Quote:
Originally Posted by overcast
Depending on the dealer's up card, it could have been correct to hit no matter what. Basic strategy says you hit s18 vs 9/10/A.
Basic strategy is dependent on the rules, which means "basic strategy" you find for a regular shoe game will be incorrect for a game with bonus pays. Some rules make almost no difference, some have an enormous impact. It's part of the reason most players concede a HUGE edge to Spanish 21.
For example, say you're playing in a game where hitting to 21 pays 3:1 automatically, except on doubled or split hands. What's your play on 11 vs 6? Standard double, right? Except now it's a colossal blunder. Why risk twice as much money to get paid even money when you can just take a card and get paid more in the first place?
That's similar to what OP is facing. Unbreakable hand, guaranteed a push at worst by taking a card, still in the running to win as well. I'm actually sure there would be scenarios like AA27 vs 4/5/6 where playing it as an 11 and taking a card is the right choice, since you can't lose.