ok
First of all: realistically, when someone makes $100k a year, they're usually college graduates -- doctors, engineers, lawyers, etc., and they will generally have a ton of bills to go with that. In the case of well-paid doctors, they also have to pay malpractice insurance. Factor in taxes, and in reality they're actually making much less than $100k.
Second, you can't just have a six-figure job and live like a hillbilly. People who make six figures are
expected to maintain a certain living standard -- drive a certain car, dress in nice tailored suits, go to country clubs -- and the long-term career health of these people depends on them doing these things. So, for someone like a lawyer, driving a BMW or better is not just a luxury, it's a necessity.
Third, it's churlish to just tell someone with a family making six figures to just live in an absolutely basic way. Getting to a point where you are making that much money is not easy, no matter what your career is. People don't do it so that they can have a basic life, they do it so that they and their children have some security and comfort.
And finally, I'm not sure if either of you guys have ever stopped to think about how ****ing expensive having a family is. I'm not a head of household but until about two months ago I was engaged to a single mom, so I have a decent idea of what the running cost of a family would be like. This is my estimate for a somewhat decent basic lifestyle for a family of four in, say, Los Angeles.
- 3-bedroom house (in a somewhat safe area of town) - $2,500 a month
- One month grocery tab for four (that includes better food than ramen, potatoes and chicken, which is what I'm primarily eating now) - $900 a month, including non-food items like cleaning implements and clothes
- Utilities - $180
- Family cell phone plan - $120
- Internet - $80
- Health insurance for four - $600
- New economy car or very nice used car + maintenance - $200
- Gas - another $200
- Entertainment - At least $100 a month
Final tab - $4,880 a month
For a family that isn't actually poor, this is actually a very bare-bones existence. Doing less than this is not something that anyone at all would unless they had no choice. And even a life like this, in a reasonably large city, would cost almost $60,000 -- e.g. as much or possibly more than a person making $100k a year actually takes home, after taxes, student loans, etc.
So no, it's not actually that surprising that someone making six figures would be living paycheck to paycheck. I would consider a family of four making less than like $50k a year after taxes + non-optional expenses like loans, actually poor (I have a fairly stringent criteria set for what constitutes poverty).
Last edited by Aleksei; 09-22-2014 at 11:29 PM.