Quote:
Originally Posted by hard2tel
How can people hate Homer's Enemy though. seriously.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jay.
Just watched Homer's Enemy to see why the split. I have no idea, great ep, laughed out loud 5 times and smiled all the way through it.
i've been trying (not very hard) to not nit up this discussion with nerdery and overanalysis, but one can only take so many comments like this.
for one, frank grimes himself isn't funny, or entertaining. his humor value comes only from homer's interactions with him. there's a comment on the homer's enemy wikipedia which says that frank grimes is like a character imported from the real world into the simpsons universe - and i think i agree with that, it's a good way of looking at frank grimes. whereas everyone in the simpsons universe finds homer's boorish, insensitive, and annoying behavior either amusing or unremarkable, frank just can't believe that he's the only 'sane' person who's actually noticing how dangerous and offensive homer is.
what frank grimes' presence amounts to is a question about how homer simpson continues to live and work in this environment, and the answer is, of course, that's it's a tv show. obviously we being citizens of the real world are supposed to find it amusing that homer simpson in this fictionalized world has gone to space and expresses skepticism when grimes hasn't - there's a lot going on here playing with reality versus fiction.
the entire episode (minus the bart subplot, which i felt was a great setup with no payoff) is an uninteresting commentary on television in general - that we are entertained and amused by someone who would be entirely unentertaining and unamusing were we to actually meet him. i don't find this kind of joke funny, i guess perhaps (given this pedantic diatribe) because i sympathize more with frank grimes than i do with homer simpson. i see why the writers think it's funny, and why you do, but i don't, and never will; this sort of episode in its complete exploration of fiction kind of destroyed homer as a sympathetic character for me, and it wasn't until the simpsons movie that they actually managed to make him almost have the attributes of a real person again.