Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn

08-01-2014 , 02:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
If Fairplay wins Pearl Islands and Parvati wins HvsV, those seasons are almost unanimously top 2



Quote:
Originally Posted by billyh66
Lol at including sugar in that category but not candice
Candice isn't hot. Amanda though.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 03:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Royale
Candice isn't hot. Amanda though.
wat

never understood the love for Amanda
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 03:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Spewtard
Tocantins is a top 10 season for me, not a top 5. My top 5 are:
HVV
FVF
China
Amazon
All-Stars
China is a good call, great season.

After two evenings of Survivor I'm now watching the final ep of All-Stars, bbl with thoughts.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 03:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SavageTilt
wat

never understood the love for Amanda
Don't look at her face
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 03:31 PM
Yeah China is a great season with a top 5/10ish performance from the winner
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 03:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by billyh66
Lol at including sugar in that category but not candice
Sugar had a 50's look about her that got me instantly in love. She's also a bit curvy, which I find really attractive. I forgot about Candice, I think she's hot too, even though I do think I rank her below the others if I forgot to mention her in the Op.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 04:49 PM
All-Stars was atrocious

I'd like to pretend it never happened
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 04:58 PM
All Stars complete

Spoiler:
Holy mother of god, that was an emo jury.

It was a pretty decent season but I wouldn't rank it near the top.

- Richard was a source of early entertainment but he was voted off
- F7 and forward would've needed Rob C or someone else willing to play hard and play for the win.
- Alicia goes down in Survivor history as one of the most annoying players ever.

- Lex was a good new acquaintance, seemed to have control over his tribe while not making himself unpopular or a target.
- Saving Amber seemed digging-a-hole-in-the-sand-to-be-able-to-stand-in-your-hut level stupid though. There was obviously an out of game relationship there having an impact on Lex decision, still seemed dumb.
- If Lex was sure he could get Tom to flip at F9 I'm sure he wouldn't have done it though, or at least I really hope that was the case.

- Rupert not being able to create a stronger relationship to his fishing buddy Tom seems like terrible play.
- Rupert or Jenna not trying to flip Tom at F5 seems terrible.
- Rob and Amber not working with Tom at F5 and instead risking rocks seems bad.

- In the end entering so many alliances seems to have cost Rob the game because ultimately he was seen as responsible when those alliances were broken.
- Saving Amber also seems like a -EV game decision as he created two mortal enemies in the jury. At least I assume Lex and the blonde voted for Amber, haven't seen the votes.
- Amber winning is quite disappointing.

The level of play was lower than I expected and level of butthurt higher. Pre-existing relationships kind of sucks, at least for me as a viewer.

I might have messed up onz names because I suck at remembering names.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 05:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KansasCT
Sugar had a 50's look about her that got me instantly in love. She's also a bit curvy, which I find really attractive.
Agree.

I think Amanda is one of those polarizing girls, but at least we can all agree her body and eyes are amazing.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 05:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Spewtard
Tocantins is a top 10 season for me, not a top 5. My top 5 are:
HVV
FVF
China
Amazon
All-Stars
I think I would just swap All Stars for Pearl Islands.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 05:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Royale
All Stars complete

Spoiler:
Holy mother of god, that was an emo jury.

It was a pretty decent season but I wouldn't rank it near the top.

- Richard was a source of early entertainment but he was voted off
- F7 and forward would've needed Rob C or someone else willing to play hard and play for the win.
- Alicia goes down in Survivor history as one of the most annoying players ever.

- Lex was a good new acquaintance, seemed to have control over his tribe while not making himself unpopular or a target.
- Saving Amber seemed digging-a-hole-in-the-sand-to-be-able-to-stand-in-your-hut level stupid though. There was obviously an out of game relationship there having an impact on Lex decision, still seemed dumb.
- If Lex was sure he could get Tom to flip at F9 I'm sure he wouldn't have done it though, or at least I really hope that was the case.

- Rupert not being able to create a stronger relationship to his fishing buddy Tom seems like terrible play.
- Rupert or Jenna not trying to flip Tom at F5 seems terrible.
- Rob and Amber not working with Tom at F5 and instead risking rocks seems bad.

- In the end entering so many alliances seems to have cost Rob the game because ultimately he was seen as responsible when those alliances were broken.
- Saving Amber also seems like a -EV game decision as he created two mortal enemies in the jury. At least I assume Lex and the blonde voted for Amber, haven't seen the votes.
- Amber winning is quite disappointing.

The level of play was lower than I expected and level of butthurt higher. Pre-existing relationships kind of sucks, at least for me as a viewer.

I might have messed up onz names because I suck at remembering names.
Here's the problem with the first all stars. Going Into the season, about 90% of the players had single or multiple alliances that we never get to see. It makes for a very weird and hard to follow season at times.

But we do get lolrupertshelter
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-01-2014 , 05:18 PM
Lolrupertshelter

What the hell was he thinking?
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:09 AM
I actually thought people liked All-Stars for some reason, but I agree that it's pretty terrible. It's legitimately the worst post-F9 season ever (though props to Boston Rob for somehow bringing the 7 dumbest and least interesting All-Stars to F8 with him), and Lex sucks.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Royale
Candice isn't hot.
I'm guessing John Cody must be more your type because Candice is hot as ****.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:14 AM
Just watched S13 like a month ago and Candice was maybe the 3rd hottest girl on her season.

Not really that hot.

And she's also boring as ****. I have her ranked as my least favorite returning player ever.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:36 AM
She was pretty much my most disliked contestant until Colton came along. I've actually done a backflip on her since BvW and her RHAP appearance. Still her Exile Island adventures is some of the best work Survivor has done. Such justice.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 03:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by K.O.S.
I actually thought people liked All-Stars for some reason, but I agree that it's pretty terrible. It's legitimately the worst post-F9 season ever (though props to Boston Rob for somehow bringing the 7 dumbest and least interesting All-Stars to F8 with him), and Lex sucks.
Haha, yeah this seems accurate.

Quote:
Originally Posted by K.O.S.
I'm guessing John Cody must be more your type because Candice is hot as ****.
She doesn't have a pretty face, especially good body or even a redeeming personality. She's a non-fat blonde though, I guess.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 03:42 AM
My only real problem with All Stars is essentially my only real problem with HvV.

The jury. Alot of the players on both seasons were awful at the game

Colby, Alicia, Rupert, Tom, etc.

But their Survivor fame seemed to have created an ego that convinced them they were actually good at the game. So when someone who IS ACTUALLY good at the game made them look like idiots (Rob on All Stars, Russell on HvV), it caused so much butthurt that the jury ensured the wrong person won both seasons, leaving a bitter taste in my mouth as a viewer. Had Rob and Russell both walked away with victories in their respective seasons, they'd be remembered as even more satisfying seasons than they already are.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 08:10 AM
Ummm. Did you just put Tom on the list of terrible players? Cause I may have to revoke your survivor watching card
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 08:12 AM
Realizing now you must have meant Big Tom and not Tom Westman. Please be more careful in your name placing going forward
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 11:13 AM
Obviously I meant Big Tom and not the guy who dominated his original season en route to victory.. I thought that didnt need clarified man lol
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 11:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Realizing now you must have meant Big Tom and not Tom Westman. Please be more careful in your name placing going forward
May the flying spaghetti monster have mercy on your soul
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:27 PM
Nope that one isn't on me. Big Tom is called Big Tom, nobody ever calls him just Tom.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:29 PM
Candice might have been a bit boring but she is miles ahead of sugar in overall likability
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:31 PM
I also meant Russell hantz instead of Russell swan so as not to confuse master anymore.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote
08-02-2014 , 12:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddBoiler
I also meant Russell hantz instead of Russell swan so as not to confuse master anymore.
Survivor Cagayan - S28 - Brains vs. Beauty vs Brawn Quote

      
m