Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started?

04-24-2007 , 01:12 AM
I just had a very good night at the tournament table and now that I'm ITM, so to speak, I would like to parlay my funds into something other than a poker bankroll. I have been considering day trading as well as real estate for quite a while, but as I lack the financial resources to confidently get involved with the loans I'd need to start buying property, the stock market is looking like a good option. If that kid from the apprentice who's around my age can do it at 18, surely I can do it now.

Does anyone have some good advice on how to get started? Are there any books on the topic that are helpful / trustworthy / recommended?

I have tried searching the internet for info but looking for good tips on getting into stock trading is like using Google to look for advice on weight loss: lots of people ad-farming for lots of other people trying to sell you snake oil.

Any tips pointing me the right way would be appreciated.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:19 AM
My advice is don't.

If you really do want to experiment and learn, then start with a play money account and slowly risk a small amount at the beginning.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:22 AM
Quote:
My advice is don't.

If you really do want to experiment and learn, then start with a play money account and slowly risk a small amount at the beginning.
Is there software / a site for doing this?

Basically I have a sum of money that I would like to grow quickly and I am not perturbed by high immediate risk as long as I can make smart decisions in the process.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:25 AM
Don't bother day trading. You'll get a better return for your money at the casino - and at least they sometimes give you free drinks.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:28 AM
Quote:
any tips for getting started?
Yeah. Don't.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:33 AM
Well with such sage advice (and thanks for it!), can anyone suggest a method for starting a little investment portfolio? Like I said, I have some money and want to diversify. I'm open for suggestions, I just don't know how to start.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 01:39 AM
Quote:
Well with such sage advice (and thanks for it!), can anyone suggest a method for starting a little investment portfolio? Like I said, I have some money and want to diversify. I'm open for suggestions, I just don't know how to start.
Link

Link 2

Read All About Asset Allocation by Rick Ferri for further information if you like.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 02:02 AM
Don't listen to the naysayers... if its something you want to learn, there no reason why you shouldn't educate yourself.

You can start by reading some of the books listed in the Reading list thread linked in the sticky.

Many of the skills you learned to play poker well, carry over to day trading.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 02:13 AM
Forget day trading for the moment. Learn to position trade first and get an idea for how the game works. Once you are beating the game for good money, think about daytrading. You need to develop an analytical and decision making process first. Do this with end of day charts first.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 02:44 AM
do a course on valuation, another on finance and then consider trading. also watch out for bank fees
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 02:45 AM
Quote:
Well with such sage advice (and thanks for it!), can anyone suggest a method for starting a little investment portfolio? Like I said, I have some money and want to diversify. I'm open for suggestions, I just don't know how to start.
Good job for taking initiative and getting started. You're doing better than 90% of the people in the world. I would echo what Jeff W wrote above. The best way to invest is to avoid high-fee, high-taxed strategies. Index funds (or index-tracking ETFs) are the best way to invest your money. Index funds are great for a couple of reasons. They offer the returns that the stock market does (more than 10% per year, historically). However, they are have less risk than individual stocks. Movements of stocks are uncorrelated to a degree, so adding more and more stocks to a portfolio will decrease your variance while keeping your EV the same. It's works similarly to playing lots of hands in poker. Funds that track indexes are better than actively managed funds. They have lower expenses and are generally more tax-efficient. In aggregate, actively managed mutual funds trail the market's level of returns. In addition, it's impossible to pick the funds that will outperform in the future. Here are some websites that might or might not help you:

http://www.diehards.org/forum/index.php (the 2+2 of investing; many published authors and professionals post there)

ifa.com (this website has a very fancy, and very thorough guide to index funds)

iwillteachyoutoberich.com (this is a blog that has some very well-written introductory articles)

altruistfa.com/readingroom.htm (this webpage has many links to research papers; it has some advanced stuff, but it's more easy to navigate than the archives of a finance journal)
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 12:56 PM
Heres some good software to start off with which is free:

http://www.quotetracker.com/index_nn.asp

http://www.mbtrading.com/ ( get demo account)
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 02:37 PM
Quote:
Don't bother day trading. You'll get a better return for your money at the casino - and at least they sometimes give you free drinks.
I find it hard to believe that people on a poker forum can be this closed minded, when the game that we play is the game that everyone else says, "don't, you'll lose your money." It's my understanding that a very small % of poker players win, and that number is very similar to the number of traders that make money.

Trading is something I've been interested in at least finding out about, to see if I have an interest in it. I've seen a lot of these replies on the forums saying how "everyone loses, you'll go broke." That's what everyone told a lot of us when we started playing poker. If there's anyone besides the haterz out there, who know a good deal about making money trading, or know of people who make a lot trading I'd be interested in at least learning about it as well if anyone has info.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 08:00 PM
Quote:
Quote:
Don't bother day trading. You'll get a better return for your money at the casino - and at least they sometimes give you free drinks.
I find it hard to believe that people on a poker forum can be this closed minded, when the game that we play is the game that everyone else says, "don't, you'll lose your money." It's my understanding that a very small % of poker players win, and that number is very similar to the number of traders that make money.

Trading is something I've been interested in at least finding out about, to see if I have an interest in it. I've seen a lot of these replies on the forums saying how "everyone loses, you'll go broke." That's what everyone told a lot of us when we started playing poker. If there's anyone besides the haterz out there, who know a good deal about making money trading, or know of people who make a lot trading I'd be interested in at least learning about it as well if anyone has info.
Trading can be profitable, but this guy is a beginner. I doubt he knows much about mutual funds/bonds/longer term trading.

Why would you suggest he skips the profitable (and beatable) low-stakes games and ploughs straight into the high-stakes where he will be against the pros.

If he wants to try trading, then I would suggest longer term trading starting with stocks. If he can beat that, then he can start increasing his opportunity advantage (assuming he has an edge) by decreasing his timeframe for trading.

For even the pros, a live quote screen is just an international one-arm bandit which they pump money into to relieve the boredom of longer-term trading (which is quite boring - like grinding the low-limits).

I stand by my initial recommendation to avoid playing the day-trading game for the OP. It's not closed-minded, it's sensible advice. I would have elaborated on my post, but I didn't feel it was necessary.

Did you start you poker career playing $2000NL? Or were you too open minded not to? Poker, like trading, can be very profitable. But you need to start sensibly. Beginning with day-trading in not sensible.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 08:18 PM
Quote:
I find it hard to believe that people on a poker forum can be this closed minded, when the game that we play is the game that everyone else says, "don't, you'll lose your money." It's my understanding that a very small % of poker players win, and that number is very similar to the number of traders that make money.
Since the daily movement of the stock market is essentially random, it's a bit different than poker. You can't really calculate your pot odds with a random market.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 08:40 PM
Quote:
Quote:
I find it hard to believe that people on a poker forum can be this closed minded, when the game that we play is the game that everyone else says, "don't, you'll lose your money." It's my understanding that a very small % of poker players win, and that number is very similar to the number of traders that make money.
Since the daily movement of the stock market is essentially random, it's a bit different than poker. You can't really calculate your pot odds with a random market.
The randomness is in the deal.
(I'm on the don't day trade side fwiw)
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-24-2007 , 11:44 PM
Quote:
Well with such sage advice (and thanks for it!), can anyone suggest a method for starting a little investment portfolio? Like I said, I have some money and want to diversify. I'm open for suggestions, I just don't know how to start.
Here's my bit of sage advice: Don't look for trading advice on a poker site, because most of the people here don't have a clue. Most of what they know, they learned in this forum from other clueless posters. Would you go to a trading site to ask for advice on how to handle a re-raise from an out of position limper pre-flop when you hold AK on the button?

That said, let's look at the basics. Do you have 30 grand? The minimum account size, by regulation, for daytrading is 25 grand. You'll need some extra for drawdowns and incidentals. If you only have 7 or 8 grand you can't daytrade stocks, but you can daytrade futures. Many similar concepts apply between the two. If you're going to do stocks, pick up a few books on daytrading and technical analysis. Forget about books on mutual funds or bonds or "value investing" because you won't be messing with any of that. You have a mountain of stuff to learn, so don't waste your time on irrelevant stuff at the beginning. Join a pay site or two like thestreet.com. The fastest way to learn, although probably not the best way, is to join a pay chat site like Pristine. It will probably cost you between $200 and $500 a month, depending on which services you sign up for. They may not be so great at making you money but they'll show you how things work. Once you've got the basics down, you may want to kick them to the curb and strike out on your own or look for trade advice elsewhere.

If you live near Vegas, go to the Money Show next month. It's free and they have both a trade show and educational symposiums. Prepare to be overwhelmed.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 12:14 AM
Quote:
Quote:
Well with such sage advice (and thanks for it!), can anyone suggest a method for starting a little investment portfolio? Like I said, I have some money and want to diversify. I'm open for suggestions, I just don't know how to start.
Here's my bit of sage advice: Don't look for trading advice on a poker site, because most of the people here don't have a clue. Most of what they know, they learned in this forum from other clueless posters. Would you go to a trading site to ask for advice on how to handle a re-raise from an out of position limper pre-flop when you hold AK on the button?

That said, let's look at the basics. Do you have 30 grand? The minimum account size, by regulation, for daytrading is 25 grand. You'll need some extra for drawdowns and incidentals. If you only have 7 or 8 grand you can't daytrade stocks, but you can daytrade futures. Many similar concepts apply between the two. If you're going to do stocks, pick up a few books on daytrading and technical analysis. Forget about books on mutual funds or bonds or "value investing" because you won't be messing with any of that. You have a mountain of stuff to learn, so don't waste your time on irrelevant stuff at the beginning. Join a pay site or two like thestreet.com. The fastest way to learn, although probably not the best way, is to join a pay chat site like Pristine. It will probably cost you between $200 and $500 a month, depending on which services you sign up for. They may not be so great at making you money but they'll show you how things work. Once you've got the basics down, you may want to kick them to the curb and strike out on your own or look for trade advice elsewhere.

If you live near Vegas, go to the Money Show next month. It's free and they have both a trade show and educational symposiums. Prepare to be overwhelmed.

This kind of advice is why I started in the investment board on a poker forum. By posting this thread I'm now armed with a plethora of good links, reading suggestions, and opinions that are more trustworthy than what I might find on at random on the internet or in the bookstore on my own.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 01:31 AM
I've been trading for a good length of time now, and I can say that if you start out daytrading equities you will almost for sure fail. Daytrading, especially equities, is one of the most difficult trading activities you can participate in, in my opinion. Without a great deal of previous knowledge or quality training you have an extremely poor chance of being profitable. If you are considering active trading I would suggest "swing" or "position" trading first, which is holding positions for days/weeks instead of minutes/hours (daytrading) or months/years (investing). I know of a quality subscription website that will give you an education (not just stockpicks) which will start you in your trading journey. PM me if you want to know about it. Also, as Alexander Elder says, you must pay your "trader's tuition" as a novice in trading. You will lose money initially, almost guarenteed, because of poor decisions you will make. But you will learn from them and you will look back on them and be thankful that you made them so you could learn from them. Good luck.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 07:19 AM
Quote:
The randomness is in the deal.
(I'm on the don't day trade side fwiw)
Sure, but in poker you get multiple deals. The stock market gives you one.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 08:17 AM
Quote:
Quote:
The randomness is in the deal.
(I'm on the don't day trade side fwiw)
Sure, but in poker you get multiple deals. The stock market gives you one.
But then there's futures. currencies, options, interest rates etc etc..

And then there's another oportunity 5 seconds/minutes/days/weeks later etc...

Day trading has endless 'deals' but your edge is significantly smaller than swing/position trading (which already might have a slim edge) due to lower daily price swings and higher transaction costs and more psychological pressure.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 08:44 AM
Quote:
Trading can be profitable, but this guy is a beginner. I doubt he knows much about mutual funds/bonds/longer term trading.

Why would you suggest he skips the profitable (and beatable) low-stakes games and ploughs straight into the high-stakes where he will be against the pros.

If he wants to try trading, then I would suggest longer term trading starting with stocks. If he can beat that, then he can start increasing his opportunity advantage (assuming he has an edge) by decreasing his timeframe for trading.
First, no one was suggesting that he jump right in and start trading. There is clearly a learning curve and he should start by doing some reading and research.

Second, there is a diference between Long term trading/investing and day trading... and a lot less to think about in putting the odds in your favor on a short term trade.

Third, your analogy of low stakes vs high stakes doesn't apply. You control your stakes by Size, not style.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 08:46 AM
Quote:
Quote:
I find it hard to believe that people on a poker forum can be this closed minded, when the game that we play is the game that everyone else says, "don't, you'll lose your money." It's my understanding that a very small % of poker players win, and that number is very similar to the number of traders that make money.
Since the daily movement of the stock market is essentially random, it's a bit different than poker. You can't really calculate your pot odds with a random market.
The market is not random... and this is easier to see on both very short and very long timeframes.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 08:51 AM
Quote:
Here's my bit of sage advice: Don't look for trading advice on a poker site, because most of the people here don't have a clue. Most of what they know, they learned in this forum from other clueless posters. Would you go to a trading site to ask for advice on how to handle a re-raise from an out of position limper pre-flop when you hold AK on the button?
This is just wrong... just because "most" don't have a clue... doesn't mean there isn't someone who can help him. This majority clulessness exists on trading sites as well. Remember, Traders play poker too...

I agree with the rest of your post, though I wouldn't suggest joining a trading chatroom that has an expense, until he's farther along the reading & research path.
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote
04-25-2007 , 09:01 AM
Quote:
Quote:
The randomness is in the deal.
(I'm on the don't day trade side fwiw)
Sure, but in poker you get multiple deals. The stock market gives you one.
Are you kidding?

The stock market isn't a single hand... there are thousands of stocks to chose from...

Imagine being dealt in on thousands of poker tables at the same time, paying no blinds, and getting to choose to play only the best premium hands at any given point in time... and when you do chose to play, getting to take most of your bet back if you dont like the flop
Day Trading for Beginners - any tips for getting started? Quote

      
m