Quote:
Originally Posted by u cnat spel
Actually, faking graphs can potentially be a very big problem. It's not very hard to change a few HHs (and suddenly your EV is going up!).
I think it will depend on the circumstances.
If someone is well known to all and shows a report where he/she is 1%+ above the criteria, I don't think we need to do a comprehensive a review.
However, in circumstances where a known poor player surprisingly qualifies, that player is going to be heavily audited - one simple preliminary check would be to look at that player's results and compare to the results from the division member's perspective.
The other point to make is that if a poor player somehow flukes it and makes the division or "cheats" to get there, it's not like they are going to be able to print money. There is going to be a massive line of sitlisters targeting that player!
Finally, as discussed previously, I agree that the consequences for cheating needs to be significant.