Quote:
Originally Posted by john voight
didnt bird suck at D, and have awesome teammates throughout? kind of like Klove w/o the teammates. Like a tall unathletic white guy, who sucked at D, could shoot and pass, grabbed rebounds b/c he played down low, and was massively overrated b/c he was a white guy who didn't suck ass?
looking at his stats now, he didn't even shoot threes. most he made was 90. obv 3s weren't as big as they are now. My question is, wtf would he do against AD. pull ups and fadeaways Kobe style? What would he do on defense to stop AD?
If he played today implementing his old style, he would rip every tendon in his body. So if he played today he would just be a tall Korvereque chuker, who is goofy and sucks at D. Kinda like Dirk circa now.
Easy AD>Bird. Though a Bird led team will win more games than AD.
The Kyle Korver is a later-day Larry Bird theme is silliness.
Regarding threes - it's disingenuous to claim that Bird didn't shoot threes. From his rookie season (79-80) through 86-87, he was 5th, 7th, 4th, 1st, 1st and 4th in made threes.
Regarding his impact on the game - during his career he was 3rd, 2nd, 2nd, 1st, 1st, 1st, 1st, 3rd and 7th yearly and 8th overall for his career in Wins Over Replacement Player.
From 81-82 through 86-87 he was 8th, 3rd, 2nd, 1st, 1st, 3rd and 2nd in PER.
He was surrounded by great players for the bulk of his prime; however, it's worth noting that in his rookie season Boston went from 29 wins in 78-79 to a league leading 61 in 79-80 with a roster that included post prime Nate Archibald, post prime Dave Cowens and (in the second half of the season) way past prime Pete Maravich along with a pre-prime Cedric Maxwell. Both Cowens and Maravich retired prior to the start of the next season.
Bird did not "suck" at the defensive end. He was not an elite face up defender and Kevin McHale or Maxwell almost always accepted the role of matching up against the other team's best forward. Bird was, however, a high IQ far above average team defender who rotated well and was among the league's best rebounding forwards - especially at the defensive end.
From his rookie year through 85-86, Bird was a yearly 8th, 4th, 7th, 7th, 8th, 10th and 7th in total rebounds.
Larry Bird could flat-out play and is, without legitimate argument against it, on the list of the greatest players ever.
http://www.basketball-reference.com/.../birdla01.html
Check out the reactions of the Hawks bench during the last two minutes of the video.
Last edited by sailorsaint; 11-23-2014 at 04:08 AM.
Reason: removed error regarding arc distance....