Quote:
Originally Posted by nunnehi
Those are good business decisions (Breaking Bad, potentially The Walking Dead, and basically any of AMC's "successful" original programming filling holes to bring eyeballs). Thinking that some new original show is going to hit high level status out the gate just isn't realistic (I think it's far more likely it will be a turd, but am definitely willing to be wrong).
In the case of this show, the premise is fundamentally flawed. The guy has been on death row for 19 years and is exonerated. Based on the trailer, there seems to be some chance he really did do it, but maybe the storytelling was just bad in the trailer, and it was referring to a different character. The problem is that the guy gets out, everyone still looks at him like he did it, and his life is apparently in danger (just like it's been for the last 19 years!).
In real life, if this happens, he gets an amazingly phat settlement for wrongful imprisonment and moves away to where no one ever heard of him...literally anywhere he wants. This show is just building conflict for conflict's sake. That's almost the exact definition of a weak premise. I have very little hope for this being good, and thought the trailer was weak.
My take was they are borrowing from Homeland and start the series with a did he do it/did he not do it type thing to build drama. Homeland made it work well. The actor who played Jonny Burns on Deadwood is the guy that is going to play the other suspect. That guy can probably play a creeper pretty well.
Also, I think someone who was on death row for 19 years is probably going to be pretty f'ed up and makes for a potential compelling character. I can see the jail flashbacks being interesting as well. Death row is an interesting topic.
Last, I think it's plausible that a small town guy comes home, doesn't have anywhere else to go, and doesn't leave. The small town setting is perfect for a story like this.
Admittedly, I may be fooled by marketing. There is a part of me that auto gives this the benefit of the doubt when I see "from the producers of Breaking Bad." Even "Sundance original series" puts an image of quality acting in my head.
Last edited by savant111; 03-26-2013 at 07:33 PM.