Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
WBM All-time Match Draft WBM All-time Match Draft

02-15-2012 , 11:31 PM
Not a huge fan of going through two rounds without having any good wrestling involved yet, but Trevor's card would still be one of the most memorable of all time.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-15-2012 , 11:37 PM
The thing is - I haven't used up really any of the great technical wrestlers. Flair, Bret, HBK, Steamboat, Angle, Benoit, etc are still out there - and there are many, many, many great matches available. I can piece in great wrestling around a couple of big moments. I don't think that there are nearly as many big moments for others to piece around their great wrestling - and I think a mix of the two makes a great card.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-15-2012 , 11:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trevorwc
The thing is - I haven't used up really any of the great technical wrestlers. Flair, Bret, HBK, Steamboat, Angle, Benoit, etc are still out there - and there are many, many, many great matches available. I can piece in great wrestling around a couple of big moments. I don't think that there are nearly as many big moments for others to piece around their great wrestling - and I think a mix of the two makes a great card.
I, for one, very much like the thinking here (as sort of evidenced by our own card as well).
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-15-2012 , 11:52 PM
lolol ffffuuuu


my picks at the flip were going to be taker vs manking and guerrero vs mysterio.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 12:41 AM
I just want to say great idea LKJ I love this draft. After 2 picks I havent botched it yet like the Wrestlemania draft.

Its so hard to figure out where to pick certain matches
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 12:57 AM
Thanks, glad people are enjoying. It is really damn tough to value matches, especially with some of the left field (though not necessarily bad) picks so far. There are matches on my board that I feel could be on nobody else's radar and I can wait until the 5th round on them, but then I'm not going to be mortally shocked if they leave the board on the next pick.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 12:59 AM
I have a tough decision. i have an epic pick but idk if I can find footage so that is going to kill me and I have no clue how long it is
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 01:21 AM
I'll echo the appreciation for this draft; it's been a lot of fun so far. I was refreshing furiously during the peak hours for picks and even the "obvious" picks were surprises.

I think the only thing we need is a Mel Kiper-esque "Big Board" so we can ridicule the Darius Heyward-Bay-like selections.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 01:47 AM
Good pick Phill with the Unbreakable Triple Threat match. I guess I should've picked that first instead of thinking it would fall to me in the second round.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 02:30 AM
My 2nd pick;



Spoiler:

Kurt Angle vs Samoa Joe Genesis 2006
This bout had a genuine big match feel as Samoa Joe was undefeated in the 17 months he had been in TNA and Kurt had just joined from WWE and was still the best wrestler in the world, for a lot of fans this was a dream match. Their rivalry started with an awesome angle that I've linked below and I really enjoyed the match when I watched it at the time. It was a great match that had alot of people talking and showed Samoa Joe could hold his own with legends and future legends like Kurt Angle. With this pick I get a non- WWE Kurt match and one of Joe's better matches that has the added benefit of only being 12:31 long.

Joe And Kurt's first altercation;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jnpp2VFO-VA




Spoiler:
My card;
Do Fixer (Ryo Saito, Genki Horiguchi & Dragon Kid) vs Blood Generation (Masato Yoshino, Naruki Doi & CIMA) - Supercard Of Honor (20:33)
Kurt Angle vs Samoa Joe- Genesis 2006 (12:31)
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 02:40 AM
LordCC has my favorite card so far, I just can't get over how ****ing awesome that Do Fixer vs Blood Generation match is. And Joe/Angle is a great match to pair it up with.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 02:58 AM
That Angle/Joe angle when Angle arrived was one of the few times I had hopes that TNA would have an infusion of creative energy and start to grow and improve. Dashed quickly of course.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 03:01 AM
I think once the main event mafia started, it kinda went in the wrong direction.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 04:35 AM
I think TNA started moving in the wrong direction the moment Joe didn't go over in that match and certainly a long time before the MEM. The PPVs in 2005 and 2006 were awesome but since then have been pretty meh with a few exceptions imo.

Last edited by LordCC; 02-16-2012 at 04:43 AM.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 04:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordCC
My 2nd pick;



Spoiler:

Kurt Angle vs Samoa Joe Genesis 2006
This bout had a genuine big match feel as Samoa Joe was undefeated in the 17 months he had been in TNA and Kurt had just joined from WWE and was still the best wrestler in the world, for a lot of fans this was a dream match. Their rivalry started with an awesome angle that I've linked below and I really enjoyed the match when I watched it at the time. It was a great match that had alot of people talking and showed Samoa Joe could hold his own with legends and future legends like Kurt Angle. With this pick I get a non- WWE Kurt match and one of Joe's better matches that has the added benefit of only being 12:31 long.

Joe And Kurt's first altercation;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jnpp2VFO-VA




Spoiler:
My card;
Do Fixer (Ryo Saito, Genki Horiguchi & Dragon Kid) vs Blood Generation (Masato Yoshino, Naruki Doi & CIMA) - Supercard Of Honor (20:33)
Kurt Angle vs Samoa Joe- Genesis 2006 (12:31)
Tbh I've not seen this match, but I still think it's a good solid pick unseen.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 04:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pharoah00
I think once the main event mafia started, it kinda went in the wrong direction.
More or less, though that exact story was a clone of what another federation did and that was critically acclaimed so the concept I think is fine, but it dragged on to long then they pulled the plug on the payoff of the young talent going over the veterans which was the entire point.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 07:53 AM
Apologies but I just realised I haven't PM'd the next guy and I'm on my phone now, I drafted first thing this morning and it didn't even cross my mind.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 10:43 AM
Never fear, I am here.

I had my entire pick written out here and changed it at the last second. With my second round pick, I choose:



Spoiler:


The Hardy Boyz vs The Dudley Boyz vs Edge and Christian
TLC II for the WWF Tag Team Championships, WrestleMania X-Seven - 15:53

I had another match in this spot originally as I wanted a ladder match, but I somehow forgot about the match that made the multi-man ladder match such a staple of WWE events for years to come. Everything in this match is great, all three teams get to shine, and it includes my favourite wrestling bump of all time - the spear from the ladder to a hanging Jeff Hardy. It was a big step in the career of Edge, and while I really wanted a 'Rated R Superstar' singles match on my card, it was hard to pass up this value. GOAT multi man ladder match AINEC.


Spoiler:
My card:

The Undertaker vs Shawn Michaels, Streak vs Career, WrestleMania XXVI, 24:04
TLC II, WrestleMania X-Seven, 15:53
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 10:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by theginger45
GOAT multi man ladder match AINEC.
A single-man ladder match would be pretty boring, if you ask me.

Good pick.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 11:30 AM
How long was Angle in tna before that match with Samoa Joe? Tna booking makes my head hurt.
It might be unfair to tna, but having matches with a 4 sided and a 6 sided ring on the same card seems awkward.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 11:35 AM
Pretty sure they hotshotted the Angle/Joe series as soon as Angle got there.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 12:15 PM
Yes, iirc Angle debuted, cut a promo, Joe walked out, Angle headbutted him, they fought, then they did that match at the next ppv, but its been ages since ive looked it up.

Edit, looked it up, he debuted, they fought pretty much as i said, then Angle was a guest ref at the next PPV then they had him end Joe's long unbroken win streak at the PPV after that.

Ignoring the quality of the match (as ive said ive not had chance to watch it) the booking is terrible, they should be doing a no contest finish like a double DQ or a time limit draw, then have Angle go over if they really have to push him that hard (tbh id have Joe take the first win then have Angle end the streak after then keep the feud simmering in the background for months).
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 02:05 PM
Pharoah, I dunno if you were PM'd, but you're on the clock and you've got about 2.5 hours to make a pick.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 04:20 PM
Moorobot, you'll be up within a half hour.

Also Hempy is out of town and requested to be skipped until he returns on Monday, so we won't bother running the clock out on him when he has already pressed "sit out." Disko, you're up for two picks in a row when it's your turn. This remains true until Hempy sits back in and starts making picks to catch up.
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote
02-16-2012 , 04:52 PM
My 2nd pick:



Spoiler:
In the most watched match in U.S. wrestling history


vs.

Spoiler:


Spoiler:
Andre vs. Hogan, WWF title, from the Main Event 1988. This match had over 33 million live viewers; a 15.2 rating.

Hogan’s 4 year run as WWF champion comes to an end here, an epic moment for ‘casual fans’ if not for us. A great showmanship/drama/entertainment match, not a great technical match obviously. The crowd is very hot. It’s a short match. But all of this is just the icing; the main reason for taking this match is unreal drawing power.

9:07 bell to bell.

Here is a great quality version that looks like a DVD release:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=ITDMD3P6T9w#t=11m46s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bv4pRhQTW04

Last edited by moorobot; 02-16-2012 at 05:03 PM. Reason: Original version of the match was messed up
WBM All-time Match Draft Quote

      
m