Mike, as we discussed today I did a lot of thinking about this hand and talked to Cha about it also and he shared some of your thoughts about the hand with me. As I said earlier, I wrote a lengthy response yesterday then deleted it because I wasn't confident enough to post it. But as you requested, here were my thoughts about the hand.
Villains stats, although a small sample, would lead me to believe he's a fairly solid player. His flop call really confuses me here, especially if he thinks you're solid.
Almost any good player is going to reraise on this flop with 2 pair, trips, or an overpair slowplayed preflop. Not only to protect his hand, but to extract value from you before the board gets even scarier. He's also not likely to be floating on a flop like this.
This leaves the nut straight, and then some draws and combo draws like JT, QT, and 77. He could also have a pair with a decent kicker like AT or KT.
I guess flat calling the nuts here is ok, but I would tend to raise it myself in the hopes you had a big overpair. Lots of people love to slowplay so I wouldn't rule it out. I would also tend to raise JT because I would be happy to get it in with an OESD and pair.
QT I would be less likely to raise so that's a possibility. I'm not sure what I would do with AT, KT, or 77, but I could see calling sometimes.
Now when a villain flat calls me on a flop in a spot where I'm likely c-betting a large % of the time, and then the turn helps me, I usually like to check and hope to induce a bluff. But this spot I think I prefer leading something like $22 on the turn.
There are several hands you're ahead of that will call. Most of these hands have outs and might check behind if you check. Sometimes if you check to them they will bluff you and it's going to put you in a tough spot.
The problem with leading is if you get raised. It's pretty tough to laydown top pair and an OESD with decent odds. I think I would muck to a reraise though.
Now if you lead and get called the river is still going to be difficult to play. I think if it blanks or we hit another Ace I would be willing to check/call nearly any bet. It's just too difficult giving someone credit for exactly QJ here. I guess trips and 2 pair are possible but they seem fairly unlikely except for AT. If you make a straight obviously we're getting it in. If the board pairs the 8,9, or T it would be an interesting decision. Also if you make 2 pair with a J.
I would love to see some other responses. I think it's an interesting spot and am surprised it hasn't seen more discussion. Your hand just seems too strong to give up on but not strong enough to commit with. Maybe in the big picture considering villains range after the flop call it's EV neutral no matter what your plan is for the hand.