Quote:
Originally Posted by GrahamCracker
Wow, they are the first casino to come up with this 6 max idea!
See my post above, its been tried before in LA and also twice in Vegas, it has never succeeded to date.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GrahamCracker
But, I think the button straddle is a good idea, anything to change the games up and put more money is good imo. alot of people are not going to fold their BB for the extra 5 so i dont really think it tightens down the game IMO.
This is short sighted thinking. Many players flock to these games but because they don't adjust well, they lose... when they lose they stop playing that game, or even stop visiting that room and revert to their old game that they could "beat". This is a vicious cycle in vegas, one after another the games that allow a button straddle chokes on it's own success because the player pool is not large enough to handle breaking players that quickly. Remember that when a straddle is on it increases the size of the pot by 2.33 (assuming a 1 - 1/2 blind structure and a capped 2x straddle), which in turn increases pot sized bets incrementally which requires deeper stacks to play optimally. This is why when Jeff Hwang and I created the PLO game structures at Aria we did not allow a straddle in the 1/3 game... the buyin cap and min buyin was too small to optimally compensate for a straddle where as the 2/5 and 5/10 structures can compensate because the min buyin and cap (or lack of a cap) is big enough to accomodate this concern.
Case in point, the Hard Rock used to have a "Trash Talk Tuesdays" game which was really popular for a while, all the midstakes players would show up every week. Then slowly the weaker players stopped showing up because they couldn't adjust properly to the straddle, they would lose too much too quickly compared to their respective regular games. Of course these players who stopped coming around were also the ones who requested and often promoted the game! Think about it... how many poker players do you know who are willing to say they quit a game because they don't know how to adjust properly?
Quote:
Originally Posted by GrahamCracker
The games at the Rio during WSOP were enjoyable with the button straddle going.
WSOP has a replenishable economy. Players who go bust are there for a short period of time before they return home, while new money arrives every day. Vegas isn't like this at any other tie of the year, there is not enough new money coming into the poker economy to replenish the losing players when they quit. The problem is that when the losing players quit a game, they also tend to quit a room. Wynn is trying to build a player base, not drive it away.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GrahamCracker
Its also good management is listening to new ideas and trying new things.
Wynn's new management should just look at the history of the old 1/3 NL game which played with $3 chips for example. This game was loved by the Wynn staff and the regulars because they found it easy to count pot size while using the $3 chips, but tourists and weaker players were at a great disadvantage. Over time the weaker players quit playing in this game, the market died - and the weaker players never came back to Wynn, they started playing elsewhere in locations where they lost more slowly.
Long story short:
1) Adding features to a game that give stronger players an edge, and break weaker players faster (like a button straddle) is good only for the good players, and it is bad for everyone else including the poker room. As a good player I LOVE button straddles, but as an executive in the poker business I know that this is bad for the game.
2) Button straddles and 6 max games are fine for the 5-10 and up NL players, they can generally adjust accordingly (and if they cannot then they can generally afford the hit). But they are not good for the main games of 1/2, 1/3, and 2/5 in Vegas where the player pools cannot be regenerated quickly.
3) Short handed tables = lower rake yield and higher staffing costs. Not smart for a poker room that is trying to build a player base.
PS: Why is it that Wynn is doing this at the 2/5 NL level, and not the 5/10NL + games? That makes no sense at all!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clayton
button straddle just kills the fish quicker, so i'm also of the opinion it's kinda bad.
amen brotha!