Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
Nope! You've just changed the wording a bit! See, I bolded the word that you added in to suit your argument, that doesn't belong.
I can give to others, charitably, without it being in my "financial" interest, and it can still be in my 'self-interest', meaning, it makes me feel good to do it. I do it voluntarily, because I am satisfied by doing it.
Yes, personal feelings of satisfaction can be a motivator behind the drive to only pursue one's self interest. But money is a great evil, and it can easily sway people to go against their own personal sense of morality.
So if you told me an Ethical Egoist would probably hold the door open for someone, because it made them personally feel good, I'd agree that that could likely happen. But if you told me an Ethical Egoist would pay for someone's $30,000 dollar surgery, because it made them feel good, I would argue that the almighty dollar would almost certainly Trump their personal feelings.
You know the whole Ayn Rand "Capitalism is the only moral system of economics" shtick? The almighty dollar is God. And since health care is so expensive, providing charity in these regards is a whole lot of denying God. So I would argue that for people like this, "personal self interest" is usually limited solely to financial interest.
And I say this as someone who used to be an Ethical Egoist.
Last edited by AllCowsEatGrass; 03-10-2017 at 05:16 PM.