Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Bill Hicks is overrated Bill Hicks is overrated

04-16-2011 , 08:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by prohornblower
I believe many members of this forum overrate Louis CK.
Who, currently, is in his league? Links appreciated.

Louis CK routine I enjoy: http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?desktop...SXjVuJVg&gl=US
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 08:55 PM
You're probably too hungry to post the right link.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 08:58 PM
I'm on the iPad, does it not work? Google "Louis CK broke".
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LFS
Who, currently, is in his league? Links appreciated.

Louis CK routine I enjoy: http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?desktop...SXjVuJVg&gl=US
I could post a couple names, but I won't because the CK fanbois will get all upset.

I have heard CK and I think he's funny and I heard he generates more material than any current practitioner but I just think he's a bit over-rated on this forum.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:04 PM
So to be clear, you think there are better stand-ups working today but you won't say who? I was actually hoping you'd post some people I hadn't heard of that are funny because I'm pretty up on this stuff and don't think he has much competition at the moment, unless Chris Rock counts.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:09 PM
Wait, are we now in a semantic argument about whether or not "overrated" means "over-ranked"?

Oh, **** did I steer down the wrong road.

EDIT: Wait, that doesn't even make sense because you can be over-ranked and still not be #1. WTF?
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:14 PM
name better comedians working today, you [censored] idiot. i'll give you a hint: you won't be able to. is CK the GOAT comedian? no, but he's the best one working today. he's prolific and hilarious.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:36 PM
I never said he was or wasn't the best stand-up working today. I said I think a lot of people on here over-rate him.

Comprehension, it's not for everybody!

LFS, I listened to CK broke and laughed once. At the 2:30 mark when he said "if it's free, I can't afford it". That clip was actually less funny than other stuff I've seen of his.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:37 PM
Not being willing to name names is so pathetic.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:40 PM
NAMES ABOUT WHAT!?
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:41 PM
CK's "broke" bit was the same re-tread bit every poor comedian (there are a ****ton of poor comedians) has done for 2 decades. With a bunch of well-timed F words. Amazing!
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:49 PM
CK did that bit in 1995 you [censored] idiot, and as usual phb is gonna phb - can't like anything
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:55 PM
I like a lot of comedians. At least a couple more than Louis CK, even.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-16-2011 , 10:01 PM
Triumph36 >>> Louis CK. There I said it.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 12:57 AM
The man was a genius. He broke ground that is now so broken its sometimes hard to see why its funny anymore.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 04:22 AM
carlin is way overrated.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 06:44 AM
i think he wass funny, but ofc he is overrated, alot of people are

and you dont always have to "make a joke" to be funny

also, he is not a stand up comedian , so it would be unfare to compare him with someone like eddie murphy
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 06:56 AM
agree with OP almost 100%, except i do find him funny

i saw this movie in a small underground cinema filled with hippies smoking pot, and honestly i wanted to punch them in the balls the whole night

every time he said something to do with the government, drugs, police or w/e, they would all make a noise people make when they see a baby for the first time. it was like every observation he made, in their eyes, they wanted to praise him as the father of enlightenment.

dont get me wrong, he had some good points, but he wasnt the ****ing revolutionary his fans make him out to be

beat: had to spend time with bill hicks fanboys
brag: scored an 8th of high quality bud after the show
variance: paid $10 for the ticket
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 07:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by riverboatking
carlin is way overrated.
I think you've missed the boat on having any opinoin matter on him. There's just no way our generation could appreciate him when he was in his prime. I kinda liked his older stuff but he was always just an old man by the time Igot into standup.




Just lol at the guy that said CK is overrated. Easily in my top 5 comedians that Im aware of.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 02:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by riverboatking
carlin is way overrated.
His later material was awful, but his earlier stuff is amazing
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 08:29 PM
i dont really like him either, but comics do seem to respect him an awful lot...

i think bill burr is the funniest stand up comic currently working, i've re-watched and thoroughly enjoyed all of his stuff.

"we'll get the population down to about 30,000 people...every year, super bowl comes around, everyone can go. 22 of you can play, the odds of you making it in the nfl, its amazing"
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-17-2011 , 08:54 PM
This thread is just so edgy and non-conformist. the essence of ron burgundy.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-18-2011 , 12:49 AM
Since we're chatting about comics other than Hicks, my current favorites are Doug Stanhope, Bill Burr and Louis CK. Any recommendations for a fan of these comedians?
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-18-2011 , 01:15 AM
Since people have calmed down I'll say I think Norm MacDonald and Jim Gaffigan are "in CK's league". Maybe even Brian Regan. Greg Giraldo would have been up there but he's no longer eligible on a technicality. And I think Giraldo was probably better at the roasting than at traditional stand-up.

Still don't see wtf this has to do with whether or not CK is over-rated by a lot of people on 2+2.

But I welcome all the "LOL Jim Gaffigan sucks, your opinion means nothing" comments coming from Triumph36 who is obviously severely butthurt about his favorite comedian.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote
04-18-2011 , 02:08 AM
MacDonald....maybe.

Gaffigan...doesn't even deserve to be in the same sentence with Louis.

Nick Swardson and Daniel Tosh are 100000x funnier than Gaffigan.
Bill Hicks is overrated Quote

      
m