Quote:
Originally Posted by thakidd99
the acting, character development is brilliant
thought the characterization was fairly awful tbh, most notably Sil literally playing the part of Paulie. iirc this was the point of the show where Paulie was written into prison bc Tony Sirico needed time off due to back surgery irl. think that ringleader role was made for him, not Sil, bc it basically made no sense for the latter. Sil never got that worked up about anything, whereas Paulie was Mr.Italian pride going back to early in the 1st season.
also Tony not gaf and being the voice of reason was really weird, given that he was usually 2nd in line for Mr.Italian pride. the whole thing was just really off.
i suspect it was written before Sirico scheduled his surgery, and instead of pushing the ep back, they just juggled everything around. think it would have played much better with Paulie in the Sil role. him getting super worked up about the whole thing, and then forgetting about it and going to the casino is just pure Paulie. none of it really makes sense for Sil.
and just generally, the show was rarely at its best when commenting directly on the Italian stuff.
and it's weird how standalone the ep seems to be. like bizarro Pine Barrens.