Quote:
Originally Posted by HastenDan
As everyone knows, white supremacist president of the 'National Policy Institute' and overall human scumbag Richard Spencer was sucker-punched by a masked assailant in public the other day.
This was celebrated and meme-ified, and there has been discussion of "is it right to punch a nazi" with, what seems to me at least, a general consensus among many democrats that Yes, punching a white supremacist / neo-nazi is justified and to be celebrated.
While I find Richard Spencer an absolutely vile human being, worthy of any and all derision and protest, at the same time my overall position of physical violence against another human being that is not engaged in physical violence is not justified.
Legally, he was criminally assaulted. The fact it was a sucker-punch by a masked person who then ran away makes the act even more cowardly.
When I was in college there were two crazy people that would appear on campus frequently, one a religious zealot that was telling everyone they were going to burn in hell and another that was a white supremacist. While engaging these people and shouting them down and protesting them, it never occurred to me to physically assault them, as it is against my principles.
In your eyes, is it okay to engage in physical violence against people that engage in hate-speech and that espouse disgusting views?
If you believe that to be the case, what level of violence acceptable? And how disgusting and abhorrent do the views have to be in order to justify the violence?
Is it acceptable to spit on these people? To shove them to escalate violence? To stab them with a knife? To execute them with a firearm? There is a distinction between picking a fight and a confrontation escalating than a pure sucker-punch out of the blue on a defenseless human.
Thoughts?
Punching him was assault and should probably be prosecuted as such. Was it wise? Probably not, although likely pretty unimportant. Was it moral, no, you shouldn't assault people for speaking their political opinions, even if they are evil.
I agree with FlyWf that anti-fascism is a core liberal value, which is why I oppose fascist actions like assaulting people for their political views.
I'm not crying for Spencer though, you ask people to punch you in the face enough times and eventually someone will take you up on it.