimental to your weight lifting.
Why do we hold our breath when we lift weights? Quote

      
m