My 'regular' dealer's choice game this week. We're playing 5 card stud, with a common and a replace. Hi-low, no qualifier.
With 4 players left, the dealer replaces the cards correctly (face-up or face-down) for players A, B & C. Dealer mistakenly pitches D his card face-up, when it was supposed to be face-down.
How do you rule?
Relevant RROP rules in spoiler.
Questions welcome, I'll let you know how we proceeded later.