Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?)

02-26-2012 , 07:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by aggo
those editorials are butthurt. they want to know how/why the WDA arrives to certain conclusions so that they can use it themselves and scrutinize it for whatever motives they have under the guise of "well we should know since this is kinda big deal"

good thing WDA is in the industry and not academia, or else nothing would ever get accomplished. Academia would argue for 10 years about the standard protocols for examining piss in an NMR, and by then, athletes wouldve already found drugs that the NMR can't differentiate from. and I'd be remiss that an athlete making 10+ million a year couldnt hire somebody to test his/her piss under the proper protocols to see what's turning up (and what isn't) if the WDA released their guidelines for how they test things.
right. the important thing is cracking down on these filthy cheaters, not making sure everything is all like accurate and stuff.
Quote:
Originally Posted by aggo
i dont know how the WDA arrives to it's conclusions, but if it's just like any industry in biotech, there is not one single scientist who gets to make a call on whether or not there is synthetic testosterone in piss.
yes i'm aware. i'll try not to use metaphors from now on.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 08:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by P0nzi
Clemens
doesn't know what a vegan is.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 09:38 AM
What is the chance of a false positive for 20:1 testosterone? Oh, you don't know?

What is the chance of a false positive for synthetic testosterone? Really, that small?
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 10:18 AM
Rome tweet from yesterday

Quote:
Jim Rome ‏ @jimrome

The fact that Bud Selig hasn't apologized to Ryan Braun publicly essentially tells you he thinks he's a cheater. And got over.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 12:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by aggo
so you're familiar with the fact that when they purify his piss for testosterone and run it through a mass-spec to check for the isotope ratio (and apparently, they only do this if they detect for elevated testosterone levels beforehand) of the carbon atoms present in their sample, that the rate of false positives is effectively zero?
ikes, presumably you've done some mass spec work. What exactly is the problem here? Seems using some other test to detect and mass spec to confirm should be pretty foolproof.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 12:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayTeeMe
ikes, presumably you've done some mass spec work. What exactly is the problem here? Seems using some other test to detect and mass spec to confirm should be pretty foolproof.
No test is foolproof, and we're not talking only about Braun. We're talking about why wada sucks balls.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 01:21 PM
You cant fool a mass spec when you have a purified sample. Its that cut and dry.

It can easily deferentiate between isotopes of more than 1 atomic mass. And you can integrate the intensity peaks of each signal to produce a ratio of isotopes present.
But to get to that point, you have to purify your sample so that you can specifically examine a narrow range of known mass to charge ratio of a given sample. Purifying the sample also destroys it, hence the need of 2 samples (which they refer to as A or B) and is inherently much more subjective and prone to errors.

So the tripping point here is the process of purifying the sample.

But if they successfully do so, and produce a clean mass spectra that shows an isotope ratio ( I assume that synthetic testosterone is 99.95% c12 and natural testosterone is something like 98% and the rest is a naturally occuring form of mostly c13) that indicates the presence of too much c12 and not enough 13 that its a mortal lock that there is synthetic testosterone present in his piss, which explains why he was found to have a 20:1 ratio in the first place.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 01:43 PM
Exactly, a mass spec is going to be pretty accurate (yes i work in a lab). But I think he's saying someone ****ed up before that. But I don't care, and who the **** knows.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 01:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ikestoys
No test is foolproof, and we're not talking only about Braun. We're talking about why wada sucks balls.
If they're using friggin MASS SPECTROMETRY (expensive as ****) to confirm the results of their preliminary tests then they are going far above what I've seen in real world labs. We certainly aren't doing mass spec in the hospital lab.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 01:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayTeeMe
If they're using friggin MASS SPECTROMETRY (expensive as ****) to confirm the results of their preliminary tests then they are going far above what I've seen in real world labs. We certainly aren't doing mass spec in the hospital lab.
But hospital labs actually publish things like false positive rates and actually try to determine normal ranges in the scientific community. WADA, otoh, hides everything and gives athletes little due process to fight any positive result.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:02 PM
I feel like Braun's team questioning the chain of custody and not the test its self is just a strategic move. I think that Braun saying he is innocent and that he would bet his life the substance never entered his body is in its self questioning the test.

Also, would he be questioning the test as a false positive or saying the test was tampered with. Once again the tampering issue can go back to the chain of custody problems.

Anyone who know a lot about drug testing and such, after a sample is sealed, is it possible to tamper with the sample?
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:04 PM
basically, no you can't tamper with a tamper sealed sample without it being obvious
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:14 PM
Could tampering with the bottle/cup/container before Braun's sample would be in it be possible?
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:17 PM
cash mahne: your hero cheated. it's ok.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:30 PM
I am sure you wouldn't have any questions if some guy who is a fan of a rival team took your urine sample home for 44 hours, when the procedures say it must be mailed the same day.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cash mahne
I am sure you wouldn't have any questions if some guy who is a fan of a rival team took your urine sample home for 44 hours, when the procedures say it must be mailed the same day.
Occam's Razor tho
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:40 PM
dont you think there are standardized protocols for these things?

the guy from espn said that the test administrator followed all the rules from mlb and his company.

it's not some schlep who asks braun to piss in a tupperware container.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 02:59 PM
Bonds and Braun are similar in that they are both likely dopers that managed to come out looking better than MLB because of MLB's incompetence and pettiness.

The media and government were both much harsher on Bonds.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 03:16 PM
it's really weird defending ikes but the argument with aggo is not about braun's specific test. everyone with a clue realizes that he almost certainly used a banned substance.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-27-2012 , 03:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phildo
it's really weird defending ikes but the argument with aggo is not about braun's specific test. everyone with a clue realizes that he almost certainly used a banned substance.
Yup, braun's case is tangentially related. If Braun had ****ed up some procedural thing and missed a test, he'd be in deep ****. It's only fair to hold the MLB to the same standard.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-28-2012 , 04:19 PM
now the collector issued a statement.

Braun looks bad here imo. still wanna bet your life?
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-28-2012 , 05:03 PM
it doesn't matter
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-28-2012 , 05:32 PM
Quote:
NEW YORK (AP)—The person who collected Ryan Braun’s urine samples that tested positive for elevated levels of testosterone says he followed the collection program’s protocol.

Dino Laurenzi Jr. issued a statement Tuesday confirming he handled the sample submitted following a playoff game on Oct. 1. He says he has been a collector for Comprehensive Drug Testing since 2005 and has taken more than 600 samples for Major League Baseball’s drug-testing program.

Braun’s 50-game suspension was overturned last week.

Laurenzi says he stored Braun’s sample in his basement in accordance with drug-collecting procedure because there was “no FedEx office located within 50 miles of Miller Park that would ship packages that day or Sunday.”

Braun, however, contends at least five FedEx locations within 5 miles were open until 9 p.m. and there also was a 24-hour location.

Laurenzi says protocol is to “safeguard” the samples at home until FedEx can ship the sample to the lab and that he didn’t tamper with the package.
MAJOR
LEAGUE
BEISBOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

anyone got dem google maps?
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-28-2012 , 05:35 PM
Piss collector seems like a great job.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote
02-28-2012 , 05:36 PM
So this bro beat the system and got some shots in at Selig or something? Nice.
Ryan Braun tests positive for PED (butnahhhhh, or AGame?) Quote

      
m