Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Selbst vs. McPhee Selbst vs. McPhee

12-11-2012 , 06:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
you guys are funny.

this sounds like a hand i TOTALLY would have berated you for. right. i love the stories from randoms about me flipping people off or berating people for no reason... like that EVER would have happened. if you're gonna complain about something i supposedly did five years ago to you, at least make it believable. it makes no sense that i would have berated you for a play that is 100% standard by the book poker.

the thing is... i've never been bitter or mean at the table, just very competitive. that means i never ever have "berated" people for completely standard plays, and i almost never "berated" amateurs. i just used to, admittedly, have a bad habit of getting upset about terrible plays from players i thought were supposed to be better than that. every now and again, when i get emotional for one reason or another, that comes up again. i think those that know me know that it's just a symptom of my hyper-competitive nature and i don't ever mean anything by it, but i get that it comes across poorly on TV. that's cool.

i'm sure people will always make up stories... i just thought the people who are actually watching might care to understand... sometimes when you're really caught up in the moment, you can get overly emotional when someone you think will act one way acts another. most of the time i'm just mad at myself for thinking one thing when another thing happened... i.e. i made a mistake, and i'm upset about that, and it comes across in a negative way. ah well, i'll continue to work on it and have this be rarer and rarer, most people will notice that, and i'm sure i'll also continue to read random made-up stories as well.

as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.


#TeamSelbst f the haters
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 07:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.
We both know you will never really get over it. It will sting every single time you see him from now on.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 01:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
you guys are funny.

this sounds like a hand i TOTALLY would have berated you for. right. i love the stories from randoms about me flipping people off or berating people for no reason... like that EVER would have happened. if you're gonna complain about something i supposedly did five years ago to you, at least make it believable. it makes no sense that i would have berated you for a play that is 100% standard by the book poker.

the thing is... i've never been bitter or mean at the table, just very competitive. that means i never ever have "berated" people for completely standard plays, and i almost never "berated" amateurs. i just used to, admittedly, have a bad habit of getting upset about terrible plays from players i thought were supposed to be better than that. every now and again, when i get emotional for one reason or another, that comes up again. i think those that know me know that it's just a symptom of my hyper-competitive nature and i don't ever mean anything by it, but i get that it comes across poorly on TV. that's cool.

i'm sure people will always make up stories... i just thought the people who are actually watching might care to understand... sometimes when you're really caught up in the moment, you can get overly emotional when someone you think will act one way acts another. most of the time i'm just mad at myself for thinking one thing when another thing happened... i.e. i made a mistake, and i'm upset about that, and it comes across in a negative way. ah well, i'll continue to work on it and have this be rarer and rarer, most people will notice that, and i'm sure i'll also continue to read random made-up stories as well.

as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.
believe what you wish, but i certainly remember all the (high stakes) hands i've played 4000 miles away from home against players i've previously seen on TV. that's exactly how the hand went. the only thing i'm not sure about is whether the flop was AQ6dd or AQ5dd. prior to this hand you had made comments that i seemed like just another crazy scandinavian kid. specifically remember you berating me on how i could call your 3bet pre with JT. i ofc felt that my play was 100% standard, but didn't see the point in explaining that to you or otherwise justifying the way i choose to play with my money. and even if my play hadn't been standard, i was absolutely dumbfounded by the fact that you choose to berate/educate random players you don't know, also on those times when you win. bottom line is you seemed as obnoxious back then as you did in that video.

nothing personal, i've only played with you once, but that's my first impression of you and i haven't seen the need to change it based on what i've seen of you on tv later.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 06:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by martre
believe what you wish, but i certainly remember all the (high stakes) hands i've played 4000 miles away from home against players i've previously seen on TV. that's exactly how the hand went..........

...........nothing personal, i've only played with you once, but that's my first impression of you and i haven't seen the need to change it based on what i've seen of you on tv later.
Don't you understand that her fans have declared that she has "pwned" you?

I find it telling that she not only accuses you of lying not once but twice but then goes to the bother of explaining what her standards are for her to "berate" someone...wtf?....and it's usally for players not living up to the high standards she demands of them - that's a clown comment if I've ever heard one.

She should just admit that she's a red-a$$ who flies off the handle when things sometimes don't go the way she expects and own it. That's a hell of a lot classier than her response here.


Players both famous and not-so-famous can be delta bravos, some make a habit of it even when they know it is being recorded for posterity. The key is to never let it bother you as much as it does them and this case you certainly appear to be the bigger person. The key for the red-a$$ is to grow the f**k up and act like an adult (or better yet like an adult profesional).
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 08:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lester Kluke
So you'd consider it wrong to berate an amateur or somebody for making a standard play. But it's somewhat excusable to berate someone for making a bad play? I understand the in the moment aspect and competitive nature. The thing is...that still opens up people to berate you for your berating in general. Sort of like that Phil H guy. But hey, if that's all you have to work on then you're doing A-okay. Continued success to you.
Ok, that was the gentler, giving the benefit of the doubt version. Now, here's more of a hits home, truth hurts version. When she berates someone for a bad play, it's an in denial defense mechanism. Sometimes when she attempts to make a move, and someone makes a move back at her or catches her in the act, and her attempt fails, she has difficulty giving credit for a good play. It can only be a good play if it works for her. She gets upset when an opponent doesn't back down to the mighty Vanessa Selbst, and the in denial default is it was a bad play by opponent.

Vanessa, you are mighty, just take it as even the mighty gets humbled sometimes.

Last edited by Lester Kluke; 12-11-2012 at 08:26 PM.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 08:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
you guys are funny.

this sounds like a hand i TOTALLY would have berated you for. right. i love the stories from randoms about me flipping people off or berating people for no reason... like that EVER would have happened. if you're gonna complain about something i supposedly did five years ago to you, at least make it believable. it makes no sense that i would have berated you for a play that is 100% standard by the book poker.

the thing is... i've never been bitter or mean at the table, just very competitive. that means i never ever have "berated" people for completely standard plays, and i almost never "berated" amateurs. i just used to, admittedly, have a bad habit of getting upset about terrible plays from players i thought were supposed to be better than that. every now and again, when i get emotional for one reason or another, that comes up again. i think those that know me know that it's just a symptom of my hyper-competitive nature and i don't ever mean anything by it, but i get that it comes across poorly on TV. that's cool.

i'm sure people will always make up stories... i just thought the people who are actually watching might care to understand... sometimes when you're really caught up in the moment, you can get overly emotional when someone you think will act one way acts another. most of the time i'm just mad at myself for thinking one thing when another thing happened... i.e. i made a mistake, and i'm upset about that, and it comes across in a negative way. ah well, i'll continue to work on it and have this be rarer and rarer, most people will notice that, and i'm sure i'll also continue to read random made-up stories as well.

as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.


how is this topic still going... Pretty sure vanessa realizes its ridiculous to expect Kevin to softplay her, or avoid her for his own sake, whatever way you want to word it.

She came off really bad in that interview...
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 10:07 PM
which part of Episode 8 EPT Berlin was it in?
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-11-2012 , 10:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by archimedes11
which part of Episode 8 EPT Berlin was it in?
nvm
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-12-2012 , 08:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
you guys are funny.

this sounds like a hand i TOTALLY would have berated you for. right. i love the stories from randoms about me flipping people off or berating people for no reason... like that EVER would have happened. if you're gonna complain about something i supposedly did five years ago to you, at least make it believable. it makes no sense that i would have berated you for a play that is 100% standard by the book poker.

the thing is... i've never been bitter or mean at the table, just very competitive. that means i never ever have "berated" people for completely standard plays, and i almost never "berated" amateurs. i just used to, admittedly, have a bad habit of getting upset about terrible plays from players i thought were supposed to be better than that. every now and again, when i get emotional for one reason or another, that comes up again. i think those that know me know that it's just a symptom of my hyper-competitive nature and i don't ever mean anything by it, but i get that it comes across poorly on TV. that's cool.

i'm sure people will always make up stories... i just thought the people who are actually watching might care to understand... sometimes when you're really caught up in the moment, you can get overly emotional when someone you think will act one way acts another. most of the time i'm just mad at myself for thinking one thing when another thing happened... i.e. i made a mistake, and i'm upset about that, and it comes across in a negative way. ah well, i'll continue to work on it and have this be rarer and rarer, most people will notice that, and i'm sure i'll also continue to read random made-up stories as well.

as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.
Not trying to jump on the bandwagon here but it is better you don't make excuses for such poor behavior. What you are not acknowledging when you say that sometimes when 'you're' caught up in the moment is that every pro is caught up in these moments. Every pro deals with these situations. The difference is, they don't flip out and act like this. It's especially painful given that you, a very good player, also owes a ton to the world of run good for your tourney success. The poker world has been more than fair to you but you have a bit of a spoiled child syndrome. Take bad beats, bad plays, etc etc with some class. Put your head down, don't be condescending, and just move on. You are in a unique position where a lot of people are going to be paying closer attention to you than others so, like it or not, your actions have a greater impact on the image of poker. Even if it isn't an amateur you are berating, there are surely amateurs at the table totally turned off by the behavior.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-12-2012 , 10:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by insidemanpoker
.........every pro is caught up in these moments. Every pro deals with these situations..........
You made that up!
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-12-2012 , 12:51 PM
I love how judgmental some people's posts are itt. Good for you if you're the perfect specimen for televised poker and would behave like a boyscout. My take is that we should be thankful there are a variety of personalities in the poker world. It makes situations more colorful, interesting and gives us something to talk, debate, discuss, rant and bitch about. It would be pretty boring without that. If you're so upset by her actions I'm going to go out on a limb and say that maybe you should peruse the psychology section and figure out why exactly her behavior bothers you so much.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-12-2012 , 01:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by therightdeal
I can't find the video, but there is a video of her heads up against some old fart, that was pretty embarrassing to watch.
Quote:
Originally Posted by FUrake
yeh i saw this recently, HU in wpt ladies event, it was really embarrasing to watch
That was really heavy edited to make Selbst the villain. The other woman was quite a bitch (according to Selbst).
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-12-2012 , 03:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gypsydc
I love how judgmental some people's posts are itt. Good for you if you're the perfect specimen for televised poker and would behave like a boyscout. My take is that we should be thankful there are a variety of personalities in the poker world. It makes situations more colorful, interesting and gives us something to talk, debate, discuss, rant and bitch about. It would be pretty boring without that. If you're so upset by her actions I'm going to go out on a limb and say that maybe you should peruse the psychology section and figure out why exactly her behavior bothers you so much.
I think opinions tend to automatically get more polarized when posted on message boards. It's just the nature of internet and non-verbal communication. Maybe some got the impression that I hate Vanessa when actually I don't. She's just not my favorite player due to some of her antics. Maybe she is to others, idk.

To me poker is still a gentlemans game. Berating other players for their mistakes is just flat out stupid and it has no value. Only two things can come out of it. Either the player who gets berated actually takes advice from what he hears and starts to play better, or he gets aggravated and leaves the game. I left the aforementioned Bellagio game after getting stacked by Vanessa because I didn't like the atmosphere in the game (I did have cash so I could've bought in for more). Maybe me leaving wasn't a huge loss for the table, but any other recreational player could've left as well. Playing cards has to be fun and if it isn't and people aren't being nice to you, why would you stay? There's lots of other entertainment options available for the same money.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-13-2012 , 12:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gypsydc
I love how judgmental some people's posts are itt............... I'm going to go out on a limb and say that maybe you should peruse the psychology section and figure out why exactly her behavior bothers you so much.
Good thing Vanessa is not the one being "judgemental" or "bothered" or your post would be hilarious.

Also love how people merely pointing out d-bag behavior are somehow "haters" and the ones with psychological problems. Some people have class and manners and some don't. There is still plenty of variety and personality even when people behave as adults, you should try it.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-13-2012 , 02:47 AM
I think the fact that Vanessa came into this post and basically called martre a liar and saying that she would not do something that we've seen her do countless times on tv, speaks volumes about her character. I don't know about you guys but I believe martre and not her, she probably berated so many people in her life she doesn't remember half of them.

Who the hell are you Vanessa that you have a right to berate people for how they play their money? Is it your money they are playing with? NO, then what business is it of yours how they play?
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-13-2012 , 07:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zajebisty
I think the fact that Vanessa came into this post and basically called martre a liar and saying that she would not do something that we've seen her do countless times on tv, speaks volumes about her character. I don't know about you guys but I believe martre and not her, she probably berated so many people in her life she doesn't remember half of them.

Who the hell are you Vanessa that you have a right to berate people for how they play their money? Is it your money they are playing with? NO, then what business is it of yours how they play?
Confirmed mad.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-13-2012 , 01:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by harkin
Good thing Vanessa is not the one being "judgemental" or "bothered" or your post would be hilarious.

Also love how people merely pointing out d-bag behavior are somehow "haters" and the ones with psychological problems. Some people have class and manners and some don't. There is still plenty of variety and personality even when people behave as adults, you should try it.
Vanessa may be the one being judgmental about how others play poker but that isn't what I was writing about.

Although I was being sarcastic, I wasn't implying that the anti-Vanessa's are haters nor that they have psychological problems either. I was being serious. I guess I could have left out the sarcasm but like martre said, "I think opinions tend to automatically get more polarized when posted on message boards. It's just the nature of internet and non-verbal communication."

What I was implying is that as people we tend to be harsh on others more-so if they're a celebrity of sorts or an authority figure and it's interesting, from a psychological perspective, as to why that is. It's okay to have an opinion about a person and their behavior but I'm curious as to why that opinion has to be a put down by making statements that they're a person with no class blah blah blah. Maybe it's just about semantics and I could have refrained from posting, idk.

Anyways, I was implying that we all live in glass houses and wasn't pointing martre out either...he just happened to quote and respond to my post.

However, since he did, another interesting point (to me) is "5 years ago". I don't know how old Vanessa is...I could look it up but I don't think she's hit 30 yet. That being said, 5 years ago, that puts her in her early 20's and for what that's worth she's still young now. I don't know about those of you here, but when I think back to **** I did and said in my 20's...ugh. Being young isn't an excuse for what we're referring to as bad behavior here, but that doesn't instantly make her a person with no class and manners as is stated on various pages itt either. (for the record I noticed that in martre's post he doesn't put down her person, only her actions)

Not that you hit 40 or 50 or whatever and you're suddenly behaving perfectly but we do tend to grow as people, learn to relax more, mature. We've typically experienced more and hopefully have grown into what would be considered a more positive direction as a person.

So my implication was twofold: One, to give her a break. She, like all of us, is learning to be the best person that she can and she's pretty new to it if you're measuring years. There isn't any value in putting her down as a person. Although there may value may be in a discerning discussion about why this behavior occurs and bothers others. Two, as previously stated, we all live in glass houses.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-14-2012 , 07:31 PM
so, she got a bit bitter about being read in hand of poker or smt?

won't bother watching clip. sounds like a standard poker player. she needs to step it up
to hellmuths level, where it actually becomes comical.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-20-2012 , 02:45 AM
I can't believe she comes in here and uses 3rd grade ape logic to defend and deny her 3rd grade ape habits.

On second thought...
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-22-2012 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fslexcduck
you guys are funny.

this sounds like a hand i TOTALLY would have berated you for. right. i love the stories from randoms about me flipping people off or berating people for no reason... like that EVER would have happened. if you're gonna complain about something i supposedly did five years ago to you, at least make it believable. it makes no sense that i would have berated you for a play that is 100% standard by the book poker.
the thing is... i've never been bitter or mean at the table, just very competitive. that means i never ever have "berated" people for completely standard plays,

If u would indulge a fish like me...is 6bet shoving small pocket pairs with little to no FE standard play?

and i almost never "berated" amateurs.

Considering your volume of play can u make a rough estimate of what "almost never" means? few people, few tens or maybe hundreds of people?

i just used to, admittedly, have a bad habit of getting upset about terrible plays from players i thought were supposed to be better than that. every now and again, when i get emotional for one reason or another, that comes up again. i think those that know me know that it's just a symptom of my hyper-competitive nature and i don't ever mean anything by it, but i get that it comes across poorly on TV. that's cool.

i'm sure people will always make up stories... i just thought the people who are actually watching might care to understand... sometimes when you're really caught up in the moment, you can get overly emotional when someone you think will act one way acts another. most of the time i'm just mad at myself for thinking one thing when another thing happened... i.e. i made a mistake, and i'm upset about that, and it comes across in a negative way. ah well, i'll continue to work on it and have this be rarer and rarer, most people will notice that, and i'm sure i'll also continue to read random made-up stories as well.

as far as this hand itself, me and kevin are over it and we're cool again, so you guys might as well get over it too.
.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-22-2012 , 06:33 PM
I think with her background he should have 5 bet shoved.

given background, 3 bet is standard, 4 bet is standard, 5 bet should have been a shove, but given the way it played out the 6 bet shove was way to risky and she shouldnt be pissed that he called.

and the call isnt even that bad. she is known to level herself. And im pretty sure she isnt going to 6 bet shove over flatting or folding premium hands.

Team McPhee for me. The hero calling legend. Selbst tilts me. But what do I know, just my 0.02
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-22-2012 , 07:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cma13

Anything other than a strong A-type personality is very rare within that type of education/career.
Are you basing this astute observation on LA Law, Boston Legal or both?

Absolutely 100% untrue. And I'd know, trust me.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-23-2012 , 01:37 AM
Vannessa Selbst always come off as a first class kunt at the tbls imo
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote
12-25-2012 , 02:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by insidemanpoker
This.
Selbst vs. McPhee Quote

      
m