Quote:
Originally Posted by TheRyno
This just happened last night. JJ in the SB limps around and I raise it to 15(1/2 table). One caller and flop comes out 88J. I bet $20 villian calls. Next card a 7. I bet $30 not wanting to scare him away, he min raises to $60 and I pause for around 30 seconds before shoving.
This is where it got interesting. He asks me "do you have J8" and I replied that there would be no way I'd be in the pot let alone raise with J8. He then asked if I had a straight. I told him maybe and that it was a scary board. After some hemming and hawing he decided to call and flipped over A8.
After the hand was over I was talking to the guy to my right and he said to me unprovoked that he thinks that I got him to call by telling him it was a scary board. Don't know that's the case but made me think of this thread and I wanted to share it.
If your opponent was a good player, you would have given him every reason in the world to fold. I'll tell you why:
Weak-hand statements from a bettor make strong hands more likely. Bluffers or players betting vulnerable hands don't want to remove strong hands from their range. When you remove J8 from your range, that is a weak-hand statement. A bluffer would have no incentive to do that.
Your response to 'do you have a straight' is 'maybe', so pretty neutral; I don't have too much opinion on that. I could see you doing that with both strong and weak hands (as it's a pretty ambiguous statement, as most during-hand statements are).
I also don't have too much opinion on 'it's a scary board.' I could see you saying that with strong or weak hands, either to intimidate him, or to point out that you might not bet with some strong hands, as it's a scary board.
But removing J8 from your range is very, very telling and I almost always fold if someone tells me something like that (assuming I peg them as an average, recreational player and not a good player who views me as good and is trying to level me.)