Quote:
Originally Posted by ninetynine99
When are those damn Inuit and Eskimos gonna get it right? Oh, I guess after enough whole grains and frozen vegetables get shipped up north.
Maybe the reason the vegetarian arguments against meat are so stupid is, well, because their brains haven't had enough meat for a while:
http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2...ins-brain-size
EDIT: Just wanted to emphasize this line:
He added that “there is no [traditional] society that live as vegans,”
No "traditional" ones. Just nut-bar ones*.
* yeah, pun obv. intended
As a vegan, I recognize that I don't have a traditional diet. Trying to argue that vegetarianism/veganism is wrong because there are not traditional societies who live that way is absurd. There are plenty of valid reasons to adopt such a diet. There are also plenty of ways to be healthy and get all the nutrition you need whether you consume animal products or not.
Humans are truly omnivores, in my opinion. We can get along on anything. The post article you reference refers to the development of the human brain from PREHUMAN ANCESTORS. The main argument made is regarding calories and efficiency in consuming those calories. The study refers to gorillas needing to eat for an additional 2 hours per day to get enough calories to support a "human" brain. Clearly, with the wonders of modern science, I can eat a fully balanced, calorie-dense vegan meal in just a few minutes several times per day. A *Gasp* vitamin or 2 on top of those meals and I don't even have to think about balancing those meals.
This to me is the point. I am able to make an informed decision that allows me to get everything I need without killing. Granted "killing" is part of nature. That's why it is silly to expect traditional societies still living with nature to adopt such diets. Those in the western/industrial world have little to no connection with a truly "natural" life, so the argument that my diet is "unnatural" doesn't mean much to me. Driving a car, living in a house, having heat, a computer, etc. etc. etc. is also all unnatural.
Speaking of nature and what a species is "meant" to do, I'm fairly certain feed lots, dairy farms, and gestation crates aren't natural environments to the animals subjected to them.
B12 is this big thing for promeat people, but it is the product of bacteria and can be made in your own colon. To be B12 deficient, you basically need to be malnourished, pregnant, or lactating.
I think if you're going to eat meat, it would be much nicer if you raised it and killed it by yourself, or, better yet, caught and killed it "naturally."
steve