Quote:
Originally Posted by Alan C. Lawhon
DVaut:
The relatively quick settlement was a combination of two factors. Gretchen Carlson's lawyer, when asked the specific question as to how strong her client's evidence was, emphatically stated that they were "very confident" with the evidence they had. (This was in direct contradiction of Ailes vehement denials.) Shortly after that, Gabriel Sherman reported - in the New Yorker - that Ms. Carlson had voice recordings on her smartphone of private conversations between herself and Ailes where Mr. Ailes [allegedly] harassed her. (In the complaint filed back in July, one of those "conversations" - the one where Ailes purportedly told Gretchen that he "... had thought for a long time that he and Ms. Carlson should have had a sexual relationship" - was probably lifted verbatim from one of those [alleged] recordings. It probably did not require extraordinary powers of deduction to realize that if Ms. Carlson did indeed have voice recordings of Ailes, hearing it all in discovery was pointless.
Sure, whatever, fine. The point remains: they had Ailes nailed, and News Corp didn't even bother to hear the evidence.
As I said in my first post that adios disagreed with:
Quote:
If Murdoch is paying $20 mil to avoid discovery then Ailes must have just walked around with his dick out trying to orally sodomize every women in the office for like years. Seems like an unfathomable amount and I can think of no other reasonable explanation other than Ailes must have been a total predator, Carlson's lawyers had a zillion witnesses or other evidence to verify and guilt wasn't in question. So much monies.
adios came along to be like lol no, it went so quickly to avoid bad PR.
Which....OK. We all seem to have consensus here. You, adios, and I. They settled out for so fast so quickly because the proceedings were destined to be farcical and the outcome preordained: Roger Ailes was super guilty and everyone knew it. That they didn't even make Carlson's lawyers throw her iPhone on the table and play the recording(s) is demonstrative the case was super hopeless. They already knew it. Which is exactly what I said.
You can even go from there and note that by avoiding discovery, plus the humongous settlement -- just to avoid showing their hand -- probably spared News Corp from even further embarrassment about Ailes conduct. If Murdoch's lawyers had to turn their hand face up and turn over tons of ****ing witnesses and other stories of Ailes wretchedness and predatory behaviors, they had to be nervous it would have leaked. They were so confident Carlson had the goods and that whatever defenses they had tried to muster buried Ailes even further that they just dumped tons of money on Carlson to not even bother showing their hand.
Again, poker analogies are strained but it's like you show up for a game of poker then just hand all the money in your wallet to your opponent and throw the deck in the trash because if the other side even catches sight of the cards then you might have to go run to the ATM to pay off your opponent even more.
Last edited by DVaut1; 09-11-2016 at 04:23 PM.