Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
181 30.42%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
317 53.28%
Therapist
8 1.34%
George Mikan
5 0.84%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.53%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
13 2.18%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.36%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.50%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.51%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 3.03%

08-09-2017 , 04:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

When more than 50% of teams and 2 dynasties won without your stat being important, I'd reconsider your points.

i don't know where you got the 50% figure from - most champions rank in the top 10 for assists

but obviously, teams can still win with sub-par assists and teamwork if they have great talent - examples of this include lebron's big 3 teams, the celtics big 4 teams, the shaq/kobe duo, and also the bad boys super-team (who also revolutionized defense)..

but nearly every other champion in the last 30 years ranked in the top 10 for assists.


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

I think teamwork is important but that isn't the only reason teams win.

teams that lack great teamwork might win a few rings based on talent, but they also lose to lesser-talented teams who offset the talent deficit with better teamwork (i.e. detroit in 04' and mavs in 11')..

otoh, jordan's teams weren't susceptible to being upset by teams with better teamwork, because his team had the best teamwork in the league (similar to the spurs or warriors)

ultimately, why can't lebron's teams have great teamwork like spurs/warriors/bulls, so they aren't susceptible to being upset by lesser talented teams?.. the dream team talent is there to have great teamwork, but there's something holding them back... hmmmm... wonder what it is.............

oh, i got it - i see the problem here looking at the stats.. apparently, Lebron's point guard style utilizes an abnormally high time of possession for a forward, which reduces his teammates' time of possession and playmaking opportunity - specifically, every teammate saw their assists decline alongside Lebron, so the TEAM had low assist rankings/teamwork and needed super-team talent to win


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

Likewise, all of these teams had years to mature together and weren't built inorganically so they could figure out things over time and experience and likely test things out while the inorganic teams have to figure things out quicker.

Lebron was granted super-teams that could win right away

How is that harder than waiting years for a team to develop into contenders?

You act like maturing into a championship team is automatic - it isn't - it takes time and perseverance, which is why it's harder than being granted super-teams that can compete for rings right away


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

I honestly don't think the heat would have struggled if wade was healthier/younger at the end of their tenure. The cavs are fine in most situations where the warriors especially with Durant don't exist.

The Bulls still won the championship in 1998 when Pippen was injured and contributing less, because they had great teamwork to offset the loss in talent.

Otoh, Lebron's teams collapse when there's a reduction in talent because his teams are based on talent, not teamwork
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Wo usually nothing to back your faulty logic.
Shocking.
Explain to me the success of the lakers as soon magic join it and Kareem went down in the finals...

Same with bird...
I wasnt talking about that.

I was talking about long term success. so was the post I quoted.

its a fact that a group of players is not able to have long term success unless they stay together for a long time.

here, Ill give you another hint, since clearly logic is not you strong suit. long term success is not necessary for short term success.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Wo usually nothing to back your faulty logic.
Shocking.
Explain to me the success of the lakers as soon magic join it and Kareem went down in the finals...

Same with bird...
seriously, this post is hilarious. we are talking about long term success.

and you come at me with the most short term success possible. winning in the very first year.

like wtf? how are you so bad at this.

I cant stop thinking about this. like, I went to do something else and this just kept gnawing at me. how can someone possibly be so completely devoid of logic and analytic ability?

my statement was the equivalent of 1=1. and you still try to refute it. truly amazing.

and really scary that we are the same species. human race is undoubtedly doomed.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

It's all that easy right?

Basically Jordan didn't win till Pippen and Grant were good enough. When he had a good enough team, they won titles.

right, but pippen/grant is pretty thin talent for a 3-peat dynasty team


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

So basically, I could wake up in 1987, Pippen first year and we replace Pippen with any other HOF rookie.....

and MJ is magically a world beater in 1987--takes out Detroit/Boston/Lakers all in 1 year?

since when do the 2011 mavs = 80's lakers/celtics

most all-time greats would've beaten that mavs team, regardless of the year - there's no way around that - lebron averaged 17 ppg and was scared as ****.. lol, it still makes me laugh


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

Wade and MJ

wade and mj would fit like a glove

wade would play on-ball and jordan off-ball, like he normally did anyway..

ultimately, jordan had elite off-ball skill, so he could realize synergies with wade, whereas lebron can't play off-ball, so they clashed.. it's pretty simple.


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

MJ wouldn't have a super elite, dominant wing to guard the top SG/SF/PF on the other team like Pippen does.

do you enjoy making things up?...

who guarded HOF drexler?

who guarded HOF miller?

who guarded HOF magic for most of the series?

so what the hell are you talking about?

it's a simple fact that jordan was assigned the other team's best perimeter player, not pippen..

the only exception is when penny destroyed pippen for 25 ppg on 48% in 96 ecf, while doing nothing the times jordan guarded him (1 point on 1-5 fg with 3 turnovers, all possessions shown here)

btw, wade was 2nd team all-defense and 1st team all-nba in 2010 before joining lebron.. so lebron DID have an all-pro defender on the wing - not that it matters in this comparison, because jordan guarded the opponent's best perimeter player, not pippen.. hope that helps


Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0

My point with that comment is MJ/Pippen wasn't successful year 1

smh... rookie pippen was a bench player who averaged 7 ppg

so there was no "mj/pippen" in 1988... or 1989 for that matter.. it was just MJ and the "Jordannaires" as Bill Laimbeer called his scrub supporting cast

infact, Laimbeer said of Pippen: "We didn't even think about Scottie Pippen. It was Michael Jordan and the Jordannaires - and you can't win championships like that with only 1 player"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xqC74bv46Z8&t=1h07m33s


so whenever you think that lebron did more with less, understand that jordan's casts were weaker than lebron's thru 1989 - nonetheless, jordan's 1989 run is the biggest carry-job and overachievement in history... lebron's 2007 run is a smaller overachievement, as the stats clearly show
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
Firstly, I'm pretty disappointed in myself and question wtf I'm doing with my life.

Having said that I've had plenty of constructive conversation in here with other posters.
To be fair you were collateral damage. It just happened that the post count of you and capone0 added up to a round figure. On a word-per-post basis I assume he has you crushed.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:33 PM
Like, capone still posting at this fury in this thread is unreal

He has to be at 100+ life hours on this thread alone by now between posting and reading and yelling and contemplating
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, & borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:43 PM
OMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG C-VIGGITY <3 <3 <3
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:49 PM
this whole thread is a ruse to bring fidstar into TZ, quality poster
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
seriously, this post is hilarious. we are talking about long term success.

and you come at me with the most short term success possible. winning in the very first year.

like wtf?.
I see so you are saying the lakers did not have long term success after magic join the lakers and won the NBA title ?
Ok....
Everything you said after seem you were talking about yourself !

Point was magic join the lakers and won right there.
After , they still had long term success .

So where was the needed of long term playing together you advocate for ?
See... before speaking about others look at yourself.

Talent is key, not long term **** your talking about...
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 05:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

teammate assists is not a proxy for teamwork.

it's a solid proxy for teamwork, better than anyone else has come up with itt


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

teammate assists is also not a great indicator of championships or offensive output,

i don't know if assists are an "indicator", but most championship teams have top 10 assist rankings, except a few teams with great talent

so i'll say the same thing that i said originally: championship teams tend to rank highly in assists and great teamwork

this is true - i don't know what else to say



Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

lebron was not gifted hall of fame teammates or great team situations.

of course he was - bosh and wade are HOF's and were all-nba before joining lebron

lebron joined arguably the best pf and sg in the league - how can any situation be better than that?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

instead he dragged flawed teammates to heights that they had never even sniffed before

jordan dragged his team more

thru 1989, jordan had worse casts than ANY cast lebron had in his career

and jordan did more with his weaker casts - see his 1989 playoff run, which was a bigger overachievement than lebron's 2007 run, as the stats clearly show


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

and did so with absolutely amazing statistical output

not as amazing as jordan's - jordan has higher career PER and ws/48

ultimately, jordan averages 5 more points in the playoffs with better efficiency, and only 1 less assist (offset by fewer turnovers)

obviously, lebron would be a FAR more dominant player if he averaged 5 more ppg with better efficiency

(both guys shoot 57% TS in playoffs, but jordan's per possession efficiency is higher... his ortg)


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

and some of the greatest pressure packed clutch performances of all time.

c'mon bro, don't bring up clutch performances - lebron isn't even in the top 100 in that category

whereas jordan is #1...


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

as capone and fidstar definitively showed earlier.

they argued against points that i didn't make

i.e. there's many teams that won rings without leading league in assists, so therefore ur wrong..

that was fidstar's counter to my point that lebron teams underachieve their talent due to his reduction of team assists and teamwork


Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

lebron has won 3 titles and contributed enough to his team's teamwork to actually beat 2 teams that had more talent than his. the 2013 spurs and 2016 warriors.

The 2013 Heat had more talent than the 2013 Spurs.. that's obvious

and kyrie/love > klay/draymond

the warriors' won 73 games so people assumed they had better talent - but they forgot about TEAMWORK - the warriors won more games because their teamwork was vastly superior to the cavs, not their talent
.

Last edited by 609; 08-09-2017 at 06:17 PM.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 06:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 609
i don't know if assists are an "indicator", but most championship teams have top 10 assist rankings, except a few teams with great talent

so i'll say the same thing that i said originally: championship teams tend to rank highly in assists and great teamwork
championship teams tend to be top 10 in most stats, there's only 30 teams in the league
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 06:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fallen Hero

championship teams tend to be top 10 in most stats, there's only 30 teams in the league

too bad lebron's teams average a 15 ranking in assists for his career

lesser teamwork prevents lebron's teams from being as good as they could be

ultimately, why can't lebron's teams have great teamwork like spurs/warriors/bulls, so his teams are BETTER like those teams were?.. the dream team talent is there to have great teamwork, but there's something holding them back... hmmmm... wonder what it is.............

oh, i got it - i see the problem here looking at the stats.. apparently, Lebron's point guard style utilizes an abnormally high time of possession for a forward, which reduces his teammates' time of possession and playmaking opportunity - specifically, every teammate saw their assists decline alongside Lebron, so the TEAM had low assist rankings/teamwork and needed super-team talent to win
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 06:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 609
it's hard to say whether lebron is on kobe's level because he team-hopped
Agree that team hopping reflects poorly on Lebron's legacy. No other top 5 all time players did that(possibly Shaq if you consider him top 5 and that hurt his legacy as well). Jabaar was traded but he didn't call up Worthy and Magic saying "Let's make a super team."

I know the argument is "But Cleveland didn't enough help for him when he left." Look at Dirk, he did more with less help than any great player ever. He didn't run to San Antonio or the Lakers to make a super team he played with what they had and eventually won a championship.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 06:40 PM
maybe because mark cuban is the owner and would give his left testicle to keep dirk happy.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 06:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
I see so you are saying the lakers did not have long term success after magic join the lakers and won the NBA title ?
Ok....
Everything you said after seem you were talking about yourself !

Point was magic join the lakers and won right there.
After , they still had long term success .

So where was the needed of long term playing together you advocate for ?
See... before speaking about others look at yourself.

Talent is key, not long term **** your talking about...
no dude. I am saying to achieve long term success, you must play together for the long term.

tell me how it is possible to have long term success in the short term?

its in the damn term. long term.

so all this crap about lebron not being able to achieve long term success on his teams is idiotic bc he was never in that position. if he had been with wade for his entire career, then he would have won a bunch more titles. if he was able to be with wade for the long term, then they absolutely would have achieved long term success.

as it was, he won 2 titles in 4 years which is pretty damn good. esp considering they beat one of the best all time teams in the spurs. proly woulda beaten them twice if wade didnt decline hard.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 07:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 609


c'mon bro, don't bring up clutch performances - lebron isn't even in the top 100 in that category

whereas jordan is #1...
its pretty amazing that in a thread full of complete idiocy with thousands of posts you are still able to outdo yourself and find a way to say the most idiotic and wrong thing.

have you actually watched the nba and lebron james?

I actually doubt it if you actually believe this. if so, you missed the game 6 vs the celtics. the 4th qtr vs the spurs. all 3 of the final games in 2016. 2015 game winner vs the bulls. 2009 game winning 3 vs the magic. game 6 and 7 vs the spurs.

theres a ton more too.

I actually feel sorry for you that you cant appreciate such amazing performances bc for some reason you are blinded by hatred. truly pathetic. like, why even follow the nba if you are gonna deny such performances?
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 07:04 PM
I love how every team the Lebronze played against is referred to as the best of all time. Mark Cuban probably did everything for Dirk since dirk wasn't a passive aggressive loser. If wade would have played his whole career w Lebronze he would probably have one less title.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RunninCM
I love how every team the Lebronze played against is referred to as the best of all time. Mark Cuban probably did everything for Dirk since dirk wasn't a passive aggressive loser. If wade would have played his whole career w Lebronze he would probably have one less title.
Pretty sure only the warriors are and the stats back that's up. The spurs have been very good but hardly goatish. With wade playing like aids on both o and d, they had no shot in the rematch.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RunninCM
I love how every team the Lebronze played against is referred to as the best of all time. Mark Cuban probably did everything for Dirk since dirk wasn't a passive aggressive loser. If wade would have played his whole career w Lebronze he would probably have one less title.
Yeah totally. Wade went to 4 straight and won 2 with Lebron while Wades ability was falling apart, they probably would have went like 0-6 the years prior with both in their primes.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
no dude. I am saying to achieve long term success, you must play together for the long term.

tell me how it is possible to have long term success in the short term?

its in the damn term. long term.

so all this crap about lebron not being able to achieve long term success on his teams is idiotic bc he was never in that position. if he had been with wade for his entire career, then he would have won a bunch more titles. if he was able to be with wade for the long term, then they absolutely would have achieved long term success.

as it was, he won 2 titles in 4 years which is pretty damn good. esp considering they beat one of the best all time teams in the spurs. proly woulda beaten them twice if wade didnt decline hard.
You just prove you are wrong with lebron....
How many NBA title with different team and reaching the NBA final did lebron do?
Where is the long term when he just keep changing team and will again after next season ....?

Long term means ****, talent means a lot more ...
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:19 PM
not every team. but certainly the warriors. I mean, they won 73 games the year after winning a title in an extremely tough conference.

if you check the $tat$ on the spurs and look at their roster then its pretty apparent that they are on the all-time great level.

oh ya and cant forget the celtics with garnett, allen, and pierce.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor

if he had been with wade for his entire career, then he would have won a bunch more titles. if he was able to be with wade for the long term, then they absolutely would have achieved long term success.
LOL i hope so !
If you want lebron to be the goat, doing less with better players would not workout for lebron to be the goat .
Unless you would take pippen over wade lol .....

That is the point all along, MJ probably had the weakest help has his number 2 and number 3 but still was able to achieve greatness and create a dynasty !

Ps: you are saying like lebron did not achieve long term success despise he did not played long term with the same player.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
LOL i hope so !
If you want lebron to be the goat, doing less with better players would not workout for lebron to be the goat .
Unless you would take pippen over wade lol .....

That is the point all along, MJ probably had the weakest help has his number 2 and number 3 but still was able to achieve greatness and create a dynasty !
Maybe the competition was poor then. I don't agree that pippen was weak, his greatest value d, isn't properly measured or valued.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
You just prove you are wrong with lebron....
How many NBA title with different team and reaching the NBA final did lebron do?
Where is the long term when he just keep changing team and will again after next season ....?

Long term means ****, talent means a lot more ...
awesome. we agree. so nice that you have disavowed all that garbage about lebron not being able to win championships long term.

hopefully you agree that if by some chance lebron and wade ended up together early in their careers then they certainly would have achieved amazing long term success.
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote
08-09-2017 , 08:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
awesome. we agree. so nice that you have disavowed all that garbage about lebron not being able to win championships long term.

hopefully you agree that if by some chance lebron and wade ended up together early in their careers then they certainly would have achieved amazing long term success.
Can you read ?
Please tell me where I said lebron did not have long term success ?
I was the one advocating long term success is not needed to play with the same individuals long term and lebron proved it.
Talent is what is needed !
LeBron = GOAT Containment Thread: SABR42, LuckyLloyd, &amp; borg23 Co-MVPs b/c of post #20163 Quote

      
m