VanMan2008: It seems you are a weak-tight nit, suffering from FGators syndrome. (FGators was/is a midstakes player who had exactly the same graph as you over 1.5 million hands, resulting in a legendary 2+2 thread. See
FGators syndrome explained for some high level theory.)
Your preflop is sort of OK, except that I think you are too loose in the BB.
However, look at your postflop stats: you basically fold whenever someone bets or raises. So on any given postflop street, you basically have two moves: bet, or check/fold. That's gonna be picked up even by fish often.
I suspect (cant really see that in stats) that you raise preflop, c-bet the flop and then give up unless you hit something. Now that is a fairly common scenario, but at NL5 you have to learn to recognize the folks who will call your c-bet with a worse hand. Yes, you can often bet AQo for value on a 762r flop against them, because they'll call the c-bet with QJ.
You are going to have to learn to play poker postflop, there's no other way.