Cash game player who will play a few tournaments a year for fun.

Day 1B of Monster Stack - Level 9 - 400/800 with a 100 ante.(this is fairly soon after the dinner break and we play 10 levels and are done for the day)

My chip stack is at $24,000 and I have a fairly tight image.

Villain 1 was splashy and had approx $12,000.

Villain 2 was approx 60 years old and seemed like a total fish based on limp calling a lot of pots. Never remember him betting prior to this hand. He had approx same amount of chips as me. ($25,000).

Villain 1 makes it $1600 UTG +2, villain 2 calls 2 off the button with a $5,000 chip. I'm on the button and look down at AA. I reraise to $3,800 (should I have made it bigger?).

Villain 1 thinks for a bit, shakes his head and calls and then Villain 2 calls without much thought.

Flop is Q94

Villain 1 checks and Villain 2 immediately goes all in.

My thought is he had to have a draw over betting the pot so much. I was 99% sure he had 10J, a flush draw or combination straight/flush draw. Didn't think he would go all in with 2 pair or a set.

What do you do? Fold and wait for better spot or call?

Mod - delete this, reposted in correct place - MTT