Quote:
Originally Posted by potleemit
Absolutely stay in cash until retirement. That is, unless you do enough reading so that you understand investing theory. Rule number one is to not lose money. And rule number two is to remember rule number one.
It is NEVER a good idea to put money into something where you don't have an edge, or at least an understanding bordering on excellence. Housing was a great investment. Enough people believed it until it became the worst investment possible. Same thing with stocks.
You cannot rely on advice from others. You worked hard for your money, and the worst thing to do would be to lose it because you put it into something you didn't understand.
I find it hard to believe that if you put 25 percent into each of the following right now, and let it ride for 15 years, you would do worse than cash.
Exxon
Kraft
Proctor and Gamble
Berkshire Hathaway
I actually believe that you could choose any of the above and put everything into it and be better off in 15 years. Buffett says that if he had all of his family money in Proctor and Gamble and he disappeared for 20 years and and couldn't check the price of the stock, he would sleep well. There are probably 15-20 stocks that fit the bill.
You could put it into an index fund and very likely be better off in 15 years than if you were in cash. But once again, why put money into something just because somebody says it will work out? If you don't know why something is a good idea, then you have to wait until you know why, so study as much as you can.
Personally, I do things differently, and I look for special situation plays, and asset plays, mainly with small caps. But that is a recipe for total disaster for someone like you who hasn't spent tens of thousands of hours in his life thinking about this stuff.
It sounds like you are heading into a nice retirement in 15 years. There is absolutely nothing wrong with guaranteeing that you enjoy it, and that means staying in cash, even if you get zero percent on your money. There is a reason that rates are so low. There will be little to no growth, and deflation is more likely than inflation, and with deflation, those dollars buy a lot more each year.
There is a certain comfort in having cash, and 90 percent of the time when people chase yield for the sake of getting a higher rate of return, huge losses will follow.
Stay in cash until you have put in a few thousand hours of reading. If you put it into blue chips, or even all into Berkshire Hathaway, you would likely be better off in 15 years than cash, but if you cannot articulate why that is the case and really understand why it is, then you have to stay put.
I'd hate to admit it, I really do. A lot of people disagree with potleemit, but the more I read his posts, the more I agree with him. At first I thought he was kind of a crack pot who knew a few things, then I've come to realize he's simply giving good advice.
Pot isn't telling you to invest in cash long term, he's telling you to stay in cash if you aren't willing to do the work to learn how to grow your money. I would laugh at someone who stays in cash, but if I knew that person would do zero work towards paying attention to what they invest in and what it's doing, then I'd probably advise the same thing.
We are all not the same people here. Some people wake up, have coffee, watch tv all day and check their investments once or twice a year, make changes (that are usually wrong), and complain about how much they lost. Some people wake up and the first thing they think is "Lets go see how premarket looks" and what happened in the world that day while they slept. Then they start looking around, seeing what went in what direction and for what reason, and keep an eye on things and base their investment decisions on when conditions are favorable.
There is a vast difference between the two, and 50% of those who put in the work STILL do the wrong things.
If you aren't willing to put in the work and learn what is going on with the world (and this is perfectly fine), then invest in the absolute safest things you can find, work hard, live your life, and be happy. If you are willing to learn how to invest and research and dabble and STILL realize you have a ton of work to do, then get to it and start learning when you have down time.
Of all the things I've learned over the last few years, I've learned that everyone doesn't think like me. When it comes to finances
I think only 1-5 people I've ever met in person think like me, and I don't know a damn thing. I try to judge people by how much they know and how much time they are willing to put in before I give them advice. If I think they won't do much, I advise them to be as conservative as possible - because I don't want to hear the bitching when it goes bad. If they know what they are doing, I bounce ideas off them and use them as a resource.
For now, I agree with pot. Be as conservative as possible. When you read/learn/research quite a bit, then start dabbling. If the dabbling is unsuccessful multiple times, go back to being conservative and forget it.
Last edited by wil318466; 07-26-2012 at 09:46 AM.