Quote:
Originally Posted by DTLB
I figured that if I could get the pfr to fold his overs and get HU with SB that would increase my chances to win the pot.
Yes. But how often does it happen that you would have won the pot if only those overcards had folded? What is your actual gain in equity?
Quote:
I could barrel the turn and get a better hand to fold.
It's true that this could always happen. But how often does it happen? Do you really expect as a normal course of action that SB is going to donk-fold?
Quote:
Even if the pfr had an OP and called my raise, he might check back turn if I check and I'd get a free shot to overtake him otr.
All of this is possible. But possibility and probability are not the same. In any given hand, we can imagine things working out in magnificent ways for us. But that imagination doesn't mean that it's a likely outcome.
Besides, I think it's far more likely that you would end up betting the turn because J-high isn't winning this pot unimproved, and a bet-call from villain on the flop isn't a strong enough indicator that he's committed to calling on the turn. Furthermore, betting the turn sets you up to bluff the river with J-high, which is probably among the worst hands you have in this spot.
So I don't see the logic here being entirely consistent.
Quote:
Since I'm going to call flop anyways, it seemed like a worthwhile shot to try to fold out the pfr for one extra small bet and get HU IP, but I'm definitely open to dissent.
Rather than looking for dissent, I would suggest that you try looking for support. Not just vague possibilities, but to look deeply at the ranges involved and the future cards.
Here's the basic problem: Half the time, you're basically guaranteed to fail. That means half the time, you're expecting to get called (or possibly 3-bet) by better hands. I would be more concerned with getting myself isolated out of position against the guy with the narrow hand range that crushes mine instead of optimistically placing bets on that 50% chance that something good might happen when I have a hand that seems to function perfectly well multi-way.
In general, if you've got a tight player in the pot, the best play isn't to put lots of bets in while definitely behind. It think it requires too much blind optimism to believe it will work out for you.