I think it's a little closer than others are saying.
I'd consider how I feel I stack up against the field. Here's a series of questions I ask myself at times, though admit I maybe shouldn't as it leads me to make some questionable decisions:
What's my equity vs. his range (obvious)?
Assuming hero wins, how much better are his chances of making a significant cash (top 3) with the new stack (58k vs. 33k) at the current tourney level?
Assuming hero loses, how much worse are his chances of making a significant cash with his new stack (14k vs. 33k) at the current tourney level?
I think it's a little closer than others are saying.
I'd consider how I feel I stack up against the field. Here's a series of questions I ask myself at times, though admit I maybe shouldn't as it leads me to make some questionable decisions:
What's my equity vs. his range (obvious)?
Assuming hero wins, how much better are his chances of making a significant cash (top 3) with the new stack (58k vs. 33k) at the current tourney level?
Assuming hero loses, how much worse are his chances of making a significant cash with his new stack (14k vs. 33k) at the current tourney level?
Why would he donk bet in the unlikely situation he has us beaten? To fold out AK/AQ/AJ? Why not just check and let us fire?
If you seriously consider folding HU 50bb deep with AA here, can you tell what kind of flops you would like in order not to fold to a donk bet?
I always jam flop. If he had a made hand 90% of the time he would c/c or c/r he's being pretty tricky playing like this and tip your hat to him if he has it hand takes 2/3 of your stack
villain is 15/13.
Greg do u agree with consensus?
I guess we often ahead otf, but his lead big/f range is pretty thin, we block all dumb A8-9 though he has 0 of them anyway and l/c range has ton of equity vs AA.
though I agree its weird for him to lead made hands.
Why would he donk bet in the unlikely situation he has us beaten? To fold out AK/AQ/AJ? Why not just check and let us fire?
If you seriously consider folding HU 50bb deep with AA here, can you tell what kind of flops you would like in order not to fold to a donk bet?
I'm not saying I think shoving is wrong, I just don't think it's as straight forward and clear-cut as others are advocating.
And to answer your question re: the donk bet, think about the many draw+pair hands that would have a positive coin flip against an overpair here. Would it be that unreasonable for these hands to lead? I think two pair hands would lead some portion of the time here as well, as well as sets due to the draw-heavy board.
In fact, I can see villain leading most anything that has us beat here due to fearing the check-behind by us and seeing a scare card OTT, of which there are many.