Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
guns in the usa guns in the usa

01-15-2017 , 02:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerowo
Yes, there are ways we can get rid of the guns. No, there isn't a way we can get rid of them quickly, or completely. Neither of those are reasons not to try unless you're a pro-gun person who thinks everything has to be 100% effective or it can't be tried at all.
What gun law restrictions do you support would have had an impact on Sandy Hook, Columbine, or Virginia tech?
01-15-2017 , 02:57 PM
I've listed mine. But again, just because a proposed restriction doesn't immediately solve a problem doesn't mean it isn't worth imposing.
01-15-2017 , 03:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
It seems clear that the fundamental disconnect in the underlying assumptions makes it hard to find middle ground.
Well, one problem (among many) is that some supporters of gun rights deny the correlations between homicide/suicide and gun ownership--or they invent rules that countries can't be compared because America is a special snowflake country.
01-15-2017 , 03:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerowo
I've listed mine. But again, just because a proposed restriction doesn't immediately solve a problem doesn't mean it isn't worth imposing.
So you admit your argument has no real basis.

Got it.
01-15-2017 , 03:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerowo
Tell us more about how Sandy Hook never happened, that may be enough to get you banned again.
GTFO woman! How many times do you need to be told that you are not at all wanted here... can you not feel that negative energy? Jesus Mary & Joseph, you confused and broken mind

Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
No Sandy Truth denial.

and remember it's not a thread
Sorry, kerolols confusion is contagious

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
Grunching: The thing that I find interesting about the gun control debate is that it seems mostly fruitless because strong supporters of gun control and strong opponents of gun control base their positions in entirely different premises.

If you support gun control, you cite data on the correlations between ownership rates of guns and gun-related deaths (i.e by country, by state), and you cite successful cases where countries removed guns and reduced the prevalence of violence like Japan or Australia, and you make some kind of cost-benefit analysis of American gun laws and conclude we should have stronger gun control, because the benefits of seem to outweigh the costs, and it's hard to make a strong argument that people really need or benefit from having so many guns.

On the other hand, pro-gun advocates seem to mostly rely on purely normative arguments: gun ownership as a right. There are arguments about "good guys with guns", the value of self-defense, or the importance of an armed population to resist tyranny, but there isn't really much analysis or data to support any of those arguments, and at least in my experience those arguments are offered somewhat post-hoc. What really seems to matter is that gun ownership as a right is symbolic of American cultural identity. The second amendment isn't seen merely as some historically contingent and modifiable code, but as a self-evident justification for opposing gun control. I've lived in rural areas my entire adult life and this seems obvious just from a content analysis of pro-gun bumper stickers, but it also shows up in arguments.

It seems clear that the fundamental disconnect in the underlying assumptions makes it hard to find middle ground.

But, mostly I think it's an interesting question how guns came to have such a strong symbolic appeal and association to American (especially rural, conservative) identity. It's a question which could be explored in a lot of different ways, all of which are politically interesting, for example the role of cultural construction of identity in political discourse and the conscious use of that sort of construction as a means to achieve more material (economic) ends by gun manufacturers and their lobbying groups like the NRA.


Wot? Crowder has some pretty legit arguments against gun control.

Top 5 gun myths debunked (10 min vid)...



Wrecking Vox's/leftist gun control propaganda/deception(20 min vid)...



I know, just some dumb comedian
01-15-2017 , 03:47 PM
NQ - timeout. Please dont post in this thread or on this topic in any other thread for 24 hours.

You've managaed to make a personal attack and throw in some Sandy hook denial. Also just posting vidoes of other peoples 'arguments' do not count as content.
01-15-2017 , 04:35 PM
Who cares about gun control with an age of 3-d printing and future weapons tech right around the corner? No proposal in the US has any chance of functionally doing **** before then. People are always going to be able to main and murder each other at will- civilization works because they almost always don't, not because they can't.
01-15-2017 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wil318466
What gun law restrictions do you support would have had an impact on Sandy Hook, Columbine, or Virginia tech?
Ah. People might break them, so let's just have no laws at all. Great logic!
01-15-2017 , 07:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomCowley
Who cares about gun control with an age of 3-d printing and future weapons tech right around the corner? No proposal in the US has any chance of functionally doing **** before then. People are always going to be able to main and murder each other at will- civilization works because they almost always don't, not because they can't.
solid post, well put. Also need to guard our own culture a little in various non-gun ways.
01-15-2017 , 07:39 PM
Whose culture?
01-15-2017 , 07:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 13ball
I repeat: Sandy Hook truthers are terrible human beings.
Had no idea such a thing existed.

After googling the 2 ppl he cited, jfc you are correct the troofers are legit scum. Just completely sickening.
01-15-2017 , 07:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomCowley
Who cares about gun control with an age of 3-d printing and future weapons tech right around the corner? No proposal in the US has any chance of functionally doing **** before then. People are always going to be able to main and murder each other at will- civilization works because they almost always don't, not because they can't.
The ability to 3D print a reliable gun is still a long way off afaict.
01-15-2017 , 07:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomCowley
Who cares about gun control with an age of 3-d printing and future weapons tech right around the corner? No proposal in the US has any chance of functionally doing **** before then. People are always going to be able to main and murder each other at will- civilization works because they almost always don't, not because they can't.
So because 3D printing is a thing, we should not try to keep guns from the mentally ill? Or not try to implement universal background checks?
01-15-2017 , 10:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 13ball
So because 3D printing is a thing, we should not try to keep guns from the mentally ill? Or not try to implement universal background checks?
Not arguing against that, even though I think it's a fairly marginal benefit in the current US. The last 30 posts or whatever were about trying to actually eliminate guns.
01-16-2017 , 12:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2OutsNoProb
Ah. People might break them, so let's just have no laws at all. Great logic!
You've completely missed the point.
01-16-2017 , 12:57 AM
What value is there to this conversation of you saying he's missed the point without saying what the point actually is?
01-16-2017 , 01:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shadow throne
What are the useful things people do with guns? I am legitimately curious. I mean, I knows some small % of people that own guns hunt, but most guns aren't very useful for hunting and are never used for such. So, what are the other useful things?

FWIW, I am not a liberal. Most of the time when I post a political thought everyone starts screaming I am a Trumpist or a racist.

I am just curious what guns are useful for.
Target shooting is fun.

Home defense.

Concealed carry, which is nice if you have a business that requires you to make night deposits, or if you work late sometimes in a big city.
01-16-2017 , 01:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Original Position
Just got back from a trip in Japan, a country of 127 million people, and only 6 gun deaths in 2014.
It's also the best guess that littering the streets of Tokyo with millions of free Uzis would probably cause an uptick of 1 extra murder a year.

I've pretty much come full circle on guns, to where I know believe in the old redneck defenses of guns like "Guns don't kill people, X kills people". What's wrong with America is the culture. The maturation of the capitalist aspects have seen massive mental illness. There is a virtually unreported epidemic of mental illness, as if the whole mental state spectrum has shifted unhealthily.

As is often pointed out, there is a lot of gun ownership in Canada while they don't have anything approaching the problems we have. This is typically pointed out in a defense of guns, but I point it out to expose the real problem- American culture. Our way of life breeds stress, frustration, resentment, just about every negative attitude or feeling there is. You ****ing people are nuts.
01-16-2017 , 05:35 AM
Handguns are the problem. They're designed for hunting people

Personally i think its individual paranoia overriding basic common sense as to how to make yourself safer. Your clint eastwood fantasy will probably end in disaster and the odds of being faced with an armed criminal skyrocket if a gun costs as much as a bottle of whiskey

Since theres already millions of guns in circulation the solution is complicated but logically speaking it doesnt make sense to have a disaster of policies because the alternative is difficult
01-16-2017 , 08:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deuces McKracken
It's also the best guess that littering the streets of Tokyo with millions of free Uzis would probably cause an uptick of 1 extra murder a year.

I've pretty much come full circle on guns, to where I know believe in the old redneck defenses of guns like "Guns don't kill people, X kills people". What's wrong with America is the culture. The maturation of the capitalist aspects have seen massive mental illness. There is a virtually unreported epidemic of mental illness, as if the whole mental state spectrum has shifted unhealthily.

As is often pointed out, there is a lot of gun ownership in Canada while they don't have anything approaching the problems we have. This is typically pointed out in a defense of guns, but I point it out to expose the real problem- American culture. Our way of life breeds stress, frustration, resentment, just about every negative attitude or feeling there is. You ****ing people are nuts.
I can't believe I'm saying this, but I agree all of this.
01-16-2017 , 08:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shadow throne
What are the useful things people do with guns? I am legitimately curious. I mean, I knows some small % of people that own guns hunt, but most guns aren't very useful for hunting and are never used for such. So, what are the other useful things?

FWIW, I am not a liberal. Most of the time when I post a political thought everyone starts screaming I am a Trumpist or a racist.

I am just curious what guns are useful for.
There are multiple reasons. They are fun, they bring peace of mind, they bring a sense of safety. They also raise the chances of death astronomically, whether by suicide, accident, whatever. Also, the likelihood of actually using the gun in a successful self-defense scenario is almost laughable.

That being said, none of the above matters. It is a right for us as Americans to own them and do with them what we see fit (within the law).
01-16-2017 , 08:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deuces McKracken
It's also the best guess that littering the streets of Tokyo with millions of free Uzis would probably cause an uptick of 1 extra murder a year.

I've pretty much come full circle on guns, to where I know believe in the old redneck defenses of guns like "Guns don't kill people, X kills people". What's wrong with America is the culture. The maturation of the capitalist aspects have seen massive mental illness. There is a virtually unreported epidemic of mental illness, as if the whole mental state spectrum has shifted unhealthily.

As is often pointed out, there is a lot of gun ownership in Canada while they don't have anything approaching the problems we have. This is typically pointed out in a defense of guns, but I point it out to expose the real problem- American culture. Our way of life breeds stress, frustration, resentment, just about every negative attitude or feeling there is. You ****ing people are nuts.
Even if it's true that others wouldn't kill even if they had guns, it still makes sense to remove the guns from the hands of those who would
01-16-2017 , 10:41 AM
I don't understand why we can't just make it a mandatory sentence for anyone found with an illegal gun, or a convicted felon is found in possession of a gun. If the above happens send them away for 10-20 years. Makes me sick that our court systems are so F'd that one of the above mentioned can get out in 6 months. Make the penalty a hell of a lot stricter for people found with an illegal firearm (not registered, stolen, convicted felon). The problem is not responsible gun owners.
01-16-2017 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deuces McKracken
It's also the best guess that littering the streets of Tokyo with millions of free Uzis would probably cause an uptick of 1 extra murder a year.

I've pretty much come full circle on guns, to where I know believe in the old redneck defenses of guns like "Guns don't kill people, X kills people". What's wrong with America is the culture. The maturation of the capitalist aspects have seen massive mental illness. There is a virtually unreported epidemic of mental illness, as if the whole mental state spectrum has shifted unhealthily.

As is often pointed out, there is a lot of gun ownership in Canada while they don't have anything approaching the problems we have. This is typically pointed out in a defense of guns, but I point it out to expose the real problem- American culture. Our way of life breeds stress, frustration, resentment, just about every negative attitude or feeling there is. You ****ing people are nuts.
+1
01-16-2017 , 01:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by juan valdez
Handguns are the problem. They're designed for hunting people

Personally i think its individual paranoia overriding basic common sense as to how to make yourself safer. Your clint eastwood fantasy will probably end in disaster and the odds of being faced with an armed criminal skyrocket if a gun costs as much as a bottle of whiskey

Since theres already millions of guns in circulation the solution is complicated but logically speaking it doesnt make sense to have a disaster of policies because the alternative is difficult
Solid post. Not that I think the US should apply the UK's standards, but fwiw over here you can own shotguns and rifles for sport/hunting, it's just pretty difficult. All anyone can really ask for is just take a step or two closer to that.

      
m