Quote:
Originally Posted by FireForEffect
I like your idea but i tweaked it once more. I'm trying to appeal to their desire to generate more tax revenue. Let me know what you think of this.
Please support legislation to license and regulate online poker in CA now before a federal ban removes this revenue option.
The next block of 20 I'm creating now will have this text but all I care about is results so fire away anytime you got something. I'm not sure how many Assembly members there are but I want to continue up until the hearing and beyond for everyone wanting to help.
I am against pushing online poker legislation as a source of government revenue, as it:
1. Opens the door to over-taxation, which would make the game unbeatable.
2. Is a red herring, as revenues will not be as robust as projected.
3. It is not the place of players to promote this reasoning as it goes against what is good for players (the higher the taxation, the worse it is for players).
In other words, government tax revenue is not actually one the reasons players want online poker legislation, so it is both unproductive and disingenuous for players to promote it that way, imo. It shouldn't be our talking point, regardless of the appeal it might have to the politicians.
As far as I'm concerned, this is no different than saying we should pass the CA legislation because it criminalizes playing on unlicensed sites, so we can throw such players in jail and seize their property. That might appeal to some of the lawmakers, but that doesn't mean we should promote it as the reason to support the legislation.
This is my litmus test: If I would prefer the legislation without such a provision, then I shouldn't promote the point of such provision as the reason to pass it. I am "pro" things like strict regulatory oversight of the sites, consumer protections, criminal penalties for cheating, open-market licensing and personal freedom of choice. Those are my talking points. I am not "pro" online poker as a government revenue source. That's how the French government views it; the game there is unbeatable, and none of the sites have yet had a profitable year.