Quote:
Originally Posted by VBAces
Maybe because they can make money by raising hands other than AA.
In the past I've read people on forums throwing out the notion that if there were no blinds people would only raise with AA. I have never seen any logic in this, and certainly no evidence of it. In games where the blinds are very small (therefore fairly irrelevant), people raise with a wide range of hands. They do this because they are hoping to win more money than if they don't raise - not because they hope to take down the blinds.
I think you could do an experiment with a home game. Play it with no blinds or antes. Preflop you could simply check, and would not have to fold unless someone raised. I'm pretty sure that not only would people raise preflop with less than AA, people would also call raises with less than AA.
The reason you have not seen the evidence behind this is because the average player does not play correctly and is willing to put money into the pot incorrectly. It is a more extreme version of the fact that bad players are willing flat behind with garbage hands, like Q2o just to see a flop. The reason you are immediately thinking that this example is ridiculous (I am assuming) is because you are considering only a typical game where stacks are, say, 100bb deep. However, what if I told you that the big blind was $100 and you were HU with stacks $150 deep? You should see that it instantly becomes correct to play any hand in this situation.
Now, think about the fact that if you only play As when there is a forced bet, you will be paying 34bb on average (222 hands = 22 orbits) to get a shot at winning a pot where you profit more than 34bb. As and Ks together would still only be 90% of hands for 17bb on average.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, if there are no forced bets, there is theoretically no reason to open a pot with anything other than the best hand. Mathematically, you can instantly see that this makes sense, just because of the situation I just brought up. Say you're playing 9max 0nl with $100 stacks and you open the pot UTG with AK thinking that you have a premium hand. If it costs your opponent $0 to wait for As and to guarantee that their range is stronger than yours, why would they choose to play any other hand? You can make the case that they will "try to bluff or outmaneuver you postflop", but then you'll see that if this is the case, you wouldn't want to open with AK in the first place--and so you yourself will only open with As.
Consider your example where players can simply check to see a free flop. You arrive at the flop 9 handed (or less, it wouldn't matter) and the pot is $0! If you bet any amount of money, you are giving your opponents 1:1 pot odds, so there is literally no reason for them to call unless they know for a fact that they have you beat (in other words, equity of 100%). So, what are you trying to gain by making a bet? You're either making a really bad bet with something less than the absolute nuts (your pot odds for the bet are undefined, x/0), or hoping that your opponent doesn't understand poker and makes a terrible call.
The reason you will
hypothetically wait for As without a forced bet is because
hypothetically, that's what the other players should be doing. Actually, I would even go so far as to argue that you should be playing no hands, because your opponents should theoretically also no be playing anything worse than AA, thus breaking the game. Without blinds to win, there is no reason to open a pot, since without having to pay 1.5bb every orbit, there is no limitation to how long you can wait for a hand, and thus you want to maximize your range against your opponents.
This is why the concept of the blind/ante is universal in poker. Of course, the average player will put chips in the pot anyway because they don't understand this concept--this is why you say that you could make money with hands other than AA. Poker is a zero sum game, and the only reason there are "good" players is because there are "bad" players that make mistakes such as putting money into the pot with hands that are too weak.
Last edited by goldFishshark; 04-20-2017 at 06:32 PM.