OP is kinda dated and confusing (and this thread very long and hard to navigate) but this so far is the end result:
http://300bestplayersintheworld.blogspot.com/
Not MEANT to be an end result of course but not sure when I'll do some updating. Haven't even looked at it in a while (sure there are many changes begging to be made already+mistakes to be corrected) and won't have much time the next few weeks.
edit:
The whole thing:
1. Lionel Messi - Argentina - Barcelona
2. Cristiano Ronaldo - Portugal - Real Madrid
3. Xavi - Spain - Barcelona
4. Andrés Iniesta - Spain - Barcelona
5. Cesc Fabregas - Spain - Arsenal
6. Didier Drogba - Ivory Coast - Chelsea
7. Carlos Tevez - Argentina - Manchester City
8. Samuel Eto'o - Cameroun - Inter
9. Zlatan Ibrahimovic - Sweden - Milan
10. Xabi Alonso - Spain - Real Madrid
11. David Villa - Spain - Barcelona
12. Wayne Rooney - England - Manchester United
13. Wesley Sneijder - Netherlands - Inter
14. Sergio Aguero - Argentina - Atletico Madrid
15. Diego Forlan - Uruguay - Atletico Madrid
16. Fernando Torres - Spain - Liverpool
17. Mesut Özil - Germany - Real Madrid
18. Gonzalo Higuain - Argentina - Real Madrid
19. Frank Lampard - England - Chelsea
20. Arjen Robben - Netherlands - Bayern München
21. Angel Di Maria - Argentina - Real Madrid
22. Edin Dzeko - Bosnia and Herzegovina - Wolfsburg
23. Steven Gerrard - England - Liverpool
24. Mikel Essien - Ghana - Chelsea
25. Kaka - Brazil - Real Madrid
26. Marek Hamsik - Slovakia - Napoli
27. Yaya Tore - Ivory Coast - Manchester City
28. Thomas Müller - Germany - Bayern München
29. Gareth Bale - Wales - Tottenham
30. Esteban Cambiasso - Argentina - Inter
31.Sebastian Schweinsteiger - Germany - Bayern München
32. Florent Malouda - France - Chelsea
33. Dani Alves - Brazil - Barcelona
34. Yoann Gourcuff - France - Lyon
35. David Silva - Spain - Manchester City
36. Maicon - Brazil - Inter
37. Luka Modric - Croatia -Tottenham
38. Franck Ribery - France - Bayern München
39. Lisandro Lopez - Argentina - Lyon
40. Samir Nasri - France - Arsenal
41. Lucho Gonzalez - Argentina - Marseille
42. Nicolas Anelka - France - Chelsea
43. Hernanes - Brazil - Lazio
44. Santi Cazorla - Spain - Villarreal
45. Rafael Van der Vaart - Netherlands - Tottenham
46. Alexandre Pato - Brazil - Milan
47. Diego - Brazil - Wolfsburg
48. Nani - Portugal - Manchester United
49. Robin Van Persie - Netherlands - Arsenal
50. Nuri Sahin - Turkey - Dortmund
51. Ever Banega - Argentina - Valencia
52. Luis Suarez - Uruguay - Ajax
53. Sami Khedira - Germany - Real Madrid
54. Seydou Keita - Mali - Barcelona
55. Daniele De Rossi - Italy - Roma
56. Luis Fabiano - Brazil - Sevilla
57. Diego Milito - Argentina - Inter
58. Juan Mata - Spain - Valencia
59. Andrea Pirlo - Italy - Milan
60. Robinho - Brazil - Milan
61. Pedro - Spain - Barcelona
62. Philipp Lahm - Germany - Bayern München
63. Ashley Cole - England - Chelsea
64. Mario Gomez - Germany - Bayern München
65. Jesus Navas - Spain - Sevilla
66. Ramires - Brazil - Chelsea
67. Marouane Chamakh - Marocco - Arsenal
68. Eden Hazard - Belgium - Lille
69. Karim Benzema - France - Real Madrid
70. Lucas Barrios - Paraguay - Dortmund
71. Fernando Llorente - Spain - Athletic Bilbao
72. Paul Scholes - England - Manchester United
73. Dimitar Berbatov - Bulgaria - Manchester United
74. Giuseppe Rossi - Italy - Villarreal
75. Sergio Busquets - Spain - Barcelona
76. Javier Zanetti - Argentina - Inter
77. Patrice Evra - France - Manchester United
78. Edinson Cavani - Uruguay - Napoli
79. Andrei Arshavin - Russia - Arsenal
80. Stevan Jovetic - Montenegro - Fiorentina
81. Darren Fletcher - Scotland - Manchester United
82. Javier Mascherano - Argentina - Barcelona
83. Nemanja Vidic - Serbia - Manchester United
84. Mikel Arteta - Spain - Everton
85. Rio Ferdinand - England - Manchester United
86. Mario Balotelli - Italy - Manchester City
87. Giorgio Chiellini - Italy - Juventus
88. Miralem Pjanic - Bosnia and Herzegovina - Lyon
89. Michel Bastos - Brazil - Lyon
90. Fabio Coentrao - Portugal - Benfica
91. Ricardo Carvalho - Portugal - Real Madrid
92. Marouane Fellaini - Belgium - Everton
93. Antonio Valencia - Ecuador - Manchester United
94. Javier Pastore - Argentina - Palermo
95. Joao Moutinho - Portugal - FC Porto
96. Antonio Di Natale - Italy - Udinese
97. Aaron Lennon - England - Tottenham
98. Mirko Vucinic - Montenegro - Roma
99. Ivica Olic - Croatia - Bayern München
100. David Pizarro - Chile - Roma
101. Carlos Puyol - Spain - Barcelona
102. Sergio Ramos - Spain - Real Madrid
103. John Terry - England - Chelsea
104. Branislav Ivanovic - Serbia - Chelsea
105. Bacary Sagna - France - Arsenal
106. Ganso - Brazil - Santos
107. Alexandre Song - Cameroun - Arsenal
108. Lucio - Brazil - Inter
109. Toni Kroos - Germany - Bayern München
110. Antonio Cassano - Italy - Sampdoria
111. Nilmar - Brazil - Villarreal
112. Dirk Kuyt - Netherlands - Liverpool
113. Michael Carrick - England - Manchester United
114. Milos Krasic - Serbia - Juventus
115. Ashley Young - England - Aston Villa
116. Marko Marin - Germany - Werder Bremen
117. Arturo Vidal - Chile - Bayer Leverkusen
118. Anderson - Brazil - Manchester United
119. Ibrahim Afellay - Netherlands - Barcelona
120. Alberto Aquilani - Italy - Juventus
121. Claudio Marchisio - Italy - Juventus
122. Simao - Portugal - Atletico Madrid
123. Neymar - Brazil - Santos
124. Tim Cahill - Australia - Everton
125. Gerard Pique - Spain - Barcelona
126. Keisuke Honda - Japan - CSKA Moscov
127. Klaas Jan Huntelaar - Netherlands - Schalke 04
128. Andy Carroll - England - Newcastle
129. Emmanuel Adebayor - Togo - Manchester City
130. Ji Sung Park - South Kora - Manchester United
131. Nigel De Jong - Netherlands - Manchester City
132. Michael Ballack - Germany - Bayer Leverkusen
133. Steven Pienaar - South Africa - Everton
134. Frederic Kanoute - Mali - Sevilla
135. Hulk - Brazil - FC Porto
136. Pepe - Portugal - Real Madrid
137. Thiago Silva - Brazil - Milan
138. Konstantin Zyryanov - Russia - Zenit
139. Goran Pandev - Macedonia - Inter
140. Gareth Barry - England - Manchester City
141. Thomas Vermaelen - Belgium - Arsenal
142. Dejan Stankovic - Serbia - Inter
143. Shinji Kagawa - Japan - Dortmund
144. Yohan Cabaye - France - Lille
145. Mark Van Bommel - Netherlands - Bayern München
146. James Milner - England - Manchester City
147. Tom Huddlestone - England - Tottenham
148. Marcelo - Brazil - Real Madrid
149. Gervinho - Ivory Coast - Lille
150. Javier Hernandez - Mexico - Manchester United
151. Loic Remy - France - Marseille
152. Zvjezdan Misimovic - Bosnia and Herzegovina - Galatasaray
153. Jefferson Farfan - Peru - Schalke 04
154. Joaquin - Spain - Valencia
155. Alexis Sanchez - Chile -Udinese
156. Marcos Senna - Spain - Villarreal
157. Lass Diarra - France - Real Madrid
158. Javi Martinez - Spain - Athletic Bilbao
159. Jack Wilshire - England - Arsenal
160. Scott Parker - England - West Ham
161. Jeremy Menez - France - Roma
162. Ryan Giggs - Wales - Manchester United
163. Elano - Brazil - Santos
164. Adam Johnson - England - Manchester City
165. Ze Roberto - Brazil - Hamburger SV
166. Jose Bosingwa - Portugal - Chelsea
167. Andre Ayew - Ghana - Marseille
168. Borja Valero - Spain - Villarreal
169. Pablo Hernandez - Spain - Valencia
170. Ezequiel Lavezzi - Argentina - Napoli
171. Alvaro Negredo - Spain - Sevilla
172. Jerman Defoe - England - Tottenham
173. Giampaolo Pazzini - Italy - Sampdoria
174. Alberto Gilardino - Italy - Fiorentina
175. Jimmy Briand - France - Lyon
176. Charles N'Zogbia - France - Wigan
177. Alou Diarra - France - Bordeaux
178. Vincent Kompany - Belgium - Manchester City
179.Luiz Gustavo - Brazil - Bayern München
180. Simon Rolfes - Germany - Bayer Leverkusen
181. Asamoah Gyan - Ghana - Sunderland
182. Lucas - Brazil - Liverpool
183. Abou Diaby - France - Arsenal
184. Radamel Falcao - Colombia - FC Porto
185. Yuri Zhirkov - Russia - Chelsea
186. Fernando Meirelles - Portugal - Liverpool
187. Riccardo Montolivo - Italy - Fiorentina
188. Francesco Totti - Italy - Roma
189. Mamadou Niang - Senegal - Fenerbahce
190. David Luiz - Brazil - Benfica
191. Humberto Suazo - Chile - Monterrey
192. Bojan Krkick - Spain - Barcelona
193. Darijo Srna - Croatia - Shaktar Donetsk
194. Andres Guardado - Mexico - Deportivo La Coruna
195. Jeremy Toulalan - France - Lyon
196. Darren Bent - England - Sunderland
197. Jon Obi Mikel - Nigeria - Chelsea
198. Walter Gargano - Uruguay - Napoli
199. Felipe Melo - Brazil - Juventus
200. Mathieu Valbuena - France - Marseille
201. Danny - Portugal - Zenit
202. Mario Götze - Germany - Dortmund
203. Theo Walcott - England - Arsenal
204. Raul - Spain - Schalke 04
205.Diego Perotti - Argentina - Sevilla
206. Juan Manuel Vargas - Peru - Fiorentina
207. Rafael - Brazil - Manchester United
208. Josip Ilicic - Slovenia - Palermo
209. Jose Manuel Jurado - Spain - Schalke 04
210. Roman Pavluchenko - Russia - Tottenham
211. Alessandro Nesta - Italy - Milan
212. Arda Turan - Turkey - Galatasaray
213. Marco Borriello - Italy - Roma
214. Oskar Cardozo - Paraguay - Benfica
215. Romelu Lukaku - Belgium - Anderlecht
216. Juan - Brazil - Roma
217. Joan Capdevilla - Spain - Villarreal
218.Bruno Alves - Portugal - Zenit
219. Marco Reus - Germany - Mönchengladbach
220. Salomon Kalou - Ivory Coast - Chelsea
221. Eljero Elia - Netherlands - Hamburger SV
222. Alan Dzagoev - Russia - CSKA Moscov
223. Anatolij Tymoshchuk - Ukraine - Bayern München
224. Aritz Aduriz - Spain - Valencia
225. Royston Drenthe - Netherlands - Hercules
226. Jordan Henderson - England -Sunderland
227. Manuel Fernandez - Portugal - Besiktas
228. Diego Costa - Brazil - Atletico Madrid
229. Landon Donovan - USA - LA Galaxy
230. Diego Godin - Uruguay - Atletico Madrid
231. Alberto Costa - Argentina - Valencia
232. Eren Derdiyok - Switzerland - Bayer Leverkusen
233. Cacau - Germany - VfB Stuttgart
234. Bryan Ruiz - Costa Rica - Twente
235. Miroslav Klose - Germany - Bayern München
236. Peter Crouch - England - Tottenham
237. Danko Lazovic - Serbia - Zenit
238. Lee Chung Young - South Korea - Bolton
239. Stefan Kiessling - Germany - Bayer Leverkusen
240. Alejandro "Chori" Dominguez - Argentina - Valencia
241. Moussa Dembele - Belgium - Fullham
242. Kevin Prince Boateng - Ghana - Milan
243. Bruno Soriano - Spain -Villarreal
244. Mats Hummels - Germany - Dortmund
245. Nicklas Bendtner - Denmark - Arsenal
246. Juan Sebastian Veron - Argentina - Estudiantes
247. Giovani dos Santos - Mexico - Galatasaray
248. Tomas Rosicky - Czech Republic - Arsenal
249. Deco - Portugal - Fluminese
250. Miguel Veloso -Portugal - Genoa
251. Vincenzo Iaquinta - Italy - Juventus
252. Wendel - Brazil - Bordeaux
253. Ronaldinho - Brazil - Milan
254. Riquelme - Argentina - Boca Juniors
255. Gokhan Inler - Switzerland - Udinese
256. Pappiss Cisse - Senegal - Frankfurt
257. Jorge Fucile - Uruguay - FC Porto
258. Kevin Nolan - England - Newcastle
259. Ruud Van Nistelrooy - Netherlands - Hamburger SV
260. Gabriel Heinze - Argentina - Marseille
261. Carlos Eduardo - Brazil - Rubin Kazan
262. Moussa Sow - Senegal - Lille
263. Alexandr Kerzhakov - Russia - Zenit
264. Yann M'Vila - France - Rennes
265. Nicolas Otamendi - Argentina - FC Porto
266. Andre Schürrle - Germany - Mainz
267. Benoit Tremoulinas - France - Bordeaux
268. Diego Lugano - Uruguay - Fenerbahce
269. Fabio Quagliarella - Italy - Juventus
270. Robert Lewandowski - Poland - Dortmund
271. Tiago - Portugal - Atletico Madrid
272. Joe Cole - England - Liverpool
273. Roberto Soldado - Spain - Valencia
274. Armin Bacinovic - Slovenia - Palermo
275. Tomas Necid - Czech Republic - CSKA Moscow
276. Antonio Reyes - Spain - Atletico Madrid
277. Domenico Criscito - Italy - Genoa
278. Gregory Van der Wiel - Netherlands - Ajax
279. Kim Källström - Sweden - Lyon
280. Bafetimbi Gomis - France - Lyon
281. Park Chu Young - South Korea - Monaco
282. Ivan Ratikic - Croatia - Schalke 04
283. Wilson Palacios - Honduras - Tottenham
284. Aly Cissokho - France - Lyon
285. Alex - Brazil - Chelsea
286. Lewis Holtby - Germany - Mainz
287. Grafite - Brazil - Wolfsburg
288. Fernando Gago - Argentina - Real Madrid
289. Jaroslav Plasil - Czech Republic - Bordeaux
290. Sergio Pellissier - Italy - Chievo
291. Andrea Cossu - Italy - Cagliari
292. Gerrardo Torrado - Mexico - Cruz Azul
293. Gabriel Agbonlahor - England - Aston Villa
294. Sven Bender - Germany - Dortmund
295. Fabrice Muamba - England - Bolton
296. Gonzalo Castro - Germany - Bayer Leverkusen
297. Vladimir Bystrov - Russia - Zenit
298. Hugo Campagnaro - Argentina - Napoli
299. Lukas Podolski - Germany - FC Köln
300. Patrik Helmes - Germany - Bayer Leverkusen