Alright, so I've never really gotten into puro, but iso PM'd me and asked me to do a writeup on a match to give some perspective of what a non-puro fan would think of it. Apparently this is a 5-star match in Meltzer's book. I guess I'll put this writeup in this thread even though the thread title tilts me.
G-1 Climax: Shibata vs. Ishii
Date: August 4, 2013
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DGDu5UqiZk
Background (copy/pasted from a PM from iso): Shibata is a former MMA fighter who just came back to NJPW in January. His shtick is that he hits really hard and destroys everybody. Ishii is a 17 year veteran who's finally gaining some popularity for being the lovable underdog who can't pull out the big victory. His shtick is that he hits really hard, sells like a god, and plays the underdog role so perfectly that the crowd is starting to root for him despite being a heel.
The Match: Okay, language barrier made me Google these guys to even know which was which, but Ishii is the Samoa Joe-shaped guy and the other one is Shibata.
The two run and collide in mid-ring, one with a high knee and the other I couldn't tell. They hammer away on each other, neither getting an advantage. Couple of corner spots, then they seemt o knock heads and both take a moment to collect themselves. As they come to blows again, Shibata doesn't seem to sell forearms at all believably.
They seem to challenge each other by each taking a knee to willingly accept a kick or chop to the chest. They take turns doing this for a bit. Yeah, again I don't like how Shibata sells these. Ishii finally seems to get the worse of the striking battle, gets staggered, and then Shibata pounds him in the corner until the ref breaks it up. At that point he goes to the opposite corner and then runs in with a sick low dropkick. Liked that spot a lot. Ishii takes a walk.
He crawls back in, but Shibata is right back on the offensive. More striking. The referee backs Shibata off while he checks on Ishii. Shibata gets Ishii back to his feet, hits a couple of chops, but off the ropes he runs into a belly-to-belly. Now it's Ishii laying in some kicks to the chest, and as Shibata gets to his feet Ishii connects on a spinning heel kick. Pulls him back up for a clothesline, attempts the pin but only gets two.
Ishii leaves Shibata sitting, tries to lay in a kick off a running start but Shibata catches his leg, gets up, and pulls him through a vicious short clothesline. After gathering himself for a moment, he locks in a Boston crab. I wonder if they call it a Boston crab in Japan. Ishii gets a rope break, but as soon as the break happens Shibata pulls him away and locks in an STF. Ishii musters enough adrenaline to force another rope break.
Shibata pulls him back to his feet, executes a release German suplex, Ishii 100% no-sells it, hits own release German, Shibata no-sells that, but Ishii turns around and levels him with a clothesline. WTF, why were they no-selling those suplexes? Both slowly make their way back to their feet and get into another striking contest. Again Shibata comes out on top, but Ishii gets back up quickly, hammers a big clothesline, then tries to quickly capitalize with a pin but can only get two.
Another striking exchange, Ishii seems to win it when he substitutes a headbutt instead of a forearm, but as he tries to lock in a suplex attempt, Shibata slips out and delibers a headbutt of his own. Both men down, slowly back to their feet. Shibata is able to apply a reverse chinlock that Ishii succeeds in making look legit painful. He manages a rope break. Shibata kicks at him, Ishii counters with an enziguiri, another complete no-sell that I don't understand, back and forth with a couple of moves with neither guy selling. Ishii hits a clothesline for a near-fall, then hits a brainbuster that finally gets the three-count.
Result: Ishii via pinfall (12:18)
Thoughts:
*Ishii impressed me far more than Shibata did. Thought he was a way better seller and easily matched Shibata's offensive abilities.
*The no-selling in a couple of spots really made no sense to me and I didn't like it.
*The pace was excellent and certainly made the whole thing watchable at the very least, and I would call it good.
*The striking sequences were fine but not exactly my thing, would have been happy to only see one or two of those rather than seemingly having them as a focal point.
*All in all, as an outsider with no context outside of that which iso gave me, I can't see the five stars this match got, but I would solidly give it something like 3.25 or 3.5 stars out of 5.