Originally Posted by Lord_Ferus
to get some seriousness in here.. lets assume we play hu and hes otb and jams 100% of hands
is it better to call with hand strenghts Q8o+ 22+ etc or just calling with a tighter range lets say 77+ ATo+
Depends on the probability of him leaving after a) you winning and all-in or b) him winning an all-in.
If these probabilities are low then something like the first range is best and if they are high you are better off waiting for a greater edge.
In reality these sort of guys often don't stick around for more than a few all ins so we should be choosing a calling range stronger than your first range but I would say looser than the second range you give.