Quote:
Originally Posted by bbfg
You didn't answer my question. Or does your opinion on mental illness not count when someone who had the status of Chester commits suicide? Your opinion that mental illness can only be valid if certain conditions are met shows that you don't accept it as an illness.
1. Mental illness is horrible, I've had friends with schizophrenia and (real) depression.
2. Mental illness hits all kinds of people from all walks of life.
3. I make the comments regardless.
Let me ask you a question. When someone offs himself, is he ever partly to blame? Or is it always "mental illness"?
Quote:
Replace "who offed himself" with "died from cancer" in your post to realise how silly/offensive your post sounds to people who do see mental illness like a regular illness.
Of course mental illness is like a regular illness, when it's an actual physical organic illness (like schizophrenia, or low thyroid hormone levels). It gets murkier when it doesn't fit into that category.
Quote:
As for being a 0.0001% / having 6 children / etc. I agree those are things that should work positively for your happiness during good times. But can't you see that this would feel like a gigantic pile of pressure during bad times? And that it would make everything even worse if you have entered in a "irrational, depressed thoughts"-state?
The dude was grieving the likely loss of his gay lover. He killed himself on the birthday of the other guy in the band who killed himself a few months earlier.
Do you ever have a choice on whether to wallow in grief or pull yourself out for the sake of your friends, family, children? Do you admit that there is any choice at all in how we approach things?
I lost a friend to suicide with schizophrenia. I don't blame them at all - it's living hell and I'd wish it on no one. That's a real mental illness suicide that the person could do nothing about.
This guy felt down after losing his very close friend so he offed himself on the birthday of that very close friend. Sounds like self pity and selfishness to me. The dude had 6 kids.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yakmelk
You seem to think they are somehow in the same league, lol at that. The reason people are complaining about this thread is simple; there are rules, even when a subject is emotional. Forgoing these rules simply because a subject is an emotional one is a recipe for anarchy and god knows what. Although, OOT is ****ed up enough as it is, I guess ****ty threads littering the front page aren't that much of a big deal anymore.
Yeah pretty much. He's a no name nobody for lots of people, so everyone piles on.