Hey guys, I guess that I'll start by saying that I am a fairly experienced hold'em player (~2000 hours mostly at 2/5 $1000 max, some at 5/10), but am fairly new to PLO (less than 100 hours live @ 2/5 and 2/5/10). The card room that I play at has recently began to run PLO games on a semi-regular basis due to the players requesting it.
I am now faced with a dilemma. I can beat the hold'em game very consistently. There are maybe a handful of players from the player pool that I would even consider competition to me, and lucky I know who all of them are and have created a dynamic such that we don't clash. Now these same bad hold'em players now want to play PLO everyday. I see that they are absolutely terrible at the game and frequently make big mistakes. But somehow I am unable to translate this into profit. I honestly think that I have run very poorly in the time that I have played PLO. I can never seem to win a whole pot. The story of my PLO life is as follows: Get stacks in with the nuts, sometimes with a redraw, run it twice, and chop. It is driving me ****ing insane. Just yesterday I got it in three ways with the overfull versus the underfull only to get 1 outed for a chop and a $3000 pot. I have read two of Jeff Hwang's books and understand the vast differences between PLO and HE, but of course experience is a crucial part of the learning curve.
The game I play in is pretty crazy. I am going to give an example of a situation that occurred last night when I was playing.
2/5 PLO game, 10 handed. My stack is ~$1000. This pot is triple straddled to $40. The $40 is to my immediate right, so I am first to act.
I am in MP and look down at: A

K

J

10
My plan at this point is to just call and either see a flop for $40, or depending on the action and whether or not someone raises (likely imo), re-pot it and try to get stacks in before the flop. Is this a seemingly profitable plan? I know that there are many hands that will stack off that I have dominated. I only really don't want to be up against kings or aces right?
So anyway, a few people call and the CO pots it to like $210, two players call, and sticking to the plan, I re-pot all-in. The pot ends up going 4-ways all-in before the flop. Now, I can't say that I got the exact suits right, but if someone was suited, I know I got that right. I am up against:
Q

J

8

7

K

9

4

3

A

J

10

9
Now, it seems to me that I have done well and that I have all of these hands dominated. But I run the numbers only to find out that I am like 15% to win the pot. I assume that this is the case because all of my outs are being held by my opponents. The question is should I continue with this strategy? Or should I wait for only aces or some middle to low double suited rundown to get it in before the flop? I understand that getting it in pre-flop is a tremendously high variance strategy and that unless I dominate my opponent, I can't really expect to better than a 2:1 favorite. I didn't run the numbers, but I assume that I have all these hands in bad shape if I am up against them individually.
Another situation that occurred that I am not entirely sure about. Sitting to my right is a player that is well known in my area. He has a ton of money and is not afraid to put it on the line. He is not a good card player. He is here to gamble. So far this session he has potted it before the flop with hands such as: J

4

4

3

.
I am on the button and straddle to $10, he, to my immediate right, re-straddles to $20...Zzz... effective stacks of about $1000.
I look down at: A

K

10

3
Again, the plan is to either see a flop for $20, or possibly get it in asap against the maniac to my right if he pots it. I flat the $20, 3 others call the $20 to the maniac. He pots it, I re-pot, and now the SB re-pots all-in for ~$1000. The maniac calls off the rest of his $1000. I am now sitting getting a bit better than 3:1 on a call knowing full well that I am likely against aces. I have to call here right?
I guess my question is should I stop trying to get all-in before the flop when I think I have my opponent dominated? Only wait for aces? What's the plan? Thanks for your input guys.