Quote:
Originally Posted by jpsychlady
Yes, I think everyone who has played at twin river is aware of the fact that they have rules that are non standard .....the no talking heads up, no showing cards heads up, no exchanging of chips for cash, the list goes on. I think the bb should have spoken up sooner and I don't remember exactly when he did speak up but I do feel like if you paid for a hand that you should get one and the ruling should never be that you can play with 1 card. Everywhere the ruling is that you have to show two cards to win the hand so I don't even know how that would play out if the bb had played with one card and then made a hand. Top pair? What would his kicker be?
Like Googenheim said, if the rule is it's a misdeal, then all the blind has to do is see a weak hand, get rid of a card (by palming it, tossing it under the table, whatever), and he now gets a free second chance at being dealt a better hand in the redeal.
The common rule is his hand is dead, no misdeal, he loses his big blind. That's why, even if you don't look at your cards until it is your turn, you should count your cards immediately. That way, you can speak up before there is significant action, and it will then correctly be a misdeal. Plus, because you spoke up right away, it is that much harder for you to have cheated by "losing" one of your cards as discussed above. A good card mechanic can still do it, but it's harder as there is less time available.
And it's not a bad idea for the dealer to count the deck as soon as practicable after such an incident.
Cheers, Greg Raymer (FossilMan)