Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out

07-21-2014 , 08:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BruceZ
I think my posts make my point clear. The guy you responded to said that it would somewhere even out. You disagreed. So we'll flip 100 times, and I win if they even out somewhere in that 100. I'll win 92% of the time. In fact, on average I'll win 7 times within that 100. If you want, I'll spot you 10 tails and we'll flip up to 100,000 times. I'll win 97.5% of the time. If we flip until you lose, you'll always lose eventually unless one of us dies first.
Well I think my post makes my point clear. The terms of the game are not if AT ANY point they are even, it is if they are even at the END of some fixed number of trials. So we were in fact not talking about the same thing and it appears we don't disagree at all. Because I am not taking the bet you are offering and you are not taking the one I am offering.

Although I quoted Bugs, I was also referring to the OP's use of the term "even out" (both were posted in between my prior post, I just didn't quote them both).
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-23-2014 , 05:26 AM
I went to the doctor yesterday.

He told me "I've got good news and bad. The bad news is that nine out of ten people with your condition die. The good news is the last nine people I treated died, so you should be fine."
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-23-2014 , 10:45 AM
The good news is you should be able to make some money betting with that doctor before you die.

However, it's really good news if nine out of ten people with your condition die, because ten out of ten people without your condition die.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-23-2014 , 11:45 AM
yes if we isolate each incident and put them in a sequence it is very possible this could happen. Odds are based on infinite attempts...any finite attempts will deviate somewhat from exact odds.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-25-2014 , 06:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AaronBrown
because ten out of ten people without your condition die.
You are only basing that observation on the fact that everyone who previously died, has died. Remember, there are 6bn people on earth right now who may not die.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-25-2014 , 06:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by David Lyons
You are only basing that observation on the fact that everyone who previously died, has died. Remember, there are 6bn people on earth right now who may not die.
I'm betting on Aaron.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-26-2014 , 03:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AaronBrown
The good news is you should be able to make some money betting with that doctor before you die.

However, it's really good news if nine out of ten people with your condition die, because ten out of ten people without your condition die.
"Ha"

Nice one. I actually did audibly laugh somewhat, hence the "ha" above.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-26-2014 , 02:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by David Lyons
You are only basing that observation on the fact that everyone who previously died, has died. Remember, there are 6bn people on earth right now who may not die.
Perhaps if anyone is really stubborn and refuses to die Aaron intends to make sure that they do!
Quote:
Originally Posted by statmanhal
I'm betting on Aaron.
So am I - I wouldn't like to get on Aaron's bad side.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-26-2014 , 03:10 PM
That's like when you ask the doctor if you will be able to dance after the operation. He says sure you will be able to dance. Then you say great because I can't dance now.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-31-2014 , 12:35 PM
No human being alive today will live forever regardless of advancements because forever is as long as universe allows you and this is still finite time plus realistically even if you could extend past 115 easily we are far from full control of biological regeneration of everything including brain cells and you still would have had accidents as possibilities eventually.

It is however possible in the next 100 years not only to extend lifespan of anyone that is selected for this to over 200 years but to finally have a way to travel close to the speed of light with some amazing technology that exploits vacuum energy or something entirely creative like that which doesnt tax local resources to insane levels, enabling time travel forward that could be millions of years.

Oh what a paradox this is really for future. I mean nomatter what technology we create we could still do better soon thereafter so any such trip is still at the mercy of the others left behind to even stop it at some point lol...or alter its ...future.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
07-31-2014 , 01:42 PM
Wow!

From a simple coin toss to biological regeneration to time travel to immortality.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-01-2014 , 12:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by statmanhal
Wow!

From a simple coin toss to biological regeneration to time travel to immortality.
Right! Next comes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-01-2014 , 02:45 PM
Dooomsday Argument - "There is a 95% chance of extinction within 9,120 years."

That's not going to bother me as I only plan to live for another 9,100 years.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-02-2014 , 10:56 AM
The side facing up during a coin toss has a 2% advantage. It's not 50/50.

In any case instances of probability are based on incredibly large sample sizes. So as n -iterations approach infinity AA will hold up ~80%. But infinity is a long time coming...
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chaotix
In any case instances of probability are based on incredibly large sample sizes. So as n -iterations approach infinity AA will hold up ~80%.
No, it doesn't take a large sample for your example to converge to expectation. With just 2300 trials, the chance for an 80% event to happen less than 78% or more than 82%, is less than 1% of the time.

With 4000 trials the chance is less than 1/10th of 1%. With 5750 trials the chance is less than 1/100th of 1%. With 7500 trials the chance is less than 1/1000th of 1%. It converges pretty rapidly.

This doesn't change the point I made in post #20 however, in answering the title question with No.

Last edited by NewOldGuy; 08-02-2014 at 12:27 PM.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:35 PM
It converges pretty rapidly to within 2%. It doesn't converge very rapidly to within 0.5% or to within 0.1%. The convergence for a given probability slows down with the square of how close you want it. For 0.5%, it takes 57600 for 3 standard deviations (0.27%). For 0.1%, it takes 1.44 million. The number n you need for a given number of standard deviations s and accuracy a when your chance of winning is p is

n = p*(1-p)*(s/a)^2.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-02-2014 , 05:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BruceZ
It converges pretty rapidly to within 2%. It doesn't converge very rapidly to within 0.5% or to within 0.1%. The convergence for a given probability slows down with the square of how close you want it. For 0.5%, it takes 57600 for 3 standard deviations (0.27%). For 0.1%, it takes 1.44 million. The number n you need for a given number of standard deviations s and accuracy a when your chance of winning is p is

n = p*(1-p)*(s/a)^2.
I simply did the below. I don't see anything wrong. It's the chance to get at most 78% (or at least 82%) on an 80% event.

binomdist(2300,.78*2300,.80,true) = .9%
binomdist(4000,.78*4000,.80,true) = .09%
binomdist(5750,.78*5750,.80,true) = .009%
binomdist(7600,.78*7600,.80,true) = .0009%

Last edited by NewOldGuy; 08-02-2014 at 06:03 PM.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-02-2014 , 07:45 PM
I was talking about getting 79.5% to 80.5% or 79.9% to 80.1%.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-03-2014 , 01:13 AM
Understood, thanks.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
08-04-2014 , 03:07 AM
Try this exercise for study. After a number of n flips how many visits to the origin do you expect (avg)? That will illuminate the process. In 3 dimensions its not even a given that it will happen eventually (eg random walk +-1 in each axis). In 2 and 1 it will eventually.
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote
10-08-2014 , 03:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shovingrivers
Well I'm not sure, but I don't understand why it has to even out, why cant one of the two keep out flipping the other even over a big sample.
. It could if something acted on the coin otherwise there is no potiental
fliiping a coin and variance does it really even out Quote

      
m