Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisV
Can do.
Sourced from The Atlantic. Graph shows the return each state gets for every $1 given to the federal govt.
States getting over $2 back include KY, WV, MS, AL, LA, FL and SC.
Hi Chris,
I have never understood this graph that has been posted many time as evidence. The article says the graph indicates " how much the federal government spends per person in each state compared with the amount its citizens pay in federal income taxes"
How is Hawaii listed as the 5th largest taker on this list yet has the 8th highest percapita income?
How is North Dakota listed as the second biggest taker while it has the second lowest % of people on food stamps:
One explanation is offered by the piece you sited, namely:
"Part of the explanation for why southern states dominate the “most dependent” category is historical. During the many decades in the 20th century when the South was solidly Democratic, its congressional representatives in both the House and the Senate, enjoying great seniority, came to hold leadership positions on powerful committees, which they used to send federal dollars back to their home states in the form of contracts, projects, installations. "
Not arguing that Alabama and other similar states don't have poorer economies, but the "proof" you sited is somewhat contaminated with large confounders.