One idea for scoring or whatever would be to take a year and have each studio use their cast to make that year's blockbuster, best picture, and best comedy and whatever else you want to use here (best indy?). Obviously time constraints in the filming/production process would prohibit the same group of actors being the lead in each film, but perhaps a lead in the blockbuster could land a supporting role in that years best picture as well or something more minor.

We would then vote on each category's cast or something.

this works. although i like my picture.

as for a cutoff: I see the argument, but i dont mind if people get late round sleepers that way.

This should be pretty much exactly what you're looking for.

perfect

How many people are we capping this at?

Any way we could start this immediately as soon as we get enough participants but not have a time limit until Jan 2nd?

This lets us get started, but it doesn't penalize anyone who isn't around during holiday season.

i really hope i don't get the first pick because there's someone who i think is far and away the #1 pick but i don't want to have to defend it

Love this idea

"Billy Madison 2" and "Tommy Boy 2" are long overdue.

Just a moment ago I had an extensive conversation with a friend, who convinced me that my guy might actually be the number 2 pick and could be argued as the third best choice. I would still take him number 1 but it might be a difficult case to argue.

Let's not forget about Punch Drunk Love 2, and Fat Guy in a Little Coat: The Reckoning.

pencil me in for this. sounds fun.

besides - I just watched Dude Wheres My Car?...so I got a pretty good plan going in now.

I def want the number one pick.

Ok, I'm in, but I just want everyone to know that if you disagree with me, you have **** taste. That goes for you, too, tuq.

Also can we please do writers?