Originally Posted by General Tsao
every criticism you and max have made has been refuted in the video. you are challenging his arguments in ways he expected and addressed in the video. like i said, if you can't understand his explanations wtf do you want me to do about it?
Actually no. I'm sorry you are too dense to understand this but he actually does not address any of my criticisms. That video was 48 minutes of drivel where he takes the obvious position that dumb criminals should not talk to the police and through some horrible logic and terrible reasoning tries to make it a universal rule that no one should ever cooperate with the police.
He further never gives a single example of when an innocent mentally sound person talking to the police led to them getting in trouble. For both speakers all the examples-- and they have plenty-- involved criminals who talk to the police and incriminate themselves. If it was so common for innocent people to incriminate themselves you'd think they would include at least one example but they don't. The only example they have of someone who was innocent incriminating themselves involves someone who is mentally ill.
Lastly Duane intentionally misstates the position of Justice Jackson so as to support his position when if you actually look at the statement in the context in which it was stated it does not mean what Duane wants people to believe it means. That leads to the question of is he dishonest or a moron. I'm leaning strongly toward dishonest since the misappropriate quote adds sensationalism and this video is just a desperate attempt at getting notoriety.