Quote:
Originally Posted by zikzak
There was a book I read far too long ago to remember the name of, or which respected university the author taught at, but the gist was that he took a quasi-scientific look at "golden age" cities throughout history and looked for patterns. What he found was that, in terms of meaningful, lasting cultural impact, one of the most prominent characteristics was cities that were slightly unstable. The greatness is rooted in the transience and uncertainty of a place in flux.
If you want to define culture as a comfortable life for yourself, then a well gentrified place with lots of tapas bars will certainly fit the bill. I am absolutely in no way criticizing that as a personal choice. But if you want to judge cities by their potential to make a major mark on the world stage, you need better metrics.
It isn't about personal preference, and it isn't about idealizing poverty or oldness or whatever. It's about trying to take an honest look at what a city has to offer at any given time and see which way it is going. I don't think it is unreasonable to say that as a touchstone of culture, SF is probably on the down slope. Its future, while almost certainly pleasant and comfortable for residents, seems unlikely to be an interesting one. It is only reaping the rewards of its past greatness.
By those conditions San Francisco is a non-entity as a city on the world stage of human history. Given that criteria, San Francisco is a poseur wanna-be and would be hard pressed to make a top 25 of current cities in the world (maybe even outside top 50).
He is right. Some people are saying "my kind of weird is good anything else is bad." Which is nonsense.
Ironically the most significant and lasting cultural development in that region is Silicon Valley and people want to disown that.
Silicon Valley has caused significant and lasting cultural changes world wide. Hippy dippy artists from San Francisco have had literally no impact. Turn of the 21st century San Francisco will be remembered as "That city by Silicon Valley".