Quote:
Originally Posted by All-In Flynn
If your main point is that vilifying Islamophobes bigots is wrong, then I have to disagree. Take the Ground Zero mosque, for example. All kinds of people got super worked up about that, but you could easily say their concerned were directed at Islam rather than at Muslims (it could be debated, but the position isn't ludicrous). Does that mean I shouldn't criticise the absurdity and hypocrisy and bigotry of those people, if I see it?
Muslims had (and have) every right to build a mosque wherever they want pursuant to zoning regulations. Anything else would seem like clear discrimination. That's just constitutional law.
But if you saw videos of those planes crashing full speed into buildings on 9/11 and now can't get on a plane because you have an irrational fear that an Islamic terrorist could be on board who will blow your plane out of the sky, that's a legit phobia in my opinion. It's irrational, but legit.
Terrorist images can be horrific. Especially, if you know a victim or someone who does. Images of people having their heads lopped off on video can have deep and lasting devastating effects on one's emotional psyche (in other words, the terrorist act was effective). These people do not have to be bigots any more than someone who witnessed a plane crash caused by an engine pylon falling off during takeoff won't fly for fear that their plane's engine might not be secured properly.
Having a fear of radical Islam is quite different than hating Muslims or thinking they are all bad people. You can even concede that 1,399,999,900 Muslims out of 1.4B are good peaceful people (just as you can conceded that 99.9% of all aircraft takeoffs won't crash), and still have a phobia. That's what makes it a phobia!