Quote:
Originally Posted by FreetoplayUK
Hi all,
I am a male poker player from the UK. I have never seen this forum before so I wondered in just out of curiousity, and I am intrigued by this, the first thread that I have read.
From reading the very interesting stuff being said here, I have the following thoughts/questions:
1.) Thanks to those women who have explained how they view sexual insults/comments and how that these are related to feelings of assault and being subjected to violence. As a guy I admit that I don't fully appreciate these feelings, and I'm sure many, many guys don't either. Whilst I am a fairly relaxed, easy going guy and don't tend to get involved in any fracas at the tables, others are on a shorter fuse, and so stuff inevitably can happen against males or females. I think personally the issue of the impact of sexually related slurs/comments on female players should be brought out in the open more so it is better understood and steps should be taken to outlaw it from the game just as much as racial slurs are not tolerated. Women players should be encouraged and IMO are good for the game.
2.) Many guys, particularly younger guys, do not treat women differently these days purely on gender alone, in my experience. In live events I play I cannot recall one instance of a man insulting a woman at the tables on a gender basis, or even at all. I always imagined if that did happen other guys would stand up and say something, I know I would feel like doing so.
3.) To what extent should female players be treated differently? I mean, you could argue that in an open competition such as a poker tourney, then everyone should be subject to the same rules? But clearly as mentioned above sexually related stuff is threatening and should be outlawed. But are there any other areas where special rules should be in place? One thought I have is that whilst a woman may know whether a comment is out of order or not, guys generally are perhaps not as sensitive and can make comments without understanding the seriousness of it or potential implications. I shout a random and general "you bitch" occasionally when something doesn't go my way. There is no intention to be sexually insulting whatsoever, it really is just a turn of phrase. If I did this at a poker table, and a female player was at the table and took offence should I be thrown out of the tourney? Should my inevitable apology be acknowledged and I receive a warning? Should tone and perceived intent by the female player and others be taken into account? Do I need to be dealt with harshly and taught a lesson that this kind of language should never be acceptable - just as seriously as a racist comment?Ok, I'll leave it there - I'm sure I have other thoughts about this, but they haven't yet presented themselves with enough clarity for me to articulate them here!
I agree with this point, and I don't like where this leads at all. Who gets to decide which is the bigger insult? I rarely insult anyone, unless I know them well and it's in jest. But I go into any poker situation knowing that someone could say just about anything, and I have to be able to take it without tiliting.
Guys go for the jugular all the time, for example, more than once playing online I've got the famous "Your mom was good last night" line. On these forums, I have been told that I shouldn't be allowed on 2+2 because of religious beliefs, and because of my political preferences, all from guys as far as I know. But I never asked anyone to be banned, and never let if affect my game, and I never considered changing my posts, since none of that came from a moderator.
I might be able to blow off "Your mom was good last night", but to another guy those might be "fighting words". Where does that rank on the race/sex/whatever insult list? It is worse that Tony G. telling yelling at a nervous amateur that "I'll take all your money and your children will starve?
And, as previously mentioned, What about the word "bitch", with no sexual intent? Guys say to other guys, "you're my bitch", meaning "I own you", all the time.
I've tried to think of any insult that would be too much for me, and I can't think of one. If someone wants to say vile things about my wife (or mother, or sister, or children), my job isn't to fight with that guy. My job is to win the tournament and take that money home to my family. Period.
Last edited by Poker Clif; 03-17-2011 at 02:12 AM.
Reason: spelling